Shilpa's Crying Act Saved her?? - Page 3

Originally posted by: lats55

since you know how to analyse various dance forms, i would like to ask you about parul's last performance , i felt that she was good and should have scored 30.. can you tell me any flaw which you find in her performance and reason for reduction of 2 marks.. this is just to know..

I felt bad for Monica coz she did seem to have the edge over shilpa in the dance off IMO. Was surprised that judges favoured shilpa. But final call is obviously from the teen deviyan, even if we don't agree.

Originally posted by: gauri92

I personally feel Shilpa's act was better.....the choreography was very basic in Monica's act, and her lines were not proper...

And to consider all performances till now.....Shilpa has always been one of the better performers on teh show and lacks in votes becasue she isn't as visible as some of teh others....its a facr, and im not trying to point fingers at anyone ar anything of the sort...but we have to admit that visibility in media has a lot to do with votes....

I completely agree with you! I liked Monica's act but I enjoyed Shilpa's more......Monica was kinda holding back and not giving the performance her all.

I think it was a tough call this week...two of the better dancers on the show up against each other.

Personally my vote went to Shilpa after they removed their silly wig thing and she came in with fighting spirit...whatever was lacking in friday's performance, she made up for it.

Monica was good too...and I enjoyed their act as well...but there was an air of defeat already about her...dunno if it was just be.

I dont udnerstand why Shilpa crying would help her in any matter(I just think she was convinced she was going to go...and that may even have helped her performance...thinking she should go out with a bang)...because it was the judges and not the audience who were going to decide. Maybe some audiences are swayed by that kinda thing but I'd like to think the judges remain as impartial as possible during elimination.

First of all their act was totally different.......i guess ppl like monicas act better coz of her outfit and the way she was looking.....but then the thing is the judges were very smart.. i was seeing monicas and shilpas act very carefully and monica did have a very little cordination problem in b/w very little i did get a pinch of that cordination problem........so i guess u cant say shilpa cried so shes out...i think the judges r matured enough and on top of that they r top choreographers...normal audience saying nething wont help....u have to see the dances properly guys

Originally posted by: lats55

i felt monica's performance was better than shilpa.. is shilpa's crying act saved her? what you all think?

it's nothing they are just making shilpa the dance-off queen...in my opinion shilpa should have been out coz she has been in dance off more than anybody else and coming back again...what are they wanting to prove?? i'm saying this coz in many dance competitons i've seen if you come dance-off again and again you'll get eliminated...so shilpa kind of knew that and she was crying...and i was also sure that now shilpa's journey is going to end...but it happened the other way round...i think coming in dance-off over an over again means janta don't like her...but what can i say it was the judges decision...so they know way more better than us and can keep our mouths shut if they can with their answers coz they know better...

What difference it makes to the show if shilpa stays or monica stays both of them are not popular with audience or judges. they dont get much votes of trps for show.shilpa gave a better performance than monica her energy was good and good expressions also good thing they did not wear the head gear on the dance off day so their expressions could be seen. as for monica though her dance had lifts her energy was down on saturday and expression were not there. so fair enough shilpa stayed why should you think she stayed due to tears if that was the case eveyweek we have people crying in jdj3 .That doesnot make any difference to the judges. i am happy she stayed

Originally posted by: gauri92

Parul had lost her footing at some point in the dance....I'll have to go back and watch that, but she did lose her footing during one of the turns.....

And other than that...I can't remember much right now because i didn't pay too much attention to Parul's dance since I knew that she would be safe.....but if ur not being sarcastic, then can I get bak to you later??? Ill have to wait for the performance to load on my comp, hte connection is damn slow...

Also, I kinda find the judging somewhat wierd.....I used to like it....but now...

While I totally love Baichung, he did not deserve teh three 30s in a row....the middle performance was so not tht good.....

ok i got your point.. i was wondering why she lost the marks.. judges should have pointed it out .. yes you are right on baichung.. even i agree with you that he don't deserve 30 three times in a row.. this can create problems if he reaches the final, as judges marks carry weight.. thanks for your explanation..
parul's dance link downloading will be faster in dailymotion site..

http://www.dailymotion.com/user/adilfzd/video/x931v0_24th-april-09-jhalak-dikhla-jaa-3-v_shortfilms

Originally posted by: LabRat34

I think it was a tough call this week...two of the better dancers on the show up against each other.

Personally my vote went to Shilpa after they removed their silly wig thing and she came in with fighting spirit...whatever was lacking in friday's performance, she made up for it.

Monica was good too...and I enjoyed their act as well...but there was an air of defeat already about her...dunno if it was just be.

I dont udnerstand why Shilpa crying would help her in any matter(I just think she was convinced she was going to go...and that may even have helped her performance...thinking she should go out with a bang)...because it was the judges and not the audience who were going to decide. Maybe some audiences are swayed by that kinda thing but I'd like to think the judges remain as impartial as possible during elimination.

my question to you is that how come monica act scored 8 point and shilpa act scored 7 point become 0 and 10.. i agree removing wig helped us to see her face expression better.. but her act remain the same.. is the energy increased it to 10?? also monica's act a difficult lift involved which she did perfectly.. it was more tougher than shilpa's dance..