Shilpa's Crying Act Saved her?? - Page 4

Originally posted by: lats55

my question to you is that how come monica act scored 8 point and shilpa act scored 7 point become 0 and 10.. i agree removing wig helped us to see her face expression better.. but her act remain the same.. is the energy increased it to 10?? also monica's act a difficult lift involved which she did perfectly.. it was more tougher than shilpa's dance..

Sorry...perhaps I didn't explain properly...but yes, In my opinion...Shilpa did a much better job the second time round...her overall performance (dance, expressions, character) was much better...like I said...she came back with a punch.

I'm not detracting from Monica's performance at all...but you could just see her heart wasn't in it, she just looked defeated to me and she didn't perform as well as the first time...

So Monica's remained an 8 even with a near perfect lift...but Shilpa's surely became more than a 7 performance in my opinion.

Of course it's difficult to compare because the acts varied so much...BUT...if you consider their acts individually (their first and second tries) it's easier to see...

i don't know i watched both shilpa performance and could not find any difference other than removing the wig.. and i differ in your point of view..LabRat34

i agree shilpa's act was weaker than monica's but in the dance off she danced wid much more energy than monica her performance was much better in dance off than the original episode so i guess she deserved another chance and not monica