TOBY - 100% right

Page

Next Last

ridhima (OMG,it really is, haha i wouldnt lie)

@babii.girl

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

Toby was 100% right.. these judges are biased.. and it is NAUTANKI dikh la jaa. i mean Saroj got so mad and demanded an explanination and and then when Toby is trying to give one she opens her mouth.. god, this saroj khan thinks shes always right.. like jeez woman u do realize everybody has a the right to have an opinion.. shes just so irritating.. i think its HIGH time saroj leaves the show.. and when Ronit was like you were the winnign chereographer for first season, you should know what the judges want.. but honestly every judge expects something different.. these judges didnt even sit down with all the contestans and tell them what they want.. and then they expect everybody to do exactly what they expect/want.

Quote

Frequent Posters

77124

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: babii.girl
when Ronit was like you were the winnign chereographer for first season, you should know what the judges want..

Ronit was stupid for saying that.

He's the winner THATS WHY he is questioning the whole thing because its not consistent from last time around.

Edited by Shawn89 - 16 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Sunaina Mitra

@sunaina02

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

I also think Toby was right but he should have put the thing diplomatically .

And I was shocked when Saroj Khan commented that Gauhar Khan is hte best she has even seen 😲

I hope she meant that in JDJ.

Otherwise , does she have so short memory that she forgot Madhuri Dixit .😕😡

Her comment was a downright insult to whole filmi dancing community.👎🏼

Quote

Ani

@archangel

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

agree guys Saroj Khan thinks she is God Almighty and that when she talks everybody has to listen but I think Toby is right these guys favor all the Dramebaaz people for eg Ram, he gets good marks for his dance not his talent I mean no offence to Ram fans but it is the sad truth

Quote

suwas

@suwas

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: archangel
agree guys Saroj Khan thinks she is God Almighty and that when she talks everybody has to listen but I think Toby is right these guys favor all the Dramebaaz people for eg Ram, he gets good marks for his dance not his talent I mean no offence to Ram fans but it is the sad truth

I agree that judges are biased.

But as you have suggested Ram was never judges favorite.Him getting lowest marks shows that. Bhaichungs first performance , Mohinderji' & Anand Raj ji's most performances were was worse than the one in which Ram got 16.

Lot of contestants like Ugesh got away with showing off magic than dancing was praised twice for that where as Ram got reprimded for what he is considered best on TV, acting.Bhaichung didn't get his much marks cut when he did not do the dance form, i think samba( all judges siad he didn't do samba but something Bhaichung style 7 he still got 23) where as Ram got praises for his but didn't get marks. They didn't cut Bhaichung's marks when he didn't lip sing but Ram's did. Juhi gave anand RAj Anand 10 that is perfect for not so great dance, except having lot of energy where as gave RAm 8 for is phenomenal Hip hop which was much more complicated with lots of steps.

And I thought dance is the talent Ram was supposed to show so what do you mean by he got good marks for dance not talent?

Edited by suwas - 16 years ago

Quote

suwas

@suwas

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

multiple post by misake.

Edited by suwas - 16 years ago

Quote

4492

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Yeh toby was right, and saroj was irritating, but toby shud've been careful in his AV and shud've asked questions and then proved his point

i think he was absolutely righ about the fact that they give marks on stuff like u carried ur weight well like for Ram, or mohendra amar nath and stuff, i mean it wud've been so much easier if they just tell the contestants what they want, i think toby's last 2 performance was quite good and i dun think they deserved to leave so early.

Quote

maya

@coolfire

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

When Rohit said "Well Toby you should know what the judges want, you were the winner of season 1!"

I wish that Toby or Bhagyashree had retorted, "Yes, but back then there were thoughtful judges on the panel, not these three idiots. Or at least one senile woman who thinks she's the Almighty!" 🤢

I refrain from speaking badly, but that outburst of Saroj Khan was appalling when all of Toby's allegations were right on the spot! The judges show favoritism (read Bhaichung's three 30s) and they prefer nautanki over technique!