What is your openion on shivams Elemination?

kisi na kisi ko to jana hi hai...

While I agree that he is in general a lower caliber singer compared to most of the contestants, I thought the judges were too harsh on him yesterday. Except a couple of places I thought he sang alright. His voice is a little raw for that type of song and he still did well.

Much as I wanted Shivam to be evicted right away...coz of his high-handedness despite being a seemingly average contestant...have to say that y'day he sounded relatively better ...infact it was one of his best perf till date but obviously the esteemed judges thought otherwise 😆

He wasn't completely bad yesterday! He did sound better yesterday compared to last week. But then again this is a competition, like fairyfantasy said kisi na kisi ko to jana hi hai, guess it had to be him this time...

Sorry to say Shivam the below average singer with the head which weighs like 50 LBs, butchered my fav Rafi Saab's rendition of "Haste Zakhm" a extremely popular song..Listen to the original and see how Shivam killed it..U will know what I am talking abt..He should have never picked this song to sing...Rafi saab ke gaane gana bachchon ka khel nahi...

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Sorry to say Shivam the below average singer with the head which weight 50 LBs butchered my fav Rafi Saab's rendition of "Haste Zakhm" a extremely popular song..Listen to the original and how Shivam killed it..U will know what I am talking abt..He should have never picked this song to sing...Rafi saab ke gaane gana bachchon ka khel nahi...

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8670M15DxT4[/YOUTUBE]

i agree rafi sahab tu sahab hain un ki to yahooo main bhi wo feeling se gate the ke koi aur nhe karsakta woh

well I would never even think of comparing Shivam to the likes of a renowned maestro like Rafisaab...😆...he's not a patch on the original by a long shot...but felt that 'Tum jo mil gaye ho' was one of Shivam's comparatively better renditions on JJWS 2...sure he can't match upto the finesse for he has his limitations...but have seen him getting overrated when all he sang was a load of crap...no offence...n though his elimination was much anticipated... I still maintain that he was not all that bad y'day...to each his own I suppose...have seen the worst of him n that certainly wasn't his kal wala perf so to speak 😛

Nonny Q is not abt TJMGH being the worst of Shivam's renditions upto date...I have heard him sing bad too b4 on JJWS as well as on II...Point is he butchered the song...No one is comparing him to Rafi saab...I would not even make mistake of putting his name in the same sentence with Rafisaab...God forbid...😭

Originally posted by: Be.A.Rebel

i agree rafi sahab tu sahab hain un ki to yahooo main bhi wo feeling se gate the ke koi aur nhe karsakta woh

aur shivam is just avg or midyorker singer nothing else and too much ghorror 😆

Originally posted by: sweetelaichi

well rightly said..but tell me something what was his mentor doing all the while when he was mentoring him for the song? didnt he realise before that the song actually was a misfit to his voice?

mentor to sirf dil ko behelane ke lye hain 😆