JDJ Epi1 Review 'Meri Mummy aap ki fan hai'-DT note page 11

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

arviabhigya

@arviabhigya

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#61

Originally posted by: BeingBlunt
Because i am talking about colors Jhalak. Not the sony one. You asked the sony one and i replied instantly.
Scarlett one i didn't mention because i already explained faisal winning was better redemption for me.

As for unbiased, its your POV i am biased because i am a fan of a certain celeb and the moment you posted i know you will call me biased. At first i though i should not reply because of the usual course of actions that has been happening in last few seasons. But then i replied and surprise surprise you go on from from normal posts to generalizing.👏

agree with u completely @BeingBlunt

Quote

soumi gupta

@soumi93

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#62

Originally posted by: arviabhigya

Sorry to intrude but Colorrs's history with JDJ she's they only make their own leads win.last year it was a different story CZ almost half of them had been part of Colors shws so they made Faisal win. Colors always tampers d votes and ensures that an actor which is currently a part of a colors show wins, thus ruining the spirit of the shw. Hope they don't play d favoritism card this year. As far as Suvreen goes, she isn't a part of a daily soap for Colors so Colors really doesn't care

So what????If this is the case then Gurmeet will not win and Sanaya Dipika Radhika will have win...well I hv expected this long ago going by the HISTORY of jdj forum and its no difference this year as well

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Alohomora_

@Alohomora_

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#63

Originally posted by: BeingBlunt
Because i am talking about colors Jhalak. Not the sony one. You asked the sony one and i replied instantly.
Scarlett one i didn't mention because i already explained faisal winning was better redemption for me.

As for unbiased, its your POV i am biased because i am a fan of a certain celeb and the moment you posted i know you will call me biased. At first i though i should not reply because of the usual course of actions that has been happening in last few seasons. But then i replied and surprise surprise you go on from from normal posts to generalizing.👏

Jhalak is still JHALAK whether Sony takes it or Colors! BBC is still IN CHARGE of Dancing with Stars-India and International!Moolah from the votes goes to them as well as channel!So I don't see why you should be leaving out Sony 's FOUR seasons of Jdj in comparison to Color's Four seasons!

Colors still had a season where a pro dancer turned out a winner..Sony's never had even ONE season where a pro dancer turned out winner!

And you still didn't get my point! I said there is NO DEFINITIVE PATTERN that Colors follows! Two people who won were NON Colors contestants as opposed to 2 from Colors who mind you also had HUGE FANDOMS!(Votes and moolah from them goes to BBC and Colors ,so being from Colors or No Colors wouldn't matter) and also scored high to perfect in the finale. There is ABSOLTELY no consistency in the winners "pattern" and that's why you can't call it a pattern!😃

Faisal won coz of the criteria specified-50% votes 50% finale score,season 6 winner won coz of the exact same criteria -50% scores of finale (which she scored FULL 30 btw making it full 50% UNLIKE the one who was pitted against Faisal -blame it on her choreo's poor job) similar for season 5 and 7!So the marks to vote ratio format was same for all..Equal chances of winning..There was NO discrepency there provided your finale performance is good enough!

Well yes I did generalise ..Sounds weird when one person from the fandom tells me Faisal winning was redemption and baaki sab log think Colors was unfair and bashed the channel so much that they ultimately had to change the format itself this time..Hard to digest..Again like I said if you aren't one of those then that bit isn't for you at all..please ignore😃

And yes I believe that it is very very biased that you keep targetting just one or two celebs all the time and the history of the two fandoms just adds up to it !Why not try to pin point other seasons and their discrepencies for a change?Like an unbiased viewer would bring up ..Thats what makes a neutral viewer different from a fan..

Edited by Aguamenti - 9 years ago

Quote

arviabhigya

@arviabhigya

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#64

@Soumi93 I m not quoting CZ d post was too long and I was too lazy to edit 😆
Last year's winner for like a redemption for Colors CZ more than half of their actors were in it. If we were going by popularity if d actors Sanaya would hv won hands down. But Colors did tamper with d votes somehow to break this cycle I fallacy of making their actors win. I m not saying ki Faisal didn't deserve to win but going by d fanbase of Sanaya, there is no way Sanaya could be Runner up.
Colors likes to time and again tamper d votes so Ashish (Rangrasiya actor) won instead of Karan Tacker
All we r saying is that when Colors tries to promote their own shows or actors, it takes away from the hard work of d contestants and d contestant who is being promoted.
So even though Helly may have worked hard for the performance, for promoting her shw and for not pointing our where she could hv done better, Colors takes away d hard work of the other contestants and Helly making it seem that only Colors favorite can win

Quote

akanksha

@luvakanksha

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#65

I love Helly but yeah I agree with ur analysis to some extent, her choreographer is not good, he wasted all the opportunity he had with sanaya last year. But yeah Helly is cute and she is an ok dancer, I wish she would have got someone like puneet - Lauren's partner or tushar - sana's partner. Then may be she would have done wonders.

Arjun and Shakti both are hopeless dancers but jhalak is all about people like them. Their growth would be wonderful to watch.

Surveen was fantastic, I never watched any film or daily soap of her's, but yeah she was great.

Shantanu was great too again never watched his work but he was nice.

Salman, well I simply don't agree with his participation. I don't hate Salman but yeah I think Salman's participation is unfair. Infact I think the format of the show is non dancers becoming dancers, and dancing with proffesionals, I mean u r bringing professionals themselves as participants. I never liked Lauren's participation too. People like Shaan, sanaya, drashti, Siddharth, Vivian etc are true role models of this format.

Infact I was OK with Lauren being a judge because she is a proffesional dancer. But i don't agree with the participation of professional dancers. In season 6 Lauren got 30 almost in every performance of her's because she was perfect in dancing since she knew the art. Whereas people like Shaan, drashti, karanveer, Siddharth were non dancers and I personally love seeing growth of these non dancers. I mean for me the wow moment of the show was when sanaya got her first 30 or when drashti got it or when Shaan got it.

Salman would get a thirty and I would be like so what? That is so predictable.

Quote

Alohomora_

@Alohomora_

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#66

Originally posted by: soumi93

So what????If this is the case then Gurmeet will not win and Sanaya Dipika Radhika will have win...well I hv expected this long ago going by the HISTORY of jdj forum and its no difference this year as well

Some will conveniently forget this .. There are four seasons hosted by Colors and out of them TWO Winners arent from Colors and one is Pro dancer!Two versus Two case..so what do certain ppl mean by Colors does X thing " all the time"..lol 😆😆 Which Colors show was GC or Faisal part of?😳

Edited by Aguamenti - 9 years ago

Quote

KhattiMeeti

@KhattiMeeti

Dazzler

Posted: 9 years ago

#67

I said season 5/6 was a disaster. I should have also added 7 too. For me best dancer not winning is a disaster. Last season Best dancer won and my fav lost still it was the best season till date. Since you asked about pattern I never heard "Meri mummy aapki fan hai" dialogue for the celebs you mentioned. First time i heard it after season 6 and i dont like it at all. Its a dance show and judges should talk only about dance. And this statement sounds even more stupid to me when there is no public voting so why the talk of fanbase. 😕

Wrong AGAIN! Alia Bhatt said she and her friends were fans of Rudra and watch Rangrasiya..Jeetendra openly claimed to be a fan of Prachi Desai back in the day when she was working in Kasam se..KJo said he himself was a big fan of the kid that came in season 7 ..NOTHING was local to season 6

P.S. Not just season 7 add 8 also to the disaster list 😛 I don't see you mentioning the injustice that happened to Scarlet or Shamita for that matter..both of whom got eliminated before your fav..Like I said Mother of all Horrors-Season 8!

@, do bold, Nish do u expect her to say that season 8 was a flop even after knowing whose fan she is?😆 And regarding the season 5/6 being "flop" n season 8 being "hit" it's clearly evident from the trps n the buzz that trp janata loved season5/6 😎n season8, well you know..🤣 just because one fanbot calls it a flop doesn't make it a flop.

The injustice happened last season when shamitha and scarlet were eliminated even after getting better scores than certain someone😉 n the same undeserving candidate came to top2😆.But, no they won't mention it because it was their fav😆

And regarding the fairness, how can we expect a fairness in a show where nondancers,dancers and now even choreographers participate as contestants?If celebs have fanbase, then the choreos are well trained in dance forms , so its unfair from both the sides. Nothing is a cake walk, celebs have to work harder than the trained ones to match up to their levels n hence it can't be called unfair if a celeb wins over the trained dancer!!

And why do people find it hard to believe that Karan johar can like actresses of TV soaps?Those actors gave trp hit shows of colors, n hence they are quite popular.Or is it just the jealousy that he didn't mention certain someone's name last season?😆

P.S: If anyone gets offended with the post, feel free to report, comment and do whatever u want, but don't expect a reply from me😆

Quote

soumi gupta

@soumi93

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#68

Originally posted by: arviabhigya
@Soumi93 I m not quoting CZ d post was too long and I was too lazy to edit 😆
Last year's winner for like a redemption for Colors CZ more than half of their actors were in it. If we were going by popularity if d actors Sanaya would hv won hands down. But Colors did tamper with d votes somehow to break this cycle I fallacy of making their actors win. I m not saying ki Faisal didn't deserve to win but going by d fanbase of Sanaya, there is no way Sanaya could be Runner up.
Colors likes to time and again tamper d votes so Ashish (Rangrasiya actor) won instead of Karan Tacker
All we r saying is that when Colors tries to promote their own shows or actors, it takes away from the hard work of d contestants and d contestant who is being promoted.
So even though Helly may have worked hard for the performance, for promoting her shw and for not pointing our where she could hv done better, Colors takes away d hard work of the other contestants and Helly making it seem that only Colors favorite can win

Ur POV ofcourse and lets agree to disagree here

Quote

Alohomora_

@Alohomora_

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#69

Originally posted by: raj1992
@, do bold, Nish do u expect her to say that season 8 was a flop even after knowing whose fan she is?😆 And regarding the season 5/6 being "flop" n season 8 being "hit" it's clearly evident from the trps n the buzz that trp janata loved season5/6 😎n season8, well you know..🤣 just because one fanbot calls it a flop doesn't make it a flop.

The injustice happened last season when shamitha and scarlet were eliminated even after getting better scores than certain someone😉 n the same undeserving candidate came to top2😆.But, no they won't mention it because it was their fav😆

And regarding the fairness, how can we expect a fairness in a show where nondancers,dancers and now even choreographers participate as contestants?If celebs have fanbase, then the choreos are well trained in dance forms , so its unfair from both the sides. Nothing is a cake walk, celebs have to work harder than the trained ones to match up to their levels n hence it can't be called unfair if a celeb wins over the trained dancer!!
And why do people find it hard to believe that Karan johar can like actresses of TV soaps?Those actors gave trp hit shows of colors, n hence they are quite popular.Or is it just the jealousy that he didn't mention certain someone's name last season?😆

P.S: If anyone gets offended with the post, feel free to report, comment and do whatever u want, but don't expect a reply from me😆

Raji,I already said its a case of sour grapes..And male chauvinism too!Always females on the target..DD uske baad last time Shamita"behenji" (yeah she was called that by some people here)and Radhika !What hypocrisy when one's own fav is a female celeb who admitted that she came to finals only cz of popularity!Offcourse blankets will be drawn over such facts..Why noone ever questions the males,that's another bothering question!