Sorry- mods please close this topic - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.6k

Users

17

Likes

110

Frequent Posters

617251 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: tptwi


Bravo! Well said, someone here understands the difference between negativity and realistic observation.


Cant realistic observation be done in a more friendly way without saying the show should end or calling it crap? Cant it be done with a little more appreciation?
Edited by tptwi - 13 years ago
...pinky... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
100% agree with you! This show is awesome!
Neha435 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: tptwi


yaar i respect your opinion and i know that everyone has the right to give their opinions.
i have no problem with that! im not trying to put a lock on everyone's mouth!
there is a difference between stating that you dislike something and constantly making posts that the show should end or sarun should quit the show or saying that the show is crap.



but arent there constant posts about Barun/ASR and other characters of how good they are? we post over and over and over and over again stating each tiny little detail, even how many breathes they took when we are absolountly mesmerized and amazed and breathless about it!!! So why such a different thinking towards negative feedback? Yes some people rant, but then this is a forum let them rant, they are here to show their fustration, the same people will show their love if they like the show, if they didnt love the show, they wouldnt be on this forum to rant over how to make it better!! Just like others shower love over it some give constructive/a little harsh opinion over it. Not 100% every one will like it, like I said everyone's brain operates differently so let them everyone speak their mind no matter what it is, if it is very harsh it will be locked up, just chill and let the forum be, that will make it an amazing place for all, not just for those who are fanatics
Edited by ArnaavKhushi22 - 13 years ago
roldc thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
I do appreciate your post. However, there was nothing in the episode today to say "I am dead" or "Mindblowing".

Many in fandom are disappointed today as we looked forward to a brilliant episode. How many fans would actually watch today's episode again and again?

I am a diehard fan of IPK since day 1 and I have every right to applaud a mind blowing episode and also express my disappointment with an average or below average episode. I will continue to watch the show till the day it breathes it's last (which I sincerely hope will not happen in the near future).

Audience can switch channels and shows with a click of their remote control. It's very easy to do that but diehard fans will remain with IPK till the end.

So when you are on the forum just be ready to accept positivity as well as negativity. All minds are not alike and will have different opinions always.

geetmaanluv thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
i respect other peoples opinion but i think they are too overly critical of a daily soap. they have cater to a larger auidence an not just few who want a mature romantic love story. its an SP show at 8 pm. dadi anjali and shyam are part of the package. i liked the episode the attention was on arhi and the rest were in the background.

i thikn they are listing to the auidence.. the lead got away alone for a while . they are dressing both better especially khushi. and hopefully they will cont the spotlight on arhi
617251 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: roldc

I do appreciate your post. However, there was nothing in the episode today to say "I am dead" or "Mindblowing".

Many in fandom are disappointed today as we looked forward to a brilliant episode. How many fans would actually watch today's episode again and again?

I am a diehard fan of IPK since day 1 and I have every right to applaud a mind blowing episode and also express my disappointment with an average or below average episode. I will continue to watch the show till the day it breathes it's last (which I sincerely hope will not happen in the near future).

Audience can switch channels and shows with a click of their remote control. It's very easy to do that but diehard fans will remain with IPK till the end.

So when you are on the forum just be ready to accept positivity as well as negativity. All minds are not alike and will have different opinions always.


Every fan has full right to express their disappointment, but cant that disappointment be expressed in a more positive way than saying "the show should end" or "the show is crap"
sammi5 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
You have stated your points and it is well written. I respect your point of view but I have to say that I respectfully disagree with parts of your post. Most people are very disappointed with the track because this is what we all lived in anticipation for, Arnav and Khushi declaring their love for each other, finally admitting it, they did but it always with interruption, I do understand that Angali needs her storyline to be advanced but, did it have to be at this time, couldn't we have had it after the wedding, couldn't we have had these rituals without Shyam and Angali in Khushi and Arnav's space all the time, their first date did Shyam and Anjali have to be their, yes I understand it is all leading up to Arnav's past and it is the foundation of why we have a serial, it is still not justifying why it has to be now, allow the wedding and its ritual, give Khushi and Arnav their time, why should Khushi have to have her Mendhi on the same day as Anjali's baby shower, why should she have to share this and also Shyam lurking around to cause destruction, this is why people are disappointed, the spark they are getting is so sparce before you blink their scene is over, this date should be Khushi and Arnav, not shared with Angali and Shyam, this is why people who are of a different opinion from yours states it on the Forum and it is not fair to say they are bashing or being critical, turning the table around it would seem like you are saying to us who differ from you that why can't we just put up and shut up, just accept what is shown, just to keep this serial on the air, well I can tell you that my mindset will not accept the put up and shut up mentality, it is an open Forum where one is giving the opportunity to have an opinion stated and just as you gave yours rightfully so others are doing the same. Just a different way of looking at this scenario.
rightknell11 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

I will repeat here what I said in a previous post.

Arnav and Khushi have become great because of the the script, screenplay and the dialogues.

Who does not forget Khushi lashing out at Arnav saying, "Baadh mein gaye aap aur bhaad mein gayee aapki naukri. Hum aapke vajeh se theek nahi hain, balke aapke bawajood bhi theek hain".

Who doesn't forget Arnav telling Khushi at their confrontation at the hotel when Payash came to meet: "Mujhe mere bhai ko halwai banane ka koi shaoq nahi".

Such wonderful, powerful dialogues. Such brilliant writing, stars emerge from a good combination of script, screenplay and dialogues. You know why? because the dialogues are the true reflection of the script and they are spoken at the right time - when there is a good tight dcreenplay - gracing the story.

This is exactly the reason why Arnav and Khushi have been etched in our memories and for a long time to come.

When the coordination amongst these three loses its steam, then obviously the characters begin to look as faltering. This is no offence to the actors themselves because they are telling lines that they have been asked to render.

So a lot of reponsibility goes to the CVs because if they create a faulty storyline, then the screenplay will have to be stretched because the story says so. And if the screenplay is stretched then the dialogues won;t seem as punchy because there is a pause to the story. And so I said that if I were Arnav and Khushi I would quit because I cannot be tolerated as a bad actor.

To this, somebody has blown my words waaay out of proportion.

I am an IPKKND fan, but I am not a liar.

Edited by rightknell11 - 13 years ago
roldc thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: tptwi


Every fan has full right to express their disappointment, but cant that disappointment be expressed in a more positive way than saying "the show should end" or "the show is crap"

CDlove thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#20
I've been in this forum for a very long time and one reason for the forum to react this way is when the show is honestly not cartering to the sentiments of the larger part of IPK audience. When the show does well (during diwali era, payash sangeeth mehendi era etc) the forum was a collective entity of praise, appreciation, decoding and analysing posts.
One must always remember this show is different and IPK audience is different from the rest. So when it does not deliver, the forum errupts with criticism and negative feedback.
More than telling the rest of the forum to stop wathcing the show or tell them to put a sock on it and quit with the complaining, we muct realise that the show is doing something wrong for more than half of us to react in this manner. AT least this way, if the creatives visit this forum they will know things are not all well and they need to buck up and get their act together.
It's a forum and the most active, vociferous forum in IF with a different set of viewers. They will criticise when they dont like the episode.
The creatives of the show needs to show better content and make these people satisfied, then the complaining will stop.

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: ramya4barun · 4 months ago

Hi. I am looking for a set of Arshi works- all by a single writer including FF's, OS and SS. 1.FF- Shahi Gupta is mentor of Arnav. When shahi...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: sk62 · 4 months ago

Hiw to upload stories in this page?

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".