Karan Deserves More Than 7

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Niyati

@hey.bhaggu

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#21

Just finished watching wahi's performance. I liked the usage of stage but Karan was WEAK! He was clumsy and that straight posture you need for latin/spanish dances, he was very clumsy in keeping that. Also some of his steps were unfinished. They also had some problems in transitions, especially right after few lifts (which weren't smooth either).

I think 24 was more than deserving for Karan in this performance but that is just my opinion.

Quote

ALISHA SHIRODKAR

@PRINCESS_ALISHA

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: Pooja4Suhit
I'm really NOT bashing anyone, but I honestly thought Bharti didn't deserve 9 when KW got 7.. Bharti's style, Jive was much easier in comparison and so were her steps. The judges baisedly ignored that, and giving KW a 7 was not fair..
</div><div>

See it also depends on lot of factors,bharti has grown up frm her past performances,secondly the execution was also very neat,while karan performance was al a mess.steps were unfinished.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Pori

@Pori

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#23

Can you be in Canada and still vote? I am double checking because i checked the terms and conditions this morning and it said people from UAE, USA and one more country could vote online, but it didnt mention Canada :(. I really want to vote for Karan

Quote

Arnav90

@Arnav90

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

#24

Well yes agree he deserve atleast 8 from Remo...

Quote

sayhitoshas

@sayhitoshas

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: Pori
Can you be in Canada and still vote? I am double checking because i checked the terms and conditions this morning and it said people from UAE, USA and one more country could vote online, but it didnt mention Canada :(. I really want to vote for Karan

I think you should be able to vote until Sunday 9 in the morning your time.

Quote

Pooja4Suhit

@Pooja4Suhit

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: aasthanup
See it also depends on lot of factors,bharti has grown up frm her past performances,secondly the execution was also very neat,while karan performance was al a mess.steps were unfinished.

Jhalak is a dance competition, not a growth competition.. Every dancer should be judges on the same basis. The execution was neat due to the steps being easy.. I'm a trained Jive dancer, and trust me, the steps she was given were literally basic. Even her mujra steps were limited. I'm not saying Karan's wasn't a mess - I agree his steps were messy, and his work could have been a lot cleaner.. His posture was wrong too but some of the steps he excuted were amazing and a lot more difficult.. There was a variety in his dance and the lifts were amazing.. f KW got 7, then Bharti should have gotten the same, really.

Quote

Zarqa

@indian_beauty

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#27

Agreed...Remo shud've at least given him an 8 but *sigh*

Quote

sayhitoshas

@sayhitoshas

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

#28

Originally posted by: Pooja4Suhit

Jhalak is a dance competition, not a growth competition.. Every dancer should be judges on the same basis. The execution was neat due to the steps being easy.. I'm a trained Jive dancer, and trust me, the steps she was given were literally basic. Even her mujra steps were limited. I'm not saying Karan's wasn't a mess - I agree his steps were messy, and his work could have been a lot cleaner.. His posture was wrong too but some of the steps he excuted were amazing and a lot more difficult.. There was a variety in his dance and the lifts were amazing.. f KW got 7, then Bharti should have gotten the same, really.

I completely agree with you, Pooja4Suhit. I have learned Flamenco, and a critical aspect of the dance is how well you 'fill' the stage - your presence. Agreed, Karan made some technical errors, given that Flamenco IS a tough dance. That said, his expressions and the manner in which he filled the stage with his presence was commendable. Which is why I thought 7 was too less a score for what he's done.