You make a very intelligent point. But fans are different than judges. Of course we all have our favorites on the show and are unhappy if our singers don't get in to the finale. But, i am only speaking for myself when i say this but all i want is judges who can be impartial and judge a singer simply on how he sang, no picking favorites and, if my favorites aren't singing up to the mark then tough luck for them. There are singers on the show that i supported previously but who, in my opinion, aren't singing up to the mark and i can understand if they aren't in the finale. But i was glad Vaishali spoke up against the judges. You can't tell me that their scoring is fair or, forget fair, even consistent. As judges, they have a responsibility to be fair and make judgment calls based on a singer's merrits only. It's like saying there's a controversial court case with both sides highly polarized / divided but the judge himself or herself has to be the fair one here. There's no way everyone can be satisfied, we all feel someone or another isn't getting a fair shake but we can all agree the judges are, for lack of better phrasing, just messed up! 😆
Edited by LuckyJade - 13 years ago