Let's take SidNi's history into account...the guy has ACCEPTED everything for the girl he loves. He Faced obstacles to win her over, went through severe hardships just to keep her in his life & then went through hell when she left him. I'm not going to doubt Sid just yet.
If we take Sid's current actions on face value then yes, it seems harsh & uncalled for. But I am willing to give him the benefit of doubt because he is Sid Khurana. His love for Roshni has always been unconditional.
If I am proven wrong & CVs are creating a big blunder by butchering Sid into a typical daily soap hero that showers his love on his woman by emotionally torturing her, then I will take my words back & will be the first to condemn him. But at present the situation is very unclear. I would rather wait before I get the daggers out!