zoyamom33 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
yesterday, shaan himsself commented on shreeram that his low notes were also so clear and was excellent and gave him a 9. Understandable, since 10 is only for those that are like out of the world! OK so far
But when Aneek sang, Shann himself said that in the beginning NOTES WERE NOT IN PLACE, FEW NOTES WERE NOT IN PLACE...then how can Shaan still give him 10???
IS 10 for the out of thr world performances or for someone who misses notes as well. Even Alka said beginning was not good for Aneek
HOW CAN SHAAN GIVE ANEEK 10?
Is this not partiality, they are giving marks based on who they want to see win?

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

3.4k

Users

16

Likes

99

Frequent Posters

sajinifaby thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: zoyamom33

yesterday, shaan himsself commented on shreeram that his low notes were also so clear and was excellent and gave him a 9. Understandable, since 10 is only for those that are like out of the world! OK so far

But when Aneek sang, Shann himself said that in the beginning NOTES WERE NOT IN PLACE, FEW NOTES WERE NOT IN PLACE...then how can Shaan still give him 10???
IS 10 for the out of thr world performances or for someone who misses notes as well. Even Alka said beginning was not good for Aneek
HOW CAN SHAAN GIVE ANEEK 10?
Is this not partiality, they are giving marks based on who they want to see win?


i agree... ur rt... altho i lik aneek.. he was not fair to irfan... thts y God gave irfan highest votes.. but we lost one of the best singers for finale.. i think best 3 is.. anwesha.. irfan n aneek..
Edited by sajinifaby - 13 years ago
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: zoyamom33

yesterday, shaan himsself commented on shreeram that his low notes were also so clear and was excellent and gave him a 9. Understandable, since 10 is only for those that are like out of the world! OK so far

But when Aneek sang, Shann himself said that in the beginning NOTES WERE NOT IN PLACE, FEW NOTES WERE NOT IN PLACE...then how can Shaan still give him 10???
IS 10 for the out of thr world performances or for someone who misses notes as well. Even Alka said beginning was not good for Aneek
HOW CAN SHAAN GIVE ANEEK 10?
Is this not partiality, they are giving marks based on who they want to see win?

Oh right, well said, Shaan was so partial to Aneek, giving a superb singer like him 10 and what became of this "partiality?" Aneek is out of the show. 😆 Ok Aneek got a ten for iffy low notes and Sreeram (who i love as a singer btw) got only nine but Sreeram's still in the show so does it really matter? I guess it was Shaan's parting gift to Aneek... 😔
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
3 out of 4 judges from one region which should not be allowed in any show...Bias can kick in anytime...goes for any region..Just like all male judges or all female judges..Need all sort of flavors..
Shaan as a host was the best...As a judge he is the worst 👎🏼..Sorry I did not want to make this post but today seeing Shaan,Alka and Shantanu just made me see it..No offense..
Edited by Dabulls23 - 13 years ago
music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
😆

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

3 out of 4 judges from one region which should not be allowed in any show...Bias can kick in anytime...goes for any region..Just like all male judges or all female judges..Need all sort of flavors..

Shaan as a host was the best...As a judge he is the worst 👎🏼..Sorry I did not want to make this post but today seeing Shaan,Alka and Shantanu just made me see it..No offense..


totally agree👏

Alka came as a guest judge and seems to have parked herself permanently😆

music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
😆

Originally posted by: suresh555

He also surpassed all the sharm today when he whined about how the show will be useless if Aneek or Anwesha were to leave. A judge making such statement is unfair and insulting to other contestents. Oops, Irfan and Shreeram are not Bengali 😈


I think he whined about it on twitter too😆

A twit twittering😆😆
bellevue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

It's about time we point our fingers to ourselves, a lot of us live in the USA cry about the discrimination that takes place against us just because we happen to be muslims, Indians, dark skinned etc. May be we need to look at our selves first. When I come here how shamelessly some of us say things against certain people if they happen to be from other than our own region. Here are some examples: oh Sreeram has south Indian accent, oh just because he is a muslim, oh so and so is shameless because he is from the same region, attacking the judges because he is aging, spiked up hair etc, etc, etc. I have nothing against people supporting their own choice of candidates based on what ever, but bringing up these issues show poor state of mind. If you have problems with the judging then say it but don't bring up issues about regions, religion, age, hair, and who knows what. We are all Indians le't s try to remember that before blurting out insults to each other.

suresh555 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: musicmuse

😆


totally agree👏

Alka came as a guest judge and seems to have parked herself permanently😆



Funny, I was thinking the same thing, Athiti Tum Kab Jaoge??
dhurandarbhat thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
The more I spend time on this forum, more I am shocked with the regionalism here. And I'm a Maharashtrian, not a Bengali. I think this is against the rules of the forum.

What's the big deal? In every show the judges are shocked when good singers are eliminated. And the fact is that Aneek and Anwesha are very good singers and it would be very sad to see them leave.
bobbiswas thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
As I see, it's not to bash a judge ... it's about bashing Shaan always. kuch bhi kare usi mein sabko problem hote hein ... who ever is mentioning about his tweet, remember he supported Irfan also there, so it's more about supporting singers who sung well. i guess tomorrow when he says he likes Kishore Kumar song, some people will say ... hoga hi. bengali. it's a shame that people in todays date are also so close minded. from the begining Shaan particularly has been a target for all. first why giving less to Aneek. then why giving more to Sharib. then favoring Anwesha. then why he cut 1marks of Anwesha. then why he gave 10 to Aneek. are banda kare bhi to kya kare.

no one opened a thread that why Kikire gave 10 to Akangsha or why Alka gave 10 to her? Was she really deserving? This was classical round and not a round to sing innocently ... Baiyan Na was sort of semi-classical and no way at par with the tough songs sung by other participants...

On 3 Judge from one region, whoz the 3rd? Alka? Shez from Gujrat so would request to tell something after knowing.

I felt bad seeing from the begining how a single person is being a target from begining.

Nomoshkar!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".