A little less Jhalak and a LOT like Comedy Circus

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

mini03

@mini03

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

Word honey! i mean he was superb in relay or even in the bodyguard act! cmon salman himself gave standing ovation just to this guy n to NO ONE else! tats huge! donno are the judges blind or something! Wahi is sucha fab dancer! no one can do the lifts better dan him! HE WAS THE BEST!

Quote

Roopal Gupta

@..Roopal..

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: nomadsoul

That's season 5 of Jhalak Dikhla Jaa for you.
Trying to up themselves in the TRP chart with a comedian who is given more screen space than the anchors or even the judges of the show.I am sorry to say but Bharti is not judged based on her dance moves but her jokes. She is hefty, yes. Yet she can dance, of course yes! But just because she's fat and can move a bit doesn't make her better than the rest of the contestants.It's a different point system out there for her. Choose the simplest of steps, and get heaps of marks. This is applicable only for Bharti and only BECAUSE she is fat o.O COMMON fat or not, handicapped or not, if it's a dance show judge a contestant based on their moves!

Now what provoked me to post this here is after seeing how biased the judges are towards some of their favourites. Take the 2^nd relay for example! I was SHOCKED to see Karan Wahi getting the lowest mark! Please watch the relay video again and see his final lift and twist. That was OUT OF THE WORLD and i swear i thought he nailed it. But NOPE! Apparently judges thought Bharti was better than Karan. Not saying because i am anyone's fan but just stating some obvious facts. Alright forget what i said, my mom, who has no clue who Karan Wahi or Bharti or the others are, purely judge everyone based on their dance performance. Even she (who's a dancer herself) said that why was Karan given the lowest mark. He was clearly the best in the relay. Judges are way too partial towards a few and it's SICK.

@green

in today's tv time i feel

NA BAAP BADA NA BHAIYYA
TRP IS THE KHIWAIYYA

(father and brother are noone in front of TRP)

@blue

i completely disagree

she is being judges on the basis of her dance only

she is improving with her dance constantly and also she do dance good enough to get the scores she is having

@pink

simple steps?😲

omg is the flexibility she is showing and her lifts and all are so simple?

and i want to take ur notice to her performance on the song : kyun main jagoon , which was dedicated to street kids...was it so easy and simple stepped?

@black

i feel marks are given on the basis of complete performance

yes kW was very good with the lift but overall performance had bharti outshining him

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ViccoTurmeric

@ViccoTurmeric

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

I agree that for trp's JDJ is doing everything!

BUT BUT BUT

Its totally wrong to say that Bharti is not judge in accordance to her performance. To do such steps is not easy especially for her, moreover is you think its easy then pzzz just try the street wala act

Coming to scores! Yes, I agree that in relay Karan could have got better marks but his performance was just not good in main act.

Quote

Ajnabee

@*Woh Ajnabee*

Stunner

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

I enjoy Bharti's jokes and comedy. Her chemistry with everyone on the set is awesome, especially with Manish and Remo! A lot of her performances are commendable strictly in reference to her weight. I won't say she's the best dancer of the lot, but she tries, and her efforts, along with Savio's show in her performances.

Coming to Wahi, I find him strictly average in terms of dance. The judges were on-the-dot giving him a 24 this week! He has no control over the lower part of his body, and he'll have to work on that. His technique needs work - Mohena puts a lot of lifts in her choreography, and he needs to ensure they're execution is more smooth and clean. I feel like he gets lost in the performance too much and forgets about his technique. "Hero" quality can only take him so far. He needs to work on dancing now!

Quote

Ajnabee

@*Woh Ajnabee*

Stunner

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: mini03
Word honey! i mean he was superb in relay or even in the bodyguard act! cmon salman himself gave standing ovation just to this guy n to NO ONE else! tats huge! donno are the judges blind or something! Wahi is sucha fab dancer! no one can do the lifts better dan him! HE WAS THE BEST!

That's because he incorporated all of Salman's popular dance moves into his performance. If anything, that "standing ovation" was for Mohena's choreography. And while we're taking things so seriously, are you planning on watching Salman's next movie starring Bharti as the female lead?

Quote

soumya mehta(dia my nick name)

@dieya

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: roopalgupta

@green
in today's tv time i feel
NA BAAP BADA NA BHAIYYA
TRP IS THE KHIWAIYYA
(father and brother are noone in front of TRP)

@blue
i completely disagree
she is being judges on the basis of her dance only
she is improving with her dance constantly and also she do dance good enough to get the scores she is having

@pink
simple steps?😲
omg is the flexibility she is showing and her lifts and all are so simple?
and i want to take ur notice to her performance on the song : kyun main jagoon , which was dedicated to street kids...was it so easy and simple stepped?

@black
i feel marks are given on the basis of complete performance
yes kW was very good with the lift but overall performance had bharti outshining him

i agree with u here

i feel it is very difficult for bharti to do lifts and dance altogether and a being a non dancer she improved a lot and judges always give fair marks according to me many times bharti scored low marks too karan wahi is better dancer than bhart but in recent episode's performance bharti;s steps were clean though they were very simple but karan's dance steps were not that clean except that lift which was excellent

Quote

RAJ

@MrChatVsNorway

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

agree with ur post partially coz Karan and Mohena were certainly not the best in the group relay performance ..but u r right as far as your opinion on bharti is concerned..this is not a standup comedy show .things are getting out of hands .earlier she used to crack jokes after her act but nowadays she is given special segments that too more than one on average..moreover the cameras are too interested to capture her even while others are on the stage(even when the judges are dancing!!)...I like Bharti but what is alarming is that she is not even featuring in bottom 4 and better dancers are being shown the door which is so unfair!!i think this will continue for few more weeks ..her jokes are getting rusty..same old "mere paas zyada belly hai" blah blah are so blase...and people who are appreciative of her sallies on the show coz they think entertainment is ultimately what they want...i would request them to watch Laugh india laugh or comedy circus..because its a dance show afterall and entertainment should only be derived out of dancing and not comedy which is becoming the mainstay of jdj season 5..

Edited by rajluvsshvpavti - 13 years ago

Quote

Shaitaan Haiwan

@Shaitan-Haiwan

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

Nomadsoul I completely agree with you.

I am very unhappy with the judges marks for the second relay. That lift that Karan and Mohena did was PHENOMENAL! I rewinded it 3 times on my pvr to watch it. I would have given them 10 points JUST for that lift!!

At the very least Karan should have gotten 8 points. Rashmi and Bharti's relay was too basic, and Rithviks was good I guess.

Quote

DkiDhanno

@DkiDhanno

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#19

I don't think one properly executed lift is the only factor being considered for points 😕 It's seems as though only Mohena stands out in their performances, which really shouldn't be the case. Karan does have great stage presence but if only he was to incorporate that into his dance, their points would be flying. As for Bharti .. only her elimination would bring us to realize what a bore the show is without some humor. God forbid that happens, but let alone she is improving and a committed contestant, and that's what matters ;)

Quote

Neeta

@U-No-Poo

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#20

Jugdes are not fair towards Wahi? People, he did not even deserve to get selected through wild card - only two people deserved to be selected: Rashmi and Ritvik (thank god they were) I think it's pretty obvious why he was selected. He's good looking and enjoys a fairly decent fan following.

The lift was executed brilliantly, no doubt. But the rest of his performance was quite weak. His dance is too disconnected, he doesn't hold the movement together. I guess that's the reason why his steps are not very sharp and clear either. Plus like they say, the whole is bigger than the sum of it's parts. He needs to be consistent throughout the performance. Which is probably the reason why Bharti scored over him - she didn't incorporate anything spectacular in her choreography but was pretty consistent.

As far as Bharti is concerned, I agree she may not be the best dancer out there, and as a dancer myself I would have probably eliminated her long ago. But frankly at this point I don't care 😆 I love her on the show and wouldn't watch it if she gets eliminated. I watch JDJ purely for entertainment, if I had to watch proper dance I would probably watch So you think you can dance. Besides, her expressions are always so vivid and bang-on: she deserves brownie points there.

Quote

1 2 3

A little less Jhalak and a LOT like Comedy Circus - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics