grand finale!! comment - Page 4

Originally posted by: roadies_4 fan

hi. when you disagree...thats what i meant....good dancing doesnt win the show, its also grace, attitude, and personality...i like prachi when she made the comment to shamiek that she wont wear any more revealing clothes than this. Shamiek commenting on her costume was really rude. Is it neccessary to show your half naked body to get good marks??? Thats when prachi won for me. As are as peoples comments about sony and ekta and what not...i dont care. Its not about the melodrama behind the scenes...its about how you show yourself on stage infront of billions of viewers. The comments about sandiya should have been aired on the news or some entertainment shows, which they have a lot of. And how do any of us know that the wildcard was only created for prachi. Indian idol has it too. its only the second time they did the show, maybe they wanted to change the format if they wanted, if they did it for idol, then why cant they do it for this show. The topics point is not to support any one of the contestants, its all about how they presented themselves as good sports. i would have respected sandiya lots more if she really had some grace and compasion for the winner. My favorite in the show was neither of them actually, i loved Negi gi. he won my heart over so many times. His grace, affection, and love, and neutrality brought him to the top 4.

Despite being the best dancer in the show Sandhya lost, so it is very natural that everyone's sympathy in the show will go to Sandhya(we have to remember that this was a dance show and not attitute/personality,..etc..we also cannot judge anyone's attitue or personality until we know them..we only knows what channel shows..)..I am not a fan of Sandhya nor Prachi..but yes Sandhya was better dancer than Prachi and Prachi also knew and said that. But unlike Mona(as she did with shevta) she never asked Sandhya to come and hold the trophy atleast..I really liked Mona's behaviour when she won than Prachi..and I don't find anyone's attitude wrong against prachi..they did go and congratulate Prachi, what else do you guys need..

Originally posted by: malak

Prachi very much deserved the treatment she got.

At last the other contestants were free to express their real emotions and we all got to see those.

Just like us viewers they all knew the fact that Sony was going to put the trophy and the 50 lacs in Prachi's begging bowl - it was a no brainer. Hat's off to Sandhya and Jay for giving their best even though in ther hearts they were very well aware of this eventuality.

India is a free country and the participants have every right to express their feelings and emotions. I am with them 100%.

Hope Sony learns a lesson from this circus show and does not insult the partcipants and judges in JDJ 3 - if it decides to have one. Would love to see BBC pulling the plug from Sony as regards this show.

Malak, I will agree that the Wild Card was not fair. However, the wild card was a decision by the channel and Synergy which is simply not Prachi's problem. If people have an issue with the introduction of the Wild Card, they should have taken it up with Sony and Synergy. Rightly or wrongly, to vent their frustration out on Prachi is simply not justified. No one is saying go gaga over her and be pally pally with her but at the same time it was unnecessary and highly rude to snub her in the manner the contestants (with the exception of Jay, Mika and Negi Sir) and the "judges" did. No one deserves to be greeted with such behavior, young or old. On another note, if the judges really felt that Sandya was the "best" they should have expressed that more clearly when assigning marks. In the Grand Finale, Prachi lagged one point behind the "best" and previously only lagged at most 2-3 points. Clearly, according to the judges, the "best" wasn't really that far ahead.
I always thought judges were rightly or wrongly supposed to be impartial and unbias. That being said, I only saw all three judges being highly biased when the winner was annonced. Not one of them congratulated the winner which was pitiful having held the position of a "judge." I don't count a half hearted congratulations 20 minutes later as a "congratulation"---fair or not fair.

Originally posted by: pingme

Despite being the best dancer in the show Sandhya lost, so it is very natural that everyone's sympathy in the show will go to Sandhya(we have to remember that this was a dance show and not attitute/personality,..etc..we also cannot judge anyone's attitue or personality until we know them..we only knows what channel shows..)..I am not a fan of Sandhya nor Prachi..but yes Sandhya was better dancer than Prachi and Prachi also knew and said that. But unlike Mona(as she did with shevta) she never asked Sandhya to come and hold the trophy atleast..I really liked Mona's behaviour when she won than Prachi..and I don't find anyone's attitude wrong against prachi..they did go and congratulate Prachi, what else do you guys need..

Pingme, can you please elaborate how Sandhya was the "best" per the judges marks? If I'm not mistaken, she was ahead by one point in the Grand Finale and previously Prachi only lagged at the most 2-3 points behind her. If they judges really felt she was the best, they should have showed same in their marks.

After watching JDJ finale tonight I am totally disgusted and disappointed in all 3 judges and Mona as hostess's behaviour. What Urmila did and said was totally unthinkable. Sony had no decency in giving Prachi the winner any TV time. It was totally unprofessional behaviour on judges part.

If this had happened in US on reality show Prachi could have sued JDJ and SOny's A** for discrimination and unprofessional behavior on judges part. Judges are supposed to be unbiased and not play favorites between contestants.

I am not Prachi fan but she showed alot more class than judges, host-hostes or Sandhya. Her mother had more class to say she would be happy if Sandhya or Prachi either one would win. Sonali & Jay were only co-contestants who were gracefully congratulating Prachi.

You go prachi for being a mature 19yr old handling the situation with grace, class and maturity. You not only made your parents proud but the viewers proud too.

Prachi your right attitude will take you places and long ways. God bless you!!.

My best wishes for Jay.

Sandhya can go get some counselling and help in accepting defeat gracefully. God help her too. What a sore loser they all were IMHO.

here i would like to mention 1 point ..... When the production house wanted prachi to come back she could very well refuse ...how can you guys say what is prachi's fault?

Juhi Parmar was all set to join nach baliye3 with a partner but she backed out after knowing that the co-contestants thought it was unfair. Juhi is way too good in her thinking.

Wild card entry was unfair and prachi will be known for winning by unfair means. You guys say Sandhya did not wish Prachi....but even prachi did not go to console Sandhya. I guess prachi should have gone. Mona was much humbler than prachi by allowing sweta to hold the trophy with her. Even though Mona did not win by any unfair means.

And if my friend is losing because of an unfair production rule then i would surely go and console her before talking to prachi. Mini did the same and i dont blame her.