History not gonna repeat this yr - Page 5

Originally posted by: nishu786

ha ha...then it will not be a dance competition,it will be an award function 😃

Originally posted by: maaniqra

sooo frnd u judje of jhalak😆

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Actually it will not be even award function that will be awkward function.😆

Originally posted by: --PiaSenGupta--

Originally posted by: nishu786

Ok,now i m giving example which has nothing to do with JDJ,nowsay me one thing if both Michael jackson & prabhu deva perform in dance competition,then marks should be given to prabhu deva by his standards or by judging him on level with MJ. bcoz at the end of the day it's a dance competition,you have to compare other dancer with the best dancer.

If perfect score is for best dancer,then you can't give same marks to other dancer just bcoz they performed good according to their individual capacity.

Note:- I like both Prabhu deva & MJ.

Originally posted by: Ubiquitos

Agree with your example but will it be fair to bring MJ and PrabhuDeva in same competition. Prabhudeva is Prabhudeva and MJ is MJ. If Isha is MJ then noone is Prabhu deva also in Jhalak .

JDJ is a dance show but not an ultimate dance show like DID where all we see is dance,dance and dance since the begining!
Isha-Salman have been beyond competition since d begining. If we want to compare them then we shud also demand good dancing celebrities in JDJ. Sanath,Talat, Susheel,Jayati,Bharti, Ravi,Giaa,Pratyusha,GC, cannot come to Isha's level in one day but still they are trying hard to dance well and that is the theme of JDJ.

Isha is a dance trainer herself and has been giving dance performances since years. Rest of contestants (even Darsheel) are far
far behind her in terms of dance even before the begining of Jhalak. So comparison shud not be there. Nahi to competition hi nahi hai( pure dancewise ) trophy simply goes to Isha!!

Mark system shud b fair when whole system of Jhalak is fair is all I can say.

Originally posted by: Ubiquitos

Agree with your example but will it be fair to bring MJ and PrabhuDeva in same competition. Prabhudeva is Prabhudeva and MJ is MJ. If Isha is MJ then noone is Prabhu deva also in Jhalak .

JDJ is a dance show but not an ultimate dance show like DID where all we see is dance,dance and dance since the begining!
Isha-Salman have been beyond competition since d begining. If we want to compare them then we shud also demand good dancing celebrities in JDJ. Sanath,Talat, Susheel,Jayati,Bharti, Ravi,Giaa,Pratyusha,GC, cannot come to Isha's level in one day but still they are trying hard to dance well and that is the theme of JDJ.

Isha is a dance trainer herself and has been giving dance performances since years. Rest of contestants (even Darsheel) are far
far behind her in terms of dance even before the begining of Jhalak. So comparison shud not be there. Nahi to competition hi nahi hai( pure dancewise ) trophy simply goes to Isha!!

Mark system shud b fair when whole system of Jhalak is fair is all I can say.

Originally posted by: --PiaSenGupta--

See if they are in the same platform ..and competing ..then they all are in the same level ..just because one can dance well does not mean he/she will not get points ...It should be purely based on DANCE