Bravo Vaishali !

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

605921

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: Dabulls23
Why now and not before when other good singers were being eliminated or were not moved over to champ side and average singers were still kept on champ side?

Yes I agree she had an attitude right at the time Sharib pointed her abt holding mic...Sharib is a big mouth bad boy, why did he have to point out anything? If Vaishali wanted to make a point do it with calm and cewl manner..She herself was given pref treatment by Shaan for few episodes..how quickly we forget when we are given pref treatment and as soon as that stops we bring up all the issues..

No doubt Vaishali is a fine singer but I think this whole thing is TRP nautanky, Sanchita leaving the show is Nautanky, Sharib is paid to bring attitude and nautanky...Judges are just nimrods sitting there giving out what ever they feel like...I accept it all and just dont give a hoot abt it..

I watch the show for mere singing..I am so used to finale and winners since C-2005...It does not make any difference to me any more..

in short everything is planned 😆

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#32

Vaishali's anger was a built-up anger. We all know that judges are biast especially with passive contestants like Irfan, Rehman and Vaishali. Vaishali's previous performances (like Tere bina from Ghar) was underrated. I think the channel should have replaced the judges in the first few weeks.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

pallavi25

@pallavi25

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#33

I clapped and cheered for Vaishali when she said that judges are biased towards certain contestants! Thats been so obvious from the beginning! Shaan reacted angrily because of his guilty conscience! And that Sharib! Dont know what he thinks of himself! Telling Vaishali to sit down...like hes the Boss! 😡 Sharib doesnt belong in Champions side and he got there thru judges favoritism because channel wants them to keep him for his cheap draamebaazi! 🤢

Quote

Rani

@April2007

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: pallavi25
I clapped and cheered for Vaishali when she said that judges are biased towards certain contestants! Thats been so obvious from the beginning! Shaan reacted angrily because of his guilty conscience! And that Sharib! Dont know what he thinks of himself! Telling Vaishali to sit down...like hes the Boss! 😡 Sharib doesnt belong in Champions side and he got there thru judges favoritism because channel wants them to keep him for his cheap draamebaazi! 🤢

I also clapped and cheered for Vashali for speaking out. I think her pent up frustration came out..she was witnessing huge bias and terrible singing by some of the contestant being praised by the judges. Shaan appeared to be very guilty, his face became white, all he could mutter, how dare anybody question him, this has never been done, judges should be able to defend their decision, they are not God...Sharib with thinks he is demi god..Sharib certainly doesn't belong in champion side.

Edited by April2007 - 13 years ago

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#35

How easily the judges forget their struggle days. Maybe they will realize it again when they are no longer popular. As it is, Moitra and Savanand only do Vidhu Chopra movies and his latest Ferrari ki Sawari has Pritam. Shaan also hardly there anymore and with his fans (I used to be one) will not like him anymore after seeing his personality on the reality shows.

Quote

shanaklover1

@shanaklover1

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

#36

i am fully on viashali side. iam so proud of her that she questioned the judges. and what did she say wronge guyz. she was 110% correct. sharib is the one with attitude problem. and she was brave enough to do this while others were to coward and scared to loose their spot on this show. i love vaishali. and shann should hang his head in shame cause he knew that vaishali was correct but he just had to save him self from all this. and by the way vaishali didnt pin out a particular person. JJWS has lost a fantabulas singer and a true and self respectful girl. i hate JJWS no cause of what happened to vaishali. and i hope they are not picking on her cause of her poor background. if thats the case the JJWS should go to hell😡👎🏼😡💔

Quote

robaroo

@robaroo

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#37

Kurmure is the most annoying one. May be all lyricists are. We have seen Javed Akhtar like people doing some nonsense while judging other shows.

Shantanu had some bright moments where i felt he did justice to the seat. But again he is unpredictable. And yes many of his parineeta etc songs are copied from other songs. lol.

Shaan is like a chameleon. He suits to the present condition. May be its required for the reality shows.

But havent we bashed anu malik , himesh rishammiya , sukhwinder singh , farah khan , ismail darbar blah blah numerous times whenever a show takes place. Its all part of the reality shows. More anger from audience ... more TRP ... more successful the show.

Vaishali was right. Sharib is riding on his industry success to survive in this show.

Quote

eshi786

@eshi786

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#38

I agree. It does take a lot of guts to speak your heart out. BRAVO VAISHALI. Shaan asked, "Are you questioning our integrity?" If I was in Vaishali's shoes, I would say "YES" . But she didn't b/c it would be taking it too far for a stupid competition. Seriously, I don't get this judging and these attitudes. Somebody please explain the following:

1. Why did Shaan decide he would let Anwesha go for a week? We know she had an emergency, but I have never seen something like that before. And I am saying this despite the fact that she is one of my favorite contestants. I want to see her in grand finale.

2. Sharib is having problems with everyone. He argued with Shreeram by telling him that he never has to fight. But why would he need to fight (ie. go to challengers and comeback to champions) if he's singing good consistently. So stupid. He argued with Kirkire for no good reason. Now with Vaishali. Why would he say something ridiculous like Vaishali can't hold a mike? He should have let judges decide that. Again, a stupid reason for starting a non-sense drama. On the other hand, Vaishali just asked, "jab sharib ki awaaz fati hui thi toh use 9 kyun mile?" and Shaan jumped as if she threw a spider in his pants. Shaan should explain that to her like Shantanu (although I thought his reason was preposterous). Agar gala fata toh woh zaada khatakta hai vs. missing a sur or two (my 2 cents).

3. In addition, Shaan said, "He didn't see energy in Vaishali's performance. Really? I thought it was a power-packed performance. I not saying she deserved a 40/40. Prbly deserved a 34/40. Again underrated. Same with Nihira. She was underrated so many times.

4. Why was Sanchita creating all this drama for these past 2 or 3 episodes? She walks out and judges let her perform? She doesn't want to come on stage cuz she didn't get enough votes? Boo-hooo. Big deal. You are in a competition. Show some sportsman spirit girl.

Personally, I think Vaishali and Irfan should have been the top two today, but its whatever. As long as I see Shreeram, Anwesha, and Irfan in Grand Finale, I am happy. 😊

Also, I hate the judges of this show. Shaan should just host. He is horrible as a judge. When Swanand sings, I doubt he can pronounce any of the lyrics correctly. Shantantu is somewhat okay out of all three, but overall poor judging. Shankar and Vishal- Shekhar would have been 200 times better than these 3 idiots.

Edited by eshi786 - 13 years ago

Quote

Mirabelle

@Havaana

Trailblazer

+ 12

Posted: 13 years ago

#39

As the competition level on Jo Jeeta Wohi SuperStar 2 is getting tougher, so are the challenges faced by the contestants. This time the challengers will face mass elimination and hence it is a do or die situation for them.

The mass elimnation that will be seen in tonight's episode has obviosuly got the challengers quite worried about their fate on the show. Irfan says "I have to win back my place amongst the Champions anyhow.I will give it my all in this round as it is a do or die situation for me now." Meanwhile Shivamm who re-entered as a wild card entry says "I have been given a second chance and I intend to make the most of it. I will put in more than 100 percent in this performance."

Along with the mass elimination, there is another interesting twist. This time along with the judges scores, the champions too will give collective points to the challengers. While most took this new twist in their stride, Vaishali seemed to have other thoughts, she says "I don't think it is right for the champions to have given us scores. And if this was the new twist, then even the challengers should have been allowed to give the champions scores in order to keep things fair." This viewpoint lead to a heated argument between Vaishali and Sharib, find out why?

In the earlier epiosde, Sanchita who was up for voting scored the lowest points and is once again amongst the challengers. Will Sanchita seize this opportunity and prove herself one last time?

Edited by J.LO - 13 years ago

Quote

Woof

@Woof

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: dhurandarbhat

I thoroughly agree with the bolded point. Everyone here is fighting over who is the best. Each person's respective favorite is the best according to that person. But there is mostly a consensus over the fact that the judges are biased towards some other contestant who is not that person's favorite and biased against that person's favorite. Honestly, are any of us qualified to pass judgement over the esteemed judges' judgement? Yes, if someone like Rahat Fateh Ali, Shankar Mahadevan or someone else of their stature would comment here saying that these judges are biased it would make sense. But common people like us have no right to judge them. And after seeing so many of these reality shows, don't we realize that all this drama is created by the channel just for trp? It seems strange to me that people still get affected by all this.

I agree with almost everything you said. Except the part in red.

Sure, RFAK and Shankar Mahadevan could say that these judges are wrong but it would be unfair for them to say that these judges are biased.

Supposing I say that "Himesh Reshammiya is a better singer than Mohd Rafi".

Most people will say I am wrong. And they have the right to say I am wrong. The most musically illiterate and the most musical people all have the right to comment and say whether they think I am right or wrong. They don't need to pass any certain qualification test. Of course, any underqualified person will not be given much importance, but they still have the right to comment.

But nobody has the right to say that I am biased simply based on that statement. How dare they say I am biased? Is it not possible that I honestly believe that Himesh is better than Rafi?

My dad loves Mukesh more than Kishore Kumar. Mukesh's own grandson loves Kishore Kumar's singing more. Now, my dad might say that Mukesh's grandson's judgment is wrong. But can he say that Mukesh's grandson is biased against Mukesh? Or can the grandson say that my dad is biased in favour of Mukesh?

Just because you disagree with someone, doesn't mean they are biased. Being biased is when you dishonestly make one side win, not because you think they're better, but because you want them to win for other reasons.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Bravo Vaishali ! - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics