Whose waltz was better?

Sanaya's in week 2 or shamita's this week?

I liked Shamitas better
Her moves were graceful and poetic

I guess comparing Sanaya's performance that week with Shamita's performance this week doesn't make any sense at all because clearly it was Sanaya's only second week in Jhalak and she had not fully recovered. Therefore taking into account she is a non dancer, her performance was credible enough for that day, for that scenario and had Sanaya done that Waltz this week she would have surely done it much better with all those dainty and highly technical stuff nitpickers look for.

Shamita's waltz should have been even more better since she is a Bollywood actress and therefore surely she must have received respectable tutoring in dance.

And I don't know why but I even liked Irfan Pathan's performance. It had a nice rawness to it and frankly speaking the audience isn't bothered at all with all those little technicalities. Many a times simple rustic performances are much adored and appreciated. It's a complex world as it is, a dash of simplicity is sorely needed. And that's the reason I think I like Sanaya's performances even though they may not be the best technically. Her performances are just the right taste. They are simple, they are graceful and they are thankfully never over the top.

Shamita's waltz was better she was more graceful

Shamita was better. She has the grace in her. 😳

Shamita's waltz was better, she was graceful and her postures are correct.

Shamita's was way better than Si ... Her postures were good n it was clean n graceful ... It's not necessary tht she's a bollywood actress so she must b well tutored cuz in tht case Si must be well trained too cuz tv actors always perform on award show n other events more than a Bollywood actors

Shamita was better cuz she was graceful & flawless

Sanaya was recovering .We. all know she is most graceful. The judges comments on her waltz would naturally be taken into account by any other dancer performing waltz the next and make sure they work on her errors

In expressions and feel,Sanaya s was much better.Technically may be shamita was good but we should not forget that Sanaya did it on second week and when she recovered from rib injury.Shamita must have kept in mind the technical advises of judges given to Sanaya.moreover,Sanaya reminded me of fairytales 😳