Are judges really so ignorant? - Page 2

Originally posted by: BUTTERFLY12

I repeat what I have told perviously as well, the channel and show makers have a plan - they analyze the voting scenario, TRPs and few other similar things and base their decisions on them to either make cleverly edited avis or to score the participants to suit themselves.

I just wish that judges remained loyal to their job. Before they signed the contract, they should make it clear that they will judge on their own and won't take any pressure from anybody - whatsoever! But the world is not that simple and to make things happen, there is a lot of activity which goes behind the curtain (and under the table!!)

Thanks for reading!

Originally posted by: kaushikbasu

@BUTTERFLY12

I agree to what you said. It is well known that Karan is one of the favorite contestant on the show. The lower the scores, more votes he gets, which translates to money and popularity. Though people might argue that why he and Bhaichung are judged on diffrent scales, then they should remember that even Karan and Gauhar should also be measured in the same scale, in which I feel more often than not Karan might fall short. Also if looked in absolute terms, I believe none should get more than 7 of 10, as purely at dancing level, 10 of 10 means perfect and which can not be bettered by anyone.

Originally posted by: BUTTERFLY12

Well I kinda disagree - I think to be a judge, you need to be the master of the game. In my opinion, both SK and VM have proved themselves to be the master of Indian dance and are highly qualified to be the judge of JDJ3 dance show.

And I agree with first part of your message where you say that no participant is particularly favored here....I agree with that because these contestants mean nothing to the channel but a source of making money and gaining TRPs so which ever contestant can bring them the same in whatever way possible - that will be applied........in the process, none of the contestant is ever safe or protected!!

Originally posted by: BUTTERFLY12

my concern is that they are like puppets in the hands of show makers and channel authorities. They are being told to score the participants in a certain range and thus they do.
----
I just wish that judges remained loyal to their job. Before they signed the contract, they should make it clear that they will judge on their own and won't take any pressure from anybody - whatsoever!

Originally posted by: kOmAl_luves_KSG

i agree, and the judges have favorites, i am not saying that just becuz i luv karan and i luv parul but becuz if u luk at all the pervious comemnts the judges have given u can see that they are always favoring one on top of another all for TRPs and i knoe that they are aming choregraphers and its all for the channel but Sony should stop and draw a line!