Unfair attitude towards Ragini?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: lunza
togepe , yes , madz does say that quite often to mahi and ankita , but I dont think it influences her when she scores them ...

ragz got 30 yesterday , anki got 28 and mahi scored 22..
and she is the only one out of the three to have got 30 (twice)

Today , rags got 23 , anki got 24 and mahi got 21 .. didnt see any bias ..

and reg ragz being a non-dancer , actually she is the only one out of the three to have had some sort of formal training in dance .. she has learnt bollywood style for one year ..
Ankita hasnt learnt dance as such ( hasnt been mentioned in any of her interviews or articles) and I think mahi hasnt learnt dance either...

if she learnt bolly dance for an year then it would have been 30 for her today...LOL

Quote

Divya Bharti RIP

@ScarredLife

Voyager

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: dew_drop
Hi! Well I feel Rags under performed today. If u notice keenly, she forgot some steps and also once she wrongly did a hand movement which made Neerav lil confused.. and he brought his hand in front and pulled it away asap and smiled. So I can understand judges pov.
Just pointing out.. Hope I didn't sound harsh..

Yeah I caught that too. I think 23 made sense.. Look at it this way - Low scores has turned her into a fighter.. She's not seating comfortably thinking - "well I got this, this week"...

Overall, I think this week was very disappointing show for JDJ... None of the dances were memorable... I truly feel that all judges are very biased when it comes to Shushant & Shampa... I don't think his act yesterday deserved 30 because he's done similar dance moves before.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: dew_drop
Hi! Well I feel Rags under performed today. If u notice keenly, she forgot some steps and also once she wrongly did a hand movement which made Neerav lil confused.. and he brought his hand in front and pulled it away asap and smiled. So I can understand judges pov.
Just pointing out.. Hope I didn't sound harsh..

everyone's performance had mistakes.. out of all hers was the best..!! but got low score..

Quote

Shikha

@lunza

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

^^ lathika , lol ya .. today it was full bollywood ..
btw , she has learnt bollywood style for a year , she mentioned it in an interview with the guru's name too..

Edited by lunza - 14 years ago

Quote

Sadvita

@Ubuntuu

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

I think Ragini was marked correctly today infact from yesterday episode I feel judges marking and comments to be fare compare to previous weeks.
Coming back to today's performance where was chemistry between Ragini and Neerav. 😕 Considering it to be sensuous song I expected more chemistry infact when I saw her act was last I thought it would be awesome,but it disappointed me considering Ragini is trained in Bollywood dancing I thought that she would bring chemistry between her and Ragini. She even forgot her steps and was kind of disturbed during act may be it was because of saree like Madhuri pointed it out.

Infact none of performance was great it was totally boring episode today.

Edited by sadvita - 14 years ago

Quote

dew_drop

@dew_drop

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Abhishah, along with the dance, I think judges take into account of concept, props, song and usage of stage.
With keeping this in mind. Both Sush and Rags deserved 30 :)
In yesterday's perf Chang got 8-9-9. And his dance was very average. But as I said hw judges notice the things I mentioned above, he definitely deserves the score.

Tiya, call me Dew 😉

Quote

Priya

@priya185

Master

+ 37

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

IMO i think she should have got 22

Quote

shrutic

@shrutic

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

I agree with all the above posts. This post really wasn't made as a pro and con. I simply felt today she deserved more than the 23 because with similar performances from others the judges have given higher scores. They are a little harsh with her. Today was a 27 mark performance from ehr cos she attempted something different, was good herself and danced on water! Sushant (Taking his name cos he was the closest competitor) wasn't as good as himself, and did not use a new concept. So I feel the marking was a little unjustified.

As for the judges, I think they are awesome. Biggest Madhuri fan :D

Quote

TheUltimate

@TheUltimate

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: shruti14
Hi,

So, I am an avid viewer of JDJ. I am generally alright with Sushant being scored the highest though I am not his biggest fan nor do I think he deserves the marks he gets all the time. The bias is evident. But this week I thought Ragini was outstanding. Yesterday she was rewarded but today the 23 has left a sour taste in my mouth!

Any one else feeling the same?

Hmmm... so when she got the performance of the week, judges' bias was not evident but now all of a sudden they are biased. Got it.