one imp reason why sanaya deserves to win!

monaya_sajan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
guys, I too agree that faizal is an awesome dancer! but isn't that the reason why he won DID? JDJ is all about a non dancer celeb turning into a dancer, and that is what SANAYA and MOHIT have achieved! Shamita comes from a south indian back ground where dancing and singing is given priority n though shilpa shetty mentions that shamita is a non dancer, it is hard to believe coz shamita has been in Bollywood as well(though not for a long time).

this competition is not for a full fledged dancer like faizal n if he wins, there is no point of JDJ. it would become DID! Faizal is as good as his choreo and his partner vaishnavi, then what has he achieved here? what has his journey been on JDJ?

I love to watch faizal perform, n I have seen the whole DID season for him, I felt proud when he moved from a chawl in Mumbai to a beautiful apartment that we saw on JDJ. But this show isn't for him. coz he has already achieved a lot!

on the other hand, Sanaya n mohit have put in efforts to put up a tough competition against faizal! I mean everyone knows where mohit n sanaya stood when they first started with the show n today they are here in the finals! granted, sanaya has a huge fandom, but the efforts she has put aren't any less!

for this reason I feel sanaya deserves to win, coz not only she has a huge fan following but her journey from a non-dancer to dancer is commendable! 😊


Guys feel free to comment or give ur opinions! 😊

Guys relax! there is no need to fight! I had in the post mentioned that faizal is an awesome dancer, no doubts about it! but according to the concept, it should be either sanaya or mohit who should win the competition! that's what I felt! in no way I wanted to defame faizal or his dancing abilities coz he is a fantastic dancer! so please don't fight or argue!
Edited by monaya_sajan - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

3.6k

Users

20

Likes

123

Frequent Posters

_Rini_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: monaya_sajan

guys, I too agree that faizal is an awesome dancer! but isn't that the reason why he won DID? JDJ is all about a non dancer celeb turning into a dancer, and that is what SANAYA and MOHIT have achieved! Shamita comes from a south indian back ground where dancing and singing is given priority n though shilpa shetty mentions that shamita is a non dancer, it is hard to believe coz shamita has been in Bollywood as well(though not for a long time).

this competition is not for a full fledged dancer like faizal n if he wins, there is no point of JDJ. it would become DID! Faizal is as good as his choreo and his partner vaishnavi, then what has he achieved here? what has his journey been on JDJ?

I love to watch faizal perform, n I have seen the whole DID season for him, I felt proud when he moved from a chawl in Mumbai to a beautiful apartment that we saw on JDJ. But this show isn't for him. coz he has already achieved a lot!

on the other hand, Sanaya n mohit have put in efforts to put up a tough competition against faizal! I mean everyone knows where mohit n sanaya stood when they first started with the show n today they are here in the finals! granted, sanaya has a huge fandom, but the efforts she has put aren't any less!

for this reason I feel sanaya deserves to win, coz not only she has a huge fan following but her journey from a non-dancer to dancer is commendable! 😊


Guys feel free to comment or give ur opinions! 😊


I always refrain from commenting on the threads which I've absolutely no interest in, but after reading you post, I felt it was less of "why sanaya needs to win" but more of "why faisal needs not to win" and that's the reason I'm commenting here.

@BOLD: May I please know that where in the rule book of Jhalak its written that dancers SHOULD not win? 😕 Why do they bring in the dancers on the show in the very first place, if they don't even stand a chance of winning? Just to raise the "STANDARD" of Jhalak? Yeah? Not making a dancer win is just the pattern that every season of Jhalak follows. Some season or other WILL definitely be the first one to break this pattern and make a contestant win on MERIT (I'm sure nobody doubts that Faisal tops that list.) And to bring that about, what better season can it be than Jhalak RELOADED, like Ganesh implied the other day.

@ITALICS: What the hell does that mean, now? 😕 Does that mean that since the other contestants have not been able to achieve as much as he has, this show is meant for them? And not for Faisal? Really? I genuinely failed to understand, please be kind enough to explain.

@UNDERLINED: What has he achieved here? Well...*sigh*
I might sound like a broken record saying this but I will proceed to say it anyway, that trophy or not, Faisal has won everyone's hearts and that feat is unparalleled.
Edited by _Rini_ - 9 years ago
_Enya_ thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: _Rini_


I always refrain from commenting on the threads which I've absolutely no interest in, but after reading you post, I felt it was less of "why sanaya needs to win" but more of "why faisal needs not to win" and that's the reason I'm commenting here.

@BOLD: May I please know that where in the rule book of Jhalak its written that dancers SHOULD not win? 😕 Why do they bring in the dancers on the show in the very first place, if they don't even stand a chance of winning? Just to raise the "STANDARD" of Jhalak? Yeah? Not making a dancer win is just the pattern that every season of Jhalak follows. Some season or other WILL definitely be the first one to break this pattern and make a contestant win on MERIT (I'm sure nobody doubts that Faisal tops that list.) And to bring that about, what better season can it be than Jhalak RELOADED, like Ganesh implied the other day.

@ITALICS: What the hell does that mean, now? 😕 Does that mean that since the other contestants have not been able to achieve as much as he has, this show is meant for them? And not for Faisal? Really? I genuinely failed to understand, please be kind enough to explain.

@UNDERLINED: What has he achieved here? Well...*sigh*
I might sound like a broken record saying this but I will proceed to say it anyway, that trophy or not, Faisal has won everyone's hearts and that feat is unparalleled.

👏👏 wow couldnt hav said it any better rini.
not.here thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: monaya_sajan

guys, I too agree that faizal is an awesome dancer! but isn't that the reason why he won DID? JDJ is all about a non dancer celeb turning into a dancer, and that is what SANAYA and MOHIT have achieved! Shamita comes from a south indian back ground where dancing and singing is given priority n though shilpa shetty mentions that shamita is a non dancer, it is hard to believe coz shamita has been in Bollywood as well(though not for a long time).



this competition is not for a full fledged dancer like faizal n if he wins, there is no point of JDJ. it would become DID! Faizal is as good as his choreo and his partner vaishnavi, then what has he achieved here? what has his journey been on JDJ?
I do not agree with this portion. If Faisal wins it would not change JDJ into DID because the contestants in DID were more equal. All were dancers who were not well known. They did not have established fandom before entering. They built it up as they went along.
In this competition Faisal came as an actor/known face. JDJ allows actors, actresses, sportsmen, rappers and dancers even if they are experienced and trained dancers. Hence he has taken part. Until the final, since it is based on votes he , as well as all the others believe they have a probability to win. Each contestant's probability is affected naturally by their popularity and how much their fans are willing to vote for them.

Every contestant had their own journey. They've achieved something. Faisal's journey for me has been him getting back into the dancer he was. He was never bad but from the coordination issue at the beginning he has come a long way.

I love to watch faizal perform, n I have seen the whole DID season for him, I felt proud when he moved from a chawl in Mumbai to a beautiful apartment that we saw on JDJ. But this show isn't for him. coz he has already achieved a lot!

on the other hand, Sanaya n mohit have put in efforts to put up a tough competition against faizal! I mean everyone knows where mohit n sanaya stood when they first started with the show n today they are here in the finals! granted, sanaya has a huge fandom, but the efforts she has put aren't any less!

Both have put in efforts, neither has put in less. They have both come a long way and achieved a lot as shown in their AVs.
Everyone has worked hard. Expectations are high on all and they did their best. I will say personally I am surprised Mohit reached the finals. That was pleasantly surprising to me.

for this reason I feel sanaya deserves to win, coz not only she has a huge fan following but her journey from a non-dancer to dancer is commendable! 😊


Guys feel free to comment or give ur opinions! 😊

DoremonLove thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: _Rini_


I always refrain from commenting on the threads which I've absolutely no interest in, but after reading you post, I felt it was less of "why sanaya needs to win" but more of "why faisal needs not to win" and that's the reason I'm commenting here.

@BOLD: May I please know that where in the rule book of Jhalak its written that dancers SHOULD not win? 😕Why do they bring in the dancers on the show in the very first place, if they don't even stand a chance of winning? Just to raise the "STANDARD" of Jhalak? Yeah? Not making a dancer win is just the pattern that every season of Jhalak follows. Some season or other WILL definitely be the first one to break this pattern and make a contestant win on MERIT (I'm sure nobody doubts that Faisal tops that list.) And to bring that about, what better season can it be than Jhalak RELOADED, like Ganesh implied the other day.

@ITALICS: What the hell does that mean, now? 😕Does that mean that since the other contestants have not been able to achieve as much as he has, this show is meant for them? And not for Faisal? Really? Igenuinely failed to understand, please be kind enough to explain.

@UNDERLINED: What has he achieved here? Well...*sigh*
I might sound like a broken record saying this but I will proceed to say it anyway, that trophy or not, Faisal has won everyone's hearts and that feat is unparalleled.

wow 👏 hands down very well said
I font get it y ppl say that just bcoz he's a dancer he shouldn't win he's a dancer still he's working very hard
I'm rooting for faisal I hope he wins breaking the stereotype of the show that only popular ones win
Paytonlee thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
JDJ is not about a non dancer turning in to a dancer. it was never said in their requirements or else they wouldnt take trained dancers into the show. the show is about celebrities dancing. If he can enter the competition then he sure as hell has equal chances like others to win. im fed up of people saying he is trained he shouldnt win. He also work hard like others every week. people have no right to say he shouldnt win. he never took the competition lightly. every week new type of performances.
"sanaya has a huge fandom, but the efforts she has put aren't any less!"

Faisal is a trained dancer, but the efforts he has put aren't any less


PD_forums thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: _Rini_


I always refrain from commenting on the threads which I've absolutely no interest in, but after reading you post, I felt it was less of "why sanaya needs to win" but more of "why faisal needs not to win" and that's the reason I'm commenting here.

@BOLD: May I please know that where in the rule book of Jhalak its written that dancers SHOULD not win? 😕 Why do they bring in the dancers on the show in the very first place, if they don't even stand a chance of winning? Just to raise the "STANDARD" of Jhalak? Yeah? Not making a dancer win is just the pattern that every season of Jhalak follows. Some season or other WILL definitely be the first one to break this pattern and make a contestant win on MERIT (I'm sure nobody doubts that Faisal tops that list.) And to bring that about, what better season can it be than Jhalak RELOADED, like Ganesh implied the other day.

@ITALICS: What the hell does that mean, now? 😕 Does that mean that since the other contestants have not been able to achieve as much as he has, this show is meant for them? And not for Faisal? Really? I genuinely failed to understand, please be kind enough to explain.

@UNDERLINED: What has he achieved here? Well...*sigh*
I might sound like a broken record saying this but I will proceed to say it anyway, that trophy or not, Faisal has won everyone's hearts and that feat is unparalleled.


well said 👏

i donot know from where this point of dancer and non dancer came into JDJ (not sure from which season this thing started)... but judges or anyone from JDJ show of this season didnot mention that dancer or non dancer thing... they just mentioned child artist never won thats all...

I always said the same my personal fav is shamita but i would love if faisal wins ... as both are fab dancers for me ...

and i seriously want this non-dancer to dancer thing stops with this seasons and gives equal opportunity to dancers who comes to JDJ
.DivaDeluxe. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
I agree that Faisal's acts have been amazing and he sure is a hella talented dancer! but has he really shown a growth as immense as Sanaya's? Looking back,even his very first performance on JDJ was fabulous! Whereas Sanaya's first performance was almost "bad", but look at her now! She has improved SOOO much! but Faisal's growth from epi1 to now isn't that great tbh xD His concepts are always epic, no doubt, but the credit for that goes to his choreo Vivek...not Faisal himself.
Sanaya has done so many different dance forms too, I actually don't think she's done the same form twice...
Despite the choreography not being top notch every week, Sanaya has shown growth continuelly, ever since JDJ started. Even Shahid himself said that after watching her first performance he never would have thought that she would make it to the finals (because it was that bad) - BUT the growth she has shown makes her spot in the finals very well deserving!!

So YES, Sanaya does deserve to win JDJ. & Hopefully she will! 👏
Edited by .DivaDeluxe. - 9 years ago
kuchnaakahoo thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Despite me being a Sanaya fan, i disagree with u completely.. JDJ was never about a non dancer 's journey transforming into a dancer.., Dont know y ppl hav this impression.. I wonder who started with this myth that trained dancers are only brought to raise the standards of the show.,
Lauren n other trained dancers never won it because of lack of popularity n this is just not the case with Faisal.. He is a very splendid n a popular actor , if u hav ever come across with his show.. He was FAB.. there is a life outside IF too.. n ppl love him a lot..

Somewhere in my heart i m still wishing Sanaya to win bcoz she has this misconception tht she can never win any thing.. ,, i m sure she is getting humongous votes.. But if at all Faisal wins, i for one do not think that it would be unfair to Sanaya...
I know many Sanaya fans will not like this opinion but Jai is a huge huge let down choreography wise.. Except for Khuda Jaane n Baby doll i never found any wow factor in his choreography.. For me it has always been Sanaya's charm n her expressions which hav worked in her favour.. her performances this week were good but the choreography was still very simple, I am still hoping for Jai to come up with something flabbergasting in the finale..

Lets see who wins..
Edited by TheSmurfs - 9 years ago
947708 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
I disagree it's not solely her all of them putting on there best equally efforts to give there best .
As much we have seen sanaya she isn't bad but not that great jai has failed to deliver consistent performance ( Charlie / shadow act was cool rest all it was average acts they got lot of time he could have pushed her further )
I feel Faisal / mohit should win .
It's only a view I am sharing no need to fight with me .
Dances of Faisal and mohit were innovative .
Edited by rs.shailu29 - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".