misfit007 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Hey guys.
I'm mostly a silent member and I rarely ever make myself known but i couldn't help myself this time.
This comments and posts i've read on the whole "Roshini Disappering on Sid" are quite intersting so here's my tid bit.

First off Roshini's words to Sid at the funeral. I personally think she was still in shock at the time. I mean really the girls been through hell of a ride over the past year or so. Let's recap a little bit.

Losing her father shortly after finding him, losing her child, losing her husband temporary due to her psychotic sister, then losing her memory and then the whole psycho Yash. Where first they were put through a sick game, then her adopted daughter is kidnaped and then her mother loses her memory and finally her life that too in front of her eyes.

Whew, that gave ME a whiplash!😲 Such drama honestly. 😆 I mean after all of this anyone would lose their mind.

Roshini was in shock at the time. I mean she did watch her mother fall to her death by slipping through her husbands hands and the first thing that was said to her right after were psycho Yash's psycho words. Things like this tend to stick to a person minds and the combination can make people believe or say things they don't really mean. I mean we so often end up saying things we don't mean or mean differently then how others interpret it.
I don't think she blames Sid for DD's death or the problems in her life even though Sid and his family thought of it that way. I think she holds herself responsible for it. She blames her love and by extension their love. It's messed up yes and it may not make sense but to a degree I can see where she's coming from. And as I said trauma messes up peoples minds. It blurs their idea of right and wrong, until everything becomes a hazy pile of mess in your head.

She clearly still loves him but she doesn't want to love him. Probably because he reminds her of what she's lost. In my opinion she blames and hates herself more than anyone else because Yash harmed her family, put Sid in that situation because of her. She may have left because she didn't want to hurt anyone anymore. (i.e. Sid)

This is of course one scenario, a more realistic one, but since this is a drama I don't know if the writers ever take that way. Simiran's involvement is a plausible theory too. I don't think she knows Roshini is alive but Its possible that Roshini came to apologize after the funeral and Simiran sent her away. That's why she never came back.

I also want to add that since Roshini is a made up character and writers tend to leave very large loopholes in characterization and plots, in the end the reason may turn out to be complete and utter garbage that will make no sense what so ever

I guess we have no choice but to hang on and wait to find out. Either way I can't wait for some kickass Sdi-Rosh scenes.

Cheers all and have a fantastic weekend

Em

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

538

Users

8

Likes

46

Frequent Posters

abinaya98 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
nicely wriitten👏👏
welcome to d forum..do make more posts pls..😊🤗
even i feel d same that roshni thinks becaz of her and her love ..more troubles can come and can harm sid...and simmi too can be reason..lets see wat way cvs take d route of d story..
m also wiaitng for sidni meet..
😳😳
Just_Smile thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
welcome to the forum dear🤗 our forum mirchi girl aka prathe also gave same sort of theory for roshni😛lets see how story unfolds n how cvs will show roshnis pov😊
athniamanvi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
wow i love the way you explained it so well and it is possible that simmi must have sent her away ...but cant believe this cvc 👏👏👏
just love your pov 👏
rosesidni thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Welcome to the forum dear.. Good to see many silent members making posts for and against Roshni😛
Anyway, what u said is perfectly fine and I agree to a great extent.. But the isuue is it is purely a Roshni POV😕 It don't consider anyone else..

Here majority doesn't have an issue with what Roshni said to Sid on funeral, it was very wrong of her but considering her shock state almost all are ready to forgive including Sid. Now, my problem is with Roshni blaming her love or their love for so long,( for me its same as blaming Sid).. I agree Roshni had suffered much, but what about Sid?😕 He have suffered equally or more just b'coz of his falling in love with Roshni.. still he has never blamed her or their relation.. What I can't digest in this entire fiasco is Roshni was not able to get over her emotion and think about Sid atleast once in these 2 yrs😕 For me that is SELFISHNESS.. DD was the same.. DD always thought about ONLY her ego, her hurt and her emotions.. never did she thought about what the other person will feel or what hell he is going through.. Same is with Roshni, she cared only about her emotions all these years & was punishing Sid for something he didn't do.. That is not love for me.. Roshni's love for Sid was so belittled by this🥱

We can always justify a character giving circumstance as excuses.. There are many who justified DD and Simran's psychoness too.. But in a pure love story like SidNi, these reasons won't be enough for people to like Roshni again.. Writers need to come up with something substantial to show Roshni loved or cared about Sid in these 2yr
Edited by rosesidni - 9 years ago
Water_Angel thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: rosesidni

Welcome to the forum dear.. Good to see many silent members making posts for and against Roshni😛

Anyway, what u said is perfectly fine and I agree to a great extent.. But the isuue is it is purely a Roshni POV😕 It don't consider anyone else..

Here majority doesn't have an issue with what Roshni said to Sid on funeral, it was very wrong of her but considering her shock state almost all are ready to forgive including Sid. Now, my problem is with Roshni blaming her love or their love for so long,( for me its same as blaming Sid).. I agree Roshni had suffered much, but what about Sid?😕 He have suffered equally or more just b'coz of his falling in love with Roshni.. still he has never blamed her or their relation.. What I can't digest in this entire fiasco is Roshni was not able to get over her emotion and think about Sid atleast once in these 2 yrs😕 For me that is SELFISHNESS.. DD was the same.. DD always thought about ONLY her ego, her hurt and her emotions.. never did she thought about what the other person will feel or what hell he is going through.. Same is with Roshni, she cared only about her emotions all these years & was punishing Sid for something he didn't do.. That is not love for me.. Roshni's love for Sid was so belittled by this🥱

We can always justify a character giving circumstance as excuses.. There are many who justified DD and Simran's psychoness too.. But in a pure love story like SidNi, these reasons won't be enough for people to like Roshni again.. Writers need to come up with something substantial to show Roshni loved or cared about Sid in these 2yr


You're right! What bout Sid? Cuz he also suffered a lot bcuz of roshni's family but he never complained to Roshni unlike Roshni for whom Sid is a punching bag( every freaking time). But I guess, this is the difference between Sid and Roshni, one is Selfless and one is Selfish. 😕
skinnypal thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
I agree she was in shock she said mean stuff to Sid in the funeral, went away leaving him... but after 2 years is she still in shock? I will not agree to that. Never. Ever. She is wrong in leaving him. She is wrong in thinking that Sid killed her mom, their love killed her mom. She is just too egoistic like always to accept her mistake. Till Sid will make her realize that she had done a mistake she will never understand.
Water_Angel thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Welcome to the forum! 😊 And bout ur post it's very apt and so much similar to my post regarding this whole "Roshni blaming Sid" fiasco. 😆
And I agree, Roshni has been thru a lot and so has Sid too, but there's a difference between both the characters is that, one complains and one doesn't. 😕 And I agree to ur point that Roshni might have went away thinking so that more troubles aren't created for Sid(which is good if she thought that way), but this is how we think ryt? Writers ka kya bharosa, they might not be that creative. 😆
I think it all will come down to the face off of SidNi, then we might get a clear picture of Roshni's feelings for Sid, after two years. 😊
Currently enjoying this season 2, and I'm sure a lot of things is gonna unfold after Dev comes into the scenario.
P.S And feel free to make post, dear! Everyone's opinion is welcomed!😊
skinnypal thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Ohh and welcome to the forum! :P

So many new members here post new Season! :) Have fun and enjoy :)
Water_Angel thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: skinnypal

I agree she was in shock she said mean stuff to Sid in the funeral, went away leaving him... but after 2 years is she still in shock? I will not agree to that. Never. Ever. She is wrong in leaving him. She is wrong in thinking that Sid killed her mom, their love killed her mom. She is just too egoistic like always to accept her mistake. Till Sid will make her realize that she had done a mistake she will never understand.


Exactly. My point is u cant be in shock for two effing years. 😆 Like come on, Roshni might have come back to her senses ryt? If so, she might well know that Yash's plan was to separate them(and he did), hence he spoke all rubbish bout Sid killing DD( according to us, which is also true), then my ques is when Roshni knws what Yash wanted that time, then how cud she still believe him after being sober?(unless there's a reason that pushed her away, maybe) 😆😆
Moreover, Roshni ryt now is a mirror image of what DD used to be, egoistic and ruthless. 😆
The writers shud give us Roshni's clear POV, tabh kuch keh sakta hai hum. 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".