Fighting for the show was wrong. Really? - Page 17

Originally posted by: rima

so what stopped you

why did you noot raise your voice

and thanks for the earlier likes

Originally posted by: nottie

i give up rima,there is no winning with u but then ur so estatatic with victory that u dont feel even an ounce of sadness for ruining somebody's career...
N yes m at fault here,i agree,u acted u got what u wanted,i dint so i lost...

Originally posted by: -SmileAway-

Rima, with all due respect a lot of people came clear to you as to why they were pissed about the petitions, and you back-tracking.

I always respected you as a senior member of the forum, which is why I had the courtesy to not go around bombarding your petitions with my own views of why it was wrong, but now that you are asking me why i don't like what you did, here it goes:

1. You, yourself said, that you are the voice of all the fans asking you to make a petition. Then why not handle the criticism that comes to you? Essentially if we are criticising your petitions, we are criticising the other fans as well. Not only that but if you make a post from your account - you become liable for whatever happens.

2. We did not make petitions to stop anything, because I, for one, do not like interfering in the lives of others. However i did vent my frustration in the frustration thread, and voiced my opinions wherever possible instead of scarfing them down SP's throat. We understood this was a fictional show, and petitioning and interfering with every decision made was interfering with the creative ability of the makers. I understand that they have done a shitty job, however no one told you to take the reigns of the show and direct it according to your liking.
Someone had pointed out in one of your petition before (which you had nicely ignored) that whatever you want is not necessarily what everyone wants. Therefore consider the other section of fans before demanding stuff and saying "this is what everyone wants"

3. As for your other demands not being met, maybe it's because it was close to impossible? Retaining Barun when he doesn't want to continue?
Asking channel to change PH as though it's cake and can be handed off to anyone - even though the PH would never give their show away in such a manner.
Therefore the only option left (from your demands) was to close the show.

4. We are not saying you are a Prime Minister that you snap your fingers and the channel gets to your beck and call. However you cannot deny that the force all the fans used on the PH to get their demands met has definitely been a catalyst in what has happened. And that is what's annoying as I wanted the show to meet a natural end rather than a forced one which has happened just now.

5. The viewers had every right to not watch the show once Sobti left. But they never exercised that right, rather they assumed that once Sobti left - show must end regardless of the other workers. If Sanaya was leaving and the same was happening, I would be equally pissed, because actors individually do not make the show, everyone has a team effort to play. And if one of the members go missing, the others put in extra effort to keep it going rather than throwing their hands up in the air adn quitting.
And the fans forced them to do the latter, which I find extremely unfair.

Therefore, we are not targeting you personally - even though some of your statements have contradicted one another - we are questioning every fan who demanded for the closure of this show. And since you yourself said that you are the spokesperson of all those fans - the questions fall upon you.

Originally posted by: Closetarshi

Why do u need approval of others? Opinion will always be divided. You did what you thought you deserve as an audience and fought for it. If a section wants ,something else, they may do the same.

And finally ,it is a competitive market, wherein if a product becomes shoddy, it has to go sooner or later. There are many serials,concepts waiting to topple each other and no one is guaranteed a permanent run. That is true for all industries. Don't understand why does the question arise of viewers thinking about how jobless crew will be?

When you buy a cell phone and it does not work, do you keep going back to the same brand thinking the people working for it should be employed?

Originally posted by: SrijhaSobti

U need to get over your ego girl! You started this, be prepared to face the criticism

Originally posted by: nonasi

Agreed.

What I don't understand is why this post was necessary. The original thread from which all those links in the main post were from was shut down for a reason (I'd like for the original post made by Rima to be just as easily accessible to everyone here as well; then it may be clearer as to why people were upset). This is now just rehashing what had essentially become a moot point.

The main point of contention for me is that the forum has been filled with conspiracy theories, spamming SP, vaghera vaghera topics for weeks now. Coming to the forum became an exercise in futility and extreme frustration because no one a) really seemed to understand what the consequences of their demands would be and b) no matter how hard you tried to speak reasonably to calm the masses down, it had no effect. The only option many saw fit was to steer clear of this mess until the dust settled...but it never did.

My personal preference was for the show to end on a high note, with A-K, preferably played by BS and SI. However, I had been excited to see where they would go with Viraf's entry. Instead, on Monday, I discover the show is ending on Friday and that the forum is now trying to save the show. For God's sake, if you didn't want it to end so abruptly, you should've a) never included that in your demands as an option and b) realised that this is SP; they end shows without a second thought.

I'm not saying that the fans are responsible for the show ending, but you can't deny that by the looks of it, they were a catalyst for the show ending in what is now less than four days' time.

Originally posted by: LuvuKhushi

ego??? frm whr did this cum???

what the hell ... 😡 😡 😡

Originally posted by: ipkknd_2011

Rima, I am sorry so many people have suddenly crawled out to mock you and have become down right rude.

What you did, you did for your conscience. You had the integrity to stand by what your conviction was. That's more than most can say on this forum!

God knows, I have not agreed with all your posts, but I have always appreciated your single minded actions towards what you believed in!

Its funny, I made a post on the basherz dori yesterday, that I had half the mind to tell you that I am your "delusional twin sister", because like you, I refuse to believe what is being said in the media. There is a lot more to it all than meets the eye and I hate it that people are now baying for Barun's blood.

What happened is not because of only one person. The channel and PH had a lot to do with it and we the fans definitely had no hand in ti!