All those shouting 'Cheating', have a look - Page 4

Originally posted by: Veronica.

So you want to say the format is unfair..Unfair to whom? To the trained dancers or to the untrained dancers? Just because sanaya didn't win, the format became unfair to untrained dancers! I hope you saw what happened to shakti, lauren, isha , sushant, shveta salve etc who were trained dancers and were denied the trophy because of the same reason. I hope you raised your voice even at that time:)
And I hope you saw the unfair-ness of the game when popularity was winning hands down iver talent.
Anyway.. we can't do anything about it, can we? That's how it has been since the beginning.

Originally posted by: fatssrilanka

True. I have seen Sanaya fans ego and because of this ego they have crossed all their limits. They always bash, degrade, Insult , curse and abuse other actors if they feel their favourite is being threatened. I think it's high time Sanaya herself comes out and asks her fans to stop all this nonsense.

Originally posted by: mu12

it not what we understand or not. manish him self said sanaya got most votes. about today's performance sanya and fisal have only 5 mark difference. there was a time when sanaya scored least 32 and fiasal 40 yet he come on bottom two, so how that strategy suddenly change when come to on finale . te voting were high on finale . u may tell fisal got more fans . but i don't think anyone vote 100 like a crazy fan do. especially a family . i too watched the JDJ with my family . they are not any specific favorite . my brother voted for fiasal ,
i don't have anything against him. he is good dancer. but i think then colours should not get contracted with any trained dancer if their show is about " A non dancer to Dancer " why they doing the opposite. and even the previous seasons too they want to follow the strategy .when laurin and DD were competing ..what happened ..DD won .
now i feel it better sanaya won't win because still people say not her work or her improvement got her trophy but her popularity . we watch every show if we have a attachment .people show it .its called their emotions ...ya when it cross limit not appreciable.r
but i truly believed that sanaya underscored .not because she is my favorite or anything but the way jai choreographed well and he did experiments when other most of the acts were freestyle and repeating

Originally posted by: march2011

i cross the age for fighting for actors but my vision in this kind of competition not just now but always it is unfair for not one but all of them.

Originally posted by: aviation-ca

DISCLAIMER - I am Sanaya fan & voted for her....

Thank god someone with sensible post.. I am not sure how many people on this forum are dancer or have danced in competition.. but this format is completely unfair to both dancers & non-dancers. To top it all having the 50% audience vote is even more foolish...

I don't think anyone can appreciate the amount of effort required by a novice to not only perform in front of audience but in a competition format with just couple of days to memorize the steps, add in the grace & expressions plus perform... in that sense congrats to Sanaya & Mohit.. they absolutely delivered...

To a dancer who is not only trained but has performed under pressure in competition like Faisal.. this format is unfair too because it being high schooler competing against elementary schooler.. there is minimum pressure, no need to push himself... I know his fans think that his performance was fantastic, this would only be in comparison to other novices...but for his caliber it truly was mundane... most of the time I felt he was just going through motion... he would have showcased his talent better in a more competitive format of professional dancers & unfortunately, his win will always be not at a peer level...

Then the voting segment, there were many a times that Sanaya would have been out except for the fans voting.. you could hear the exasperation in Ganesh Hedge's voice during the latter rounds & even in semi-final that whether you do good or bad, your fans vote will save you.. and finally in sarcasm when he said even the few who haven't voted for you, please vote for Sanaya... even more telling when he declared in semifinal to Faizal that you should be the winner... again this is the uneven contestant that the program is choosing...

Finally it puts the Choreographer in a bind.. while Faizal's choreo who was not even performing had the easier task to set it for two professional dancer, while Sanaya's choreo had to not only keep the dancer's limitations, but also perform with her.. so he was using her strong point of using more expression & telling of story rather than the aerobic exercises format of Faizal who was showcasing his dance moves rather than emoting a story...

Bottom line: If Sanaya had won, it would always have been because of voters... but on the other hand Faizal victory is a not a hard fought one, but with some slight of hand... once the semifinal came on and the judges comments, it was not hard to see where the outcome was headed...

Originally posted by: Veronica.

'Non dancer to dancer'? Where is it mentioned? Please enlighten me. Last I heard it was 'dancing with the stars'. Nowhere is it mentioned that the star should be a trained dancer or an untrained dancer.
And what 'strategy' are you talking about? DD won coz she recieved more votes than Lauren. Sanaya lost coz she recieved less votes than Faisal. Her popularity couldn't even win her a competition, so i guess its clear how 'popular' she is.
P.s. I know what are 'emotions'. But her fanbots should realise that even others have emotions, not just them and barbiedoll. They were bashing faisal and my post was for such people only.

Originally posted by: jalalak

i don't want to say again n again same thing when one who is not ready to understand others calibre n even thought never reply to this posts n even previously aslo i never wanted to but i had to reply bcz faisal being a only deserving contestant from every aspect was bashed so badly just bcz he is youngest among the others after being the winner one make hue n cry for the format is also like sore loser n some one calls his brilliance dance skill as aerobic exercises then what should aspect from them but one should not forget his highly emotional acts like hamari adhuri kahani n mahi teri chunariya laheryi n judges wanted him as winner itself proves how fairly he did in this competition that not only the viewers n fans of him but judges thought that he is only deserving person in true sense but i don't know few person not ready to accept it we don care for it even no one is care for it m happy that in all season of jhalak this was the most just unbiased result n faisal is winning means justice is done to the trophy