JDJ is scripted right ?? - Page 16

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi

The whole point of mentioning that line was to confirm that you have ignored the major chunk of my information to understand Isha's limitations and have taken the line outta the context to build some more assumptions.

Seriously? You probably won't notice a joke if it's dancing under your nose in Dobby's socks (sorry about all the Harry Potter references; it's second nature to me now)

Anyways, you see even I get tangled with assumptions. So I assumed that if someone is making such a blatant statement, he or she wouldn't have known of such injuries. it is understandable for many to undermine an injury if one has no clue of it. But in your case, on one hand, you claim to have knowledge of such injuries while on the same instance you find it OK to group them all together and tag them all with the same prognosis 😲

You know what my point was? If your technically sound line of thought may permit me - Unless one is not dying, starving or is mentally unstable, a performer should perform under all circumstaces, no matter how shitty the performance turns out to be. I hope I made it clear this time.

I wasn't speaking as a medical specialist or a doctor, I was speaking strictly as a performer. For a normal person, an injury might be reason enough to take a break for a few days (as per 'medical' advice), but not for a performer. We dance even when our bones are fractured, skulls cracked, muscles torn etc' and even when doctors advice us not to even move an inch. Now you can go around waving your seperate prognosis for each person but trust me when I say they wouldn't give a rat's ass.

Well, even after all that information, you want her to give a performance, then I really have to go back to my previous assumption of you not knowing of injuries such as of Isha's.
****Face Palm****Just because I believe she could have performed atleast something even despite her injury, I don't have knowledge about injuries? So basically, what you believe is correct, while what some other person believes isn't? Apply some of your own principles on yourself. For someone who harpes on so much about intolerance towards being judged, you're quite judgemental yourself.

Kahaani Khatam for you, but there are others who would like to see them on stage. So I am happy with judges decision for using VETO. They can't unfortunately make everyone happy. SorryYeah, apology accepted.

P.S - Yes 😆😆 (As I said earlier everyone has some sorta bias, some arise from love and some from hatred, FYI: I like psychology as well, human brain is amazing)

And how did you come to the brilliant conclusion that what I feel towards Salman-Isha is hatred? You know, I'd much rather hate people like KRK and Rakhi Sawant, because even they are far more interesting. Besides, how do you know whether I actually hate them or post here simply to rile up their fangirls? Guess you'll never know 😉

P.S - You know what real hatred is? What you feel towards people like me. 😆 P.P.S - Your siggie dabba proves the above statement. LOLWA 😆

yikes! double post

Originally posted by: U-No-Poo

Originally posted by: U-No-Poo

P.S - You know what real hatred is? What you feel towards people like me. 😆 P.P.S - Your siggie dabba proves the above statement. LOLWA 😆

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

You know I appreciate your comment. And this is how it should be. Praise your favorite but don't at least mock others. I am better off applauding a GC fan like you than certain haters who are laughing at Isha's injury and calling it sympathy, even wishes her other hand to be broken and forget about the one who wishes her to die 🤢

Seriously, you think a person who loves dancing will fake such injury to garnish the votes. I don't know if she deserves it or not, but judges and the makers want her on the show so she is here. You or me or anyone can't do anything about it. So far she's been getting 0/60 and has been surviving on votes, then I would like to ask others who are voting day and night when their favorites get low scores and even get saved over the one who deserves simply based on voting, so how is it fair then. Of course then the lecture is about JDJ being a popularity show. But when it comes to someone else, all the logic goes out the window. You see the double standard here of certain individuals.

***The above argument has been made keeping aside the fact that it all might be scripted***

And about GC winning, I wouldn't mind that either and will be happy only for his certain fans like you. I also have the same view as you in terms of WC, I feel it isn't fair for them to win. And I don't think they will since it wouldn't make any sense. Had a big debate on it with Khushi 😉 So outta all I will be more happy if non WC wins except for Bharti, who in no way deserves to be on this stage 😡

And I agree, it is a competition, reaching till now is commendable for any contestant. And based on dancing and votes (and cheap jokes 🤢), people who didn't deserve it, has already left the stage 😊

P.S: I have always appreciated your neutral stand being someone's fan 😃

Originally posted by: ..Sadiie..

@Bold

OMG WHAT?!😲😲

That is Bloody INSANE!! No matter how Much I hate a certain Celeb I will NEVER Stoop so low such as wishing they injure their other body parts or even worse; DIE!!

I'm seriously shocked here, people have actually said that?! Inhumane I say!🤢

Oh yes, some of things that has come out on this forum is indeed very inhumane, lame, pathetic and simply laughable. I don't think I have seen any GC hater go to that extend. Then again I don't understand such hatred for any celeb, why waste time and energy on someone who you don't like or even care.

I totally agree with you!

You know, when the show had begun and the performances were pouring in, I always wanted to see GC&Isha in the Finals because for me it meant that GC was competing against someone who was always getting awesome scores. So for me it's a proud moment when i think of the two being in the finals😳 I like how you compared the two, but brought out only GC in the lime light 😆😆

Though I am not an Isha fan and I usually do get disappointed with her performances but then again I don't even say she should be out of the competition Cuz I only want the less deserving people to leave*You know who😆* - Isha is a deserving Contestant as well as GC. Bingo, that's what I have been trying to say on many occasions, from all the contestants, i would have liked the less deserving to go first, but then again it's a competition and we will have to tolerate someone like Bharti or others, there isn't a thing like fair competition anyways.

So from the lot I choose non WC, basically Isha and GC. And yes I agree some of Isha's performances haven't been on par especially after Salman got injured, but it's still a pleasure to see them perform on the stage compared to others especially since their execution is quite flawless to me, it's always a treat. And same with GC, I have liked many concepts churned out by Shampa and he has even done justice to most of them to an extend, though I still think he is far from being a good dancer. As someone had said, he is a good student who experiments and follows whatever he is taught to his limitations. So no problemo here 😉

About the WC entries, well I have a strong feeling Rashmi MIGHT Win if I think about her being the face of Colors TV - They always favour their own people right...so kinda doubt if GC or Isha will win Cuz I feel Rashmi might...but let's see what happens 😃 Sincerely Wish GC or Isha win as both have been in the Competition for the longest amount of time - A more of GC cuz I'm rooting for him😳

I also think Rashmi might reach the finals. I agree and don't agree with this decision. Agree cuz she is a fab dancer and has the potential and don't agree cuz she is WC. When it comes to Isha, I don't think she is going to win anyways due to her less popularity and other factors. So I shall enjoy what is given to me. In the end I got no control over what channel wants though I would like to see her win, but the use of VETO and couple of non performances do make a crack in her record of being the winning candidate.

And, Thank You :) You have no idea what those words mean to me...feel like I've achieved something I lost when JDJ Started and I turned into a typical Fan Girl. Thank You :)

You're most welcome sweetie 😃, I have to give the credit where it's due. And no worries, even after having an open mind on this stage, I just got tagged as a "Fan girl" simply for taking a stand and being passionate about my views on Isha's progress 😆😆 And who cares if you get tagged as the fan girl, at least you are standing up for your views and choice as long as it is done with proper conduct.

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

That's your opinion which is quite idealist and might work in the real world. Unfortunately, this is a competition and when opportunity is given not to perform and take weeks off, why would any sane person risk their health. So Isha is given weeks off, judges and JDJ makers don't have the problem, then it doesn't even make sense for her to quit the show just cuz you or others think it is unfair. And who knows she even might be bound to the contract which is making her stay or she is staying because she wants to. End of the day it is her call.

Give me one reason why allowing her to stay is fair. Just one valid reason. And no, don't shove her perfect 30 record into my face. It doesn't count.

She is a performer on JDJ, but that's not the end of life for her. This isn't a do or a die situation. Who are you or me to ask her what she should do. She will do what is apt for her and her health, I am sure she knows better how to lead her life. Yes you can question the decision and express your views, which you have done very well, but it isn't gonna change the facts. It is a show after all, not everything will be done based on fairness and justice. On a side note, what might be fair to one might not be fair to others, difference of opinion, perspective, call it whatever.

Shabdo ki khichdi banake pesh karne ke hunar ki kya khoob peshkash!

So you are basically speaking as an idealist performer, while I am speaking with a medical knowledge who is taking the practical approach as to why Isha might not be able to perform or shouldn't perform. You can stick to your views and let me stick to mine. It is as simple as that.

I'm not speaking as an idealist performer, what I've said is true for everyone who claims to be a 'professional dancer'.

(Did you really follow all my posts to come up with such a statement, I didn't realize I had a stalker 😆😆)

Oh yes, I am a hardcore stalker. Entertainment ke liya kuch bhi karega 😛

Really, is this how you go about, putting words in people's mouth. I did not say I am correct neither did I say you don't have the knowledge, I simply stated my assumption based on what I read (and in no way was I judging your knowledge or you, one can not judge someone based on couple of lines he or she might have written on a virtual forum) I simply stated my opinion based on my experience, but if you think I am forcing you to accept my POV, you're so wrong. I do not impose my opinions on others. I already stated many times, people will see what they want to see and judge a situation based on their experience and bias. And yes I still stick with my theory that everyone has some sorta bias, whether you agree or not.

I know you are not forcing me to accept your opinion, you are simply showcasing a brilliant example of the rape of the english language through repetitive essay-like posts (and I wonder whether it was you who mocked another member's long replies)

@ red, the same applies to you. You're doing exactly the same, trying to make me want to agree with your beliefs while neglecting my own. I tried to agree to disagree with you but then you didn't like that cuz according to you that's not how a debate works. You want others to accept your expert opinions but you don't wanna do the same.

Janaab, I'm not trying to make you agree! 😆 Kya ghor ananyay! You haven't replied to any of our (salman-Isha 'haterzzz') claims with a single logical argument. All you have been harping on about is 'It's my opinion. It's my assumption. It' my theory based on some other assumption. It's Isha's life. It's the judges call. Let me stick to my opinion. Let Isha do what's best for her' yada yada yada daba doo 😆

When I made that statement it was a general statement for two extremes. And I am guessing you are looking beyond the grey areas. Not everyone has to be a lover or a hater, there are people who fall in between, same way the bias will vary from person to person in a spectrum of two extremes. Also, I should have also added that bias doesn't simply come from being a fan or hater, there are many ways one can develop bias towards someone or something. Now that's another topic all together.
@red: Please do not use such statements in your reply, cuz it simply weakens your argument and the respect I might have had for your views.

@Big font: EXACTLY! OMG! DAFUQ DID I JUST READ??!?!?! 😲 YOU MANAGED TO GRASP THAT CONCEPT?!?!

P.S - You know what real hatred is? What you feel towards people like me. 😆 Now you aren't applying your own principle on yourself. Why the heck would I feel any sorta hate towards you, virtual someone. What baffles me is when people assume that people with different views can't acknowledge one another and can only feel that gigantic hate towards the person with opposite view. Since you have made that statement, may be that's how you take any contrast view and the person, I don't.

P.S: You shouldn't expect others to have an open mind in a debate when you are sticking with your own blinders.