grand finale!! comment

I dont want to offend anyone! But seriously, I hate this crap about consoling the loser and pretty much insulting the winner. its a competition and someone wins and someone loses. They did the same crap last year when mona won. Urmila just sat and shook prachi's hand and she got off stage to hug sandiya and javed and walked right past prachi. If this is what goes on in india, they they should really just stop the competition programs. The one thing i like about indian idol is no matter which one won, they always gave the standing O to the winner and had smiles on their faces. I was feeling horrible for prachi. I felt her hurt in her face. Instead of appreciating and ranting and raving about her, they just keep on appreciating sandiya. Granted sandiya was a better dancer, but dancing is not what wins the competition, is the grace, the attitude, and personality. And frankly, sandiya was always on her high horse, which is what turns people off to her. I would have respected her more if she said that i dont want to comment on this because this is prachi's time to shine. Mona doesnt even congratulate prachi until that whole 15minutes of raving about sandiya and how she is the real winner. I would have thought that mona would have a least known how it felt when she was in that position. It felt like they were 10 years old and they didnt want her to cry so they just kept on making her feel better. So sad. I had to get my point across. Best of luck to all of them...especially prachi. she has a very bright future.😉

Originally posted by: adnanFarz

I dont want to offend anyone! But seriously, I hate this crap about consoling the loser and pretty much insulting the winner. its a competition and someone wins and someone loses. They did the same crap last year when mona won. Urmila just sat and shook prachi's hand and she got off stage to hug sandiya and javed and walked right past prachi. If this is what goes on in india, they they should really just stop the competition programs. The one thing i like about indian idol is no matter which one won, they always gave the standing O to the winner and had smiles on their faces. I was feeling horrible for prachi. I felt her hurt in her face. Instead of appreciating and ranting and raving about her, they just keep on appreciating sandiya. Granted sandiya was a better dancer, but dancing is not what wins the competition, is the grace, the attitude, and personality. And frankly, sandiya was always on her high horse, which is what turns people off to her. I would have respected her more if she said that i dont want to comment on this because this is prachi's time to shine. Mona doesnt even congratulate prachi until that whole 15minutes of raving about sandiya and how she is the real winner. I would have thought that mona would have a least known how it felt when she was in that position. It felt like they were 10 years old and they didnt want her to cry so they just kept on making her feel better. So sad. I had to get my point across. Best of luck to all of them...especially prachi. she has a very bright future.😉

You said it all 👏. To them it is basically money making show and some bias judges and hostess. I have not see the finale yet but reading your post I can imagine how Prachi must have felt. Atleast Mona would have understood. When last yr Mona won over Sweta I supported that decision b/c I felt she was the most improved dancer with better attitude. I guess people change so quickly.

I will post my views once I see finale episode.

adnanFarz
These are exactly my sentiments. I was very disappointed watching same. The judges were squealing about Sandhya being the best and yet when it came to giving marks, Prachi was only one point behind Sandhya! Even in the past, as far as their judging was concerned, their marks proved that Sandhya and Prachi were neck and neck. If Sandhya was the best and wayyyyyyy ahead of the other contestants, then they should have proved that when giving out their marks!

Secondly, I don't see the issue with being popular. Who people chooses to spend their hard earned money on by sending an sms is their choice and their prerogative.

And yes, one could clearly see the hurt on Prachi's face at being blantantly snubbed. I must say that I thought for a 19 year old, she certainly handled same with alot of grace and class. Some people would say that Jeetendra was/is biased towards Prachi yet when she won he stood there and didn't even congratulate the girl but simply talked about Sandhya. In fact, I thought Shaimak was more warm. And Urmila, does she actually believe in what she says? Why does she even compliment someone and then do a 360? Last week she was talking about how wrong it is to say that one's effort is more truer than anothers, and yet, when Prachi won, she sat there and proclaimed that Sandhya is the winner per her. Like Negi Sir said, these people are supposed to be unbiased judges and yet they were and are like the audience BIASED! They found countless flaws with Prachi and Jay but never acknowledged Sandhya's imperfect expressions. Nevertheless, it was uncalled for to hurt anyone's feelings and that was a damm shame!

Originally posted by: zerobstolerence

adnanFarz
These are exactly my sentiments. I was very disappointed watching same. The judges were squealing about Sandhya being the best and yet when it came to giving marks, Prachi was only one point behind Sandhya! Even in the past, as far as their judging was concerned, their marks proved that Sandhya and Prachi were neck and neck. If Sandhya was the best and wayyyyyyy ahead of the other contestants, then they should have proved that when giving out their marks!

Secondly, I don't see the issue with being popular. Who people chooses to spend their hard earned money on by sending an sms is their choice and their prerogative.

And yes, one could clearly see the hurt on Prachi's face at being blantantly snubbed. I must say that I thought for a 19 year old, she certainly handled same with alot of grace and class. Some people would say that Jeetendra was/is biased towards Prachi yet when she won he stood there and didn't even congratulate the girl but simply talked about Sandhya. In fact, I thought Shaimak was more warm. And Urmila, does she actually believe in what she says? Why does she even compliment someone and then do a 360? Last week she was talking about how wrong it is to say that one's effort if more truer than anothers, and yet, when Prachi won, she sat there and proclaimed that Sandhya the winner. Like Negi Sir said, these people are supposed to be unbiased judges and yet they were and are like the audience BIASED! Nevertheless, it was uncalled for to hurt anyone's feelings and that was a damm shame!

exactly what i am saying. I was mortified at the circus around sandiya and her dancing. what she putt more hours than prachi? actually, prachi worked 10 times harder because she had to prove herself when she was voted out. It is rediculous on how them anounce a winner and then dance circles around the loser so they comment and get an audiance and reaction from viewers to make money. absolute shame. i want to call Mona and give her a wake up on what she was thinking when she totally ignored prachi's victory and ranted about sandiya. The saying "best man wins" doesnt mean the "best dancer wins" its the same thing with the turtle and the hare story. You can be the best, the fastest, but that doesnt always win the race...and sandiya and sony all involved in the show should go back to kindergarten and read that story. hehe😆

i haven't even seen the whole finale yet.. even though im happy that prachi won🥳.. and i saw d ending bit online 😳😳 had to see prachi and deepak get their awards😉😉.. the part that struck me the most was.. when sandhya was consoling mini.. i thought it'd be the other way around 🤔🤔 anyway.. and mini just walked past prachi.. and went towards the bac.. d way prachi turned around..the look on her face.. i felt sooo bad for her.. i mean can ppl be more rude.. (i mean watever happened.. from my POV as a viewer.. rude rude rude..) i understand that they wanted sandhya to win as she was the better dancer and wat not.. but seriously... its prachi's moment.. prachi and deepak -- and it was just HORRIBLE.. prachi got bad treatment.. from judges.. and someee participants.. but prachi did do an amazing job in keeping her emotions intact and im happy for her 👏

🥳

Originally posted by: adnanFarz

I dont want to offend anyone! But seriously, I hate this crap about consoling the loser and pretty much insulting the winner. its a competition and someone wins and someone loses. They did the same crap last year when mona won. Urmila just sat and shook prachi's hand and she got off stage to hug sandiya and javed and walked right past prachi. If this is what goes on in india, they they should really just stop the competition programs. The one thing i like about indian idol is no matter which one won, they always gave the standing O to the winner and had smiles on their faces. I was feeling horrible for prachi. I felt her hurt in her face. Instead of appreciating and ranting and raving about her, they just keep on appreciating sandiya. Granted sandiya was a better dancer, but dancing is not what wins the competition, is the grace, the attitude, and personality. And frankly, sandiya was always on her high horse, which is what turns people off to her. I would have respected her more if she said that i dont want to comment on this because this is prachi's time to shine. Mona doesnt even congratulate prachi until that whole 15minutes of raving about sandiya and how she is the real winner. I would have thought that mona would have a least known how it felt when she was in that position. It felt like they were 10 years old and they didnt want her to cry so they just kept on making her feel better. So sad. I had to get my point across. Best of luck to all of them...especially prachi. she has a very bright future.😉

MY GOD - I was about to make a topic on this and you beat me to it 😆

I thought that it was extremely rude that everyone was busy consoling Sandhya when it was Prachi who had won. I thought that it was extremly rude and impartial of everyone to go on for a full 20 mins about how Sandhya deserved to win. At the end of the day, this is a competition and it is based on popularity, what do they expect???? Prachi has always been neck and neck with Sandhya in the scores department, so how can it come as a shock to them that she won???? I thought that Prachi took everything with grace and all the other contestants were extremely rude - no one congratulated her, except for Jay , Mika and surprisingly Sonali - and possibly Negi Ji, but could have missed him. Prachi is the youngest contestant there - everyone except for Jay is 30+ I just cannot believe that they behaved so immaturely.

I cannot believe Urmilla's comment at the end, when asked about Prachi's win, because in the very beginning of the of teh finale, she said that all of them deserved to win, she did a complete 360 and said that Sandhya was the winner for her. At least Shaimak was grown-up enough to congratulate Prachi near decently, and Jeetu Ji, someone who is meant to favour Prachi immensly, did not congratulate her properly either. That is why the judges are meant to stay as nuetral as possible. I agree that you cannot help liking someone, but you should never favour them so obviously😡. I thought that it was disgusting behavior. i hope that if ther eis a JDJ 3 that they change the judges and bring in judges that wont be biased and eat their own words, by saying one thing before and saying another thing afterwards. I thought that the best panel of judges that I have ever seen were on NB 2 - they were totally unbiased, even if they did like someone they did not let it show in their comments during teh filming of teh programme.

I have never been a fan of Sandhya's, but in all honesty she is a mature 30+ to Prachi's 19yrs, I thoiught that she did not take her loss with good spirit, especially when she proclaimed I don't care what any of you say, I am The Winner. Granted that she might (not in my opinion) have been a better dancer than Prachi, it does not mean that Prachi did not deserve to win. Sandhya spoke for a full 10 minutes about her loss and did not once congratulate Prachi. I thought that she could have been more gracious in her loss, but I didn't really expect that anyway

Coming to the other contestants, I cannot even comprehend, how Mini came running out of no where went to console Sandhya, but sis not once congratulate Prachi😕. How rude is that?

I thought everyone's behaviour totally over-shadowed Prachi's win, especially all this blatant favouritism of Sandhya. When Mona won last year, no one was happy either, even though I suppported her through out, since I thought that she was the most improved dancer. No one was happy with her win, but at least the hosts were on her side. I thought that Mona could have done the same thing for Prachi, since she knew what it was like to be the under-dog in the competition.

I was disgusted at the end of the finals and everyones behaviour - especially for mature 30+ adults, they all acted like a high-school clique turning against the out-sider.

sandhya is still the real winner and in terms of score... sandhya was ahead of prachi by quite some difference most of the time... not neck to neck.... had sandhya been voted out instead of prachi then there would have been no wildcard bullcrap... it was bought by ekta to bring her popular star back in the show...and look that also made her the winner... the competition is about dancing and other stuff comes later... sandhya has been the most consistent and deserved to win... oh well... cant do anything about the audience voting.. its evident they go by popularity status of celebrity and stuff... watever... it isnt new... happens in saregama, indian idol, etc... the undeserving always win...

This show is based on populairty and noone cares for talent. Its same in US dancing with the stars. Although They don't create any WC for contestents. Its unfair with others.

Originally posted by: superman_1

sandhya is still the real winner and in terms of score... sandhya was ahead of prachi by quite some difference most of the time... not neck to neck.... had sandhya been voted out instead of prachi then there would have been no wildcard bullcrap... it was bought by ekta to bring her popular star back in the show...and look that also made her the winner... the competition is about dancing and other stuff comes later... sandhya has been the most consistent and deserved to win... oh well... cant do anything about the audience voting.. its evident they go by popularity status of celebrity and stuff... watever... it isnt new... happens in saregama, indian idol, etc... the undeserving always win...

this topic wasnt about who won and why they won and who deserved to win...but it is about the way the winner was presented and treated as a "winner." Its not only talent, its all about your image, the maturity you show and your entertainment. Sandiya was always cocky about herself, and she surely showed that at the end of the show, when she said that she doesnt care what anyone says she is the winner of JDJ. She never even congratulated prachi. In the end its just a competition, someone wins, someone loses, but being a good loser is worth more than being a good winner. she was a sore loser and it completely showed...The show could have had her reaction to the results on any other show, but not at the time that should have been for prachi. thats all i am saying. i didnt care who won, it was well deserved either way

may I ask when did aki come in the show???? did he come right at the end........plzzzz someone iform me sooooonnnn