Debate starts now Game all team mem. play - Page 5

Originally posted by: aman123

Where are the other team members???? Soon we will have a judge at the end of the debate she will decide who will win. The judge will be not fimilar with this form.

i dnt knw i am the only one defending Mona. i think i am Mad .

This the the debate topic so you have to argue with other team members so your team could win. (but in a nice way. 😊 )

Originally posted by: sandya_rao7

i dnt knw i am the only one defending Mona. i think i am Mad .

I have updated the topic that all mem. play so hopefully more mem. will play.

Originally posted by: sandya_rao7

My god u r twisting my words i said shveta got more marks thn she deserved her dance was not that nice as to fetch her 30 marks and i gave the e.g. of tanaz her dance is the one which sld fetch 30 marks. i did not say that shveta sld not win bcoz she is not as good as tanaz? but that means u agree she is not as good as thm.and i told u i dnt wnt to argue with u but by twiting my words like this u r doing nothing but provoke me.

NO,you said that SVetha isnt as great a T-B,thus she doesnt deserve 30....Its basically wrong to compare svetha with T-B,as the concept of that show is different from the concept of this

Svetha is more sophisticated,more graceful..NB is more on drama,more on nautanki.....Thus in no way could you compare svetha to T-B....Because,here the concept is different,here the ancing style is different

You say that only T_B's performance deserves a 30,and svetha's not as good as them,so deosnt deserve a 30.....SO you're indeed comparing the two....

and I never said T-B are better than SVetha....I find Baktyaar to be hyper,and Tanaz isnt as graceful as Svetha..Now lets not bring in other shows contestants out here and compare SVetha /Mona to them....

Originally posted by: sandya_rao7

if all the other people are saying shveta is better ok their opinion i dnt care i do wht i feel is right.if they are not with her i cnt help it.but i am with her whether she wins or loses she has done a hell of a good job and even thn if she dosent win its the bad luck of jdj.

u conviniently forget the flaws of shveta and see Mona's and wht u r sayin is that the once who say shveta was beter are unbiased and the once who say Mona is better are biased?

and wht do u call such things as biased.norrow minded, mona is my auntie are they praises?

i had reason for saying shveta is not competetive bcoz she knw wht the format of the show is all agreed to it they bowed in front of aundiances decision and here she is questioning thm. she always knew that people's decicion will be final but still was complaining not once but many times. dont u think these are lame excuses?

You say if Mona doesnt win,its the bad luck for JDJ.....SInce this is a debate,I can contradict your opinion...I think the otherwise..If Svetha doesnt win,its a shame to JDJ and the indian audience....

SVetha is more flexible,she is more graceful,she points her toes well,the lifts are so fine,the whirling is so topflight,and the dances are so versatile.....

Mona on the other hand is not flexible,she doesnt point hert toes well,there arent that many new innovative steps,her dance is repetitive....her bijli was akin to "dilwalon ka dil lootne".....She isnt that novel when it comes to her costumes,and her hip movements arent that immaculate....

And,you said I dont see svetha's flaws....Well,if you see her flaws,why not point it out...just saying that she is flawed connotes the escapist tendency,point out the flaws,point out where she was bad,rather than just saying that she was bad.....

and Svetha fans can say that they are unbiased because svetha was the better performer on the D day,and almost everyone agrees that she was better...Thus,we feel vindicated,that we're rooting for the right contestant,the best contestant.....

and what's so wrong is svetha feels that the audience are biased....And why would that come as a ostacle in the clarity of reasoning😕..Even Mona once griped that the judges didnt give her enough scores,do we bear the grudge and not recognize her improvement...One needs to vote on basis of dance,and not on basis of who said what

Originally posted by: sandhya_rao7

ok so u mean to say that if judges give nice marks to shveta they r fair and if they dnt they r not?

Applying the reverse psychology....DO you mean to say that the judges are biased only if Mona doesnt get good scores...No,because your argument gives one that impression..Only because Mona didnt score well,judges are biased....

On the D day,the judges WERE NOT biased,as it doesnt require a PHD in dance to say who the better dancer was,who was more appealing to the eye,who was more fine,who was more versatile....

mona fans:
1)biased;coz of jassi as u all no n i am repeating it
2)hypocrytes;can't stand when shveta is praised and always try to put the comment down to turn the tables
3)when mona makes mistake they try to cover it up giving risiculous excuses
4)when mona praised they try to rub it in shveta fan's faces
5)when shveta makes a mistake or performance not as good they highlight it
6)jealous that shveta is being compared to be as good as madhuri but if sanjay said so himself then y r we harrassing his opinion. i think he knows better than us as buffie had said earlier in another topic. he has done movies with madhuri so he has seen her dance live and he has also seen shveta dance live so i think he is the only one that can make a true comparison definitly NOT MONA FANS

SHVETA ROCKS ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!! 😆

This is what I have to say. Too late to join the group. I like both the gals, but obviously, at the final stage of the competetion, I am with Shweta, needless to say.

the show is Jhalak dikhla ja.. "Dancing" with the stars..

the competetion is not about Natural fondness for dance - hence ajay jadeja was out, it is not about bringing novel ideas & choreography- hence mahesh was out, it is NOT ABOUT SHOWING IMPROVEMENT, not about entertaining.. it is about displaying DANCE SKILLS- hence mona should be out.
Mona razzle dazzles and entertains and is a fabulous person. She played Jassi and stole hearts.. i agree .. but she falls short of repeatedly PERFECT intense dance numbers.

DANCING SUPERIORITY --> Shweta since day 1, gala 1.

she scored poor marks the day she performed bharatnatyam with a very bad transitioning mdra from "katakamukha" o "alapadma". Other than that, she has been just par excellence. Her performances call for NO DEBATE OF ANY SORT
😉
qt

Originally posted by: Buffie

Infact most of the Mona supporters have agreed that they would vote for mona only because they want to,so there's no more need to debate,as the Best is Svetha,but the favourite is Mona.....People vote for whom they like,and not for the better dancer....

yup thats true n wat im tryin to say is that they shouldnt as this is a DANCE competition.

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

This is what I have to say. Too late to join the group. I like both the gals, but obviously, at the final stage of the competetion, I am with Shweta, needless to say.

the show is Jhalak dikhla ja.. "Dancing" with the stars..

the competetion is not about Natural fondness for dance - hence ajay jadeja was out, it is not about bringing novel ideas & choreography- hence mahesh was out, it is NOT ABOUT SHOWING IMPROVEMENT, not about entertaining.. it is about displaying DANCE SKILLS- hence mona should be out.
Mona razzle dazzles and entertains and is a fabulous person. She played Jassi and stole hearts.. i agree .. but she falls short of repeatedly PERFECT intense dance numbers.

DANCING SUPERIORITY --> Shweta since day 1, gala 1.

she scored poor marks the day she performed bharatnatyam with a very bad transitioning mdra from "katakamukha" o "alapadma". Other than that, she has been just par excellence. Her performances call for NO DEBATE OF ANY SORT
😉
qt

omg! u said that so well! gr8 job. i guess this puts all the arguements for mona out!!!

Debate over SHVETA WINS!!!😆

lol im jus kiddin u can contine with ur discussion but as of now shveta seems to be in the lead with all the good debaters we have got like mermaid, buffie and me of course 😆

-cheers
ritika