Originally posted by: purva
OMG.... how can people say Shveta should not win b'coz she was already a dancer and Mona bettered her way in this show to get to finals.... by that logic.... people who have great talent like dancing or singing should not be allowed to participate in any competition and if they do they should not win.... how lame is that?? Now that channel has allowed Shveta to participate in JDJ... i think people should judge everyone strictly on the basis of dance performance....
I agree Mona has improved a lot š but still so far Shveta has given better performances than Mona so I am supporting Shveta but if Mona performs better than Shveta today.... then Mona should win š but otherwise... Shveta should win... as simple as that š
see now, let me explain to you why mona fans dont like the idea of shveta winning. :you are right with your
by that logic.... people who have great talent like dancing or singing should not be allowed to participate in any competition and if they do they should not win.... how lame is that??
but you need to look at that with another perspective. see, in indian idol, fame gurukul, boogie woogie, sa re ga ma pa, its all a competition between the best dancers/singers in india, those who are pros in their fields with lots of experience, and thats why the best deserve to win, because unless they are really good, they shouldnt be competeing anyways.
the whole reason why JDJ is another type of show is because the celebrities are supossed to be UNSKILLED IN THE FIELD OF DANCE. its supossed to be different celebrities coming from different aspects of television who dont have the dance experience, coming together to learn and compete in dance. now here we have shveta, who is clearly skilled already, with a background in dance to which she admitted herself in one of the first few episodes. now is it fair to any of the other contestans? i think not.
put yourself in that position. you are in a cooking competition and you dont know the abc of cooking, you are going to spend 8 grueling weeks learning how to cook meals, and more than one on many occasions, you are trying your best, but you know from the second episode that theres no chance your going to win because the next person beside you is a dam chef. now tell me, would you still have sympathy for that chef?
you may not see it because your a shveta fan, but mona fans see it. they are seeing her extremly hard work. come on, she went from a complete nondancer and has come to be in the final two! if shveta was not in this competition, then for sure she would have won, she is the most improved dancer of them all.
as for when it comes to that since shveta is already in the competition because she was choosen by JDJ then we should vote fairly, then i dont agree with that. come on, JDJ also chose the judges, and tell me, how fair are they? completly biased judges and everyone knows that. in that case, you should have stopped us from bad talking the judges for being biased because they were choosen by JDJ.
everyone, shevta/mona fans alike put down the judges in many many posts about being biased and they shouldnt be judges, now some are techically being "hypocritical" (im sorry if i offend anyone by the use of that word, but i didnt know what else to use, my vocab is dying š) because they are saying that shevta "needs" to be voted for. in that sense, if mona fans dont appreciate the fact that she'll be out because shveta was the wrong choice for the competition, i dont think that anyone has the right to stop them from saying that.
im looking forward to watching todays competition, but i dont think that mona will be able to perform well since she lost many days when toby ran off on her. i hope she can perform to the best of her capability.
on another note, just to let you shevta fans all know that i've been very supportive of shveta and she has gotten my votes in a couple of rounds, but when i actually sat down and thought about it, i felt that she really should have gone to a more advanced competition because she realistically should not have been allowed to participate. and since then, i've been supporting mona for being able to capture my attention in all performances, improving each performance to the best of her ability, being able to take the judges criticism and work on it without breaking down under the pressure like shveta, for having wonderful costumes and for being that happy go lucky person who smiles through all the judges comments, and all the marks they giver her without falling apart. she become an amazing dancer, and she makes me respect her, and thats why, i support her.šš vote M O N A to 2525. cheers.