Respect the relationship - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

152

Views

10.5k

Users

45

Likes

597

Frequent Posters

slanka thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#71
Loved ur sensible post!👏


This proved the phrases:
---THE SISTER IS NEXT TO MOTHER
----THE SISTER IS PROTECTED BY THE BROTHER!!


(P.s.the comment was shifted to page one)
Edited by slanka - 13 years ago
SillyPepper thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: barunroxx7

I think what I dont like about Anjali is the she is super selfish..Always thinking about herself..Doesnt she want her brother to move on ? Why does she want her bro to do rona dhona for Shymoo like her ? 🥱



Exactly ! I was like "What the" over tum pyaar main ho, tum mujhe bhool gaye ho...Seriously, that chap was kidnapped, was almost killed along with his wife, she faced some reality about "duniya main sabse accha pati" and her reaction is this...come, weep with me for I was betrayed by a lech 😕

She is self absorbed, dwell in bubble, clingy lady
ranjitha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: cindrella255



Indeed it is the mindset

Arnav- buaji is one track that I adore very much(but I wish there is some consistency...she accuses Khushi, forces engagement with Shyam, shove Kh's orphan status in no time and conveniently forgets everything)



both of them have a great comic timing and that works for me... but consistency? high expectation my dear 😆 all I know is, someday Arnav will find a mom in Buaji and not Garima 😃
vaatuhaara thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: cindrella255




Sanju, Advice is the cheapest thing , so one can give bhashan...after all,it's free...but in this same forum several labels were 2 given to those who like ASR... teeny boppers, hormonal teens,arselickers to name a few...people did not think that liking a character and supporting is their POV...funny dat no one thought it was passing judgement on others...none those who preach about moral policing raised voice then...but when things are other way around, automatically u become moral police... what ever floats their bloat...
@ TM - Glad u made this topic...I agree that the portrayal by CVs is not something excellent but making such comments won't make us any better...and honestly I don't find anything wrong in hugging or touching cheeks of brother...I do that and we are grown ups...we even pull other's hair for fun... but some people really amaze me

Edited to add-

I will not be surprised if this thread gets closed soon...sorry for saying this TM





yes dear.. I knw! I'm someone who gets 'constructivly criticisd' everyday!😉 n has a 'naamkaran' everyday..hehe. I knw i cant prevent such posts, bt there may be innocent souls who 'like' n 'encourage' such topics thinking its fun, without knwing, they r in a trap.. If we can collectivly reduce '1 Like' frm such posts, i wil be glad.. Its not to insult any member, dats y no names r said here.
.Sad.But.True. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: cindrella255



Exactly ! I was like "What the" over tum pyaar main ho, tum mujhe bhool gaye ho...Seriously, that chap was kidnapped, was almost killed along with his wife, she faced some reality about "duniya main sabse accha pati" and her reaction is this...come, weep with me for I was betrayed by a lech 😕

She is self absorbed, dwell in bubble, clingy lady

@BOLD Ditto ! 😊
SillyPepper thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: ranjitha



both of them have a great comic timing and that works for me... but consistency? high expectation my dear 😆 all I know is, someday Arnav will find a mom in Buaji and not Garima 😃



I know

But I love their scenes...ditto about the last part
Barunkidewani thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#77
I agree with you...😳 👍🏼
I too have seen the comments regarding their bond...
Thanks for your post...😃
SunoNa123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#78
Agree with u completely jachu 👍🏼 .. U said it all.👏

will get back.. 😳
mpk2011 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#79



The thread seems to have taken a turn in the past one hr and it is really amazing to see that there is still defense for the indecent comments that have been made on the relationship of siblings.

Firstly, since the original post by the TM clearly mentioned that the post is not directed to Arnav-Anjali relationship and is more a general post on the sibling relationship, I don't see any reason why the cvs, or actors or portrayal of the scene has to be brought into the picture. This is because in this case the word perception will mean the way anybody thinks about this relation in general independent of its portrayal in the show. If somebody has not seen such a relation or to be precise the proximity in such a relationship then they may not understand it (though I personally believe that it is not required to have a firsthand experience of a thing in order understand it), but it is surely not right on their part to try and paint such a relationship in a bad light !!!!

Secondly, since I am seeing the portrayal of the scenes between Arnav and Anjali has been brought into picture in this thread I would like to say certain things.

Even if the projection or portrayal is concerned there is absolutely no problem as far as I can see.

Consider the two scenes (which actually created an uproar in the forum!!), in one episode Khushi while pretending to be sleeping held Arnav's hand when he tried to got up and go. The next episode Anjali held his hand when he left her in her room. It is the gesture (read holding the hand) which was the same and not the inner meaning, and I am sure that intelligent audience of 2012 are smart enough to make that out. Arnav definitely have reciprocated to both of them differently and we have seen that!!!

If Arnav had his mom and he used to hug her then what would have been the reaction of people ? Would they have still said that it is disgusting ? Nope, cause the age gap is bigger in that case !! Unfortunately, people still have the mentality of weighing everything with the scale of age. If an elder says something and a younger person disobeys then ppl say that the person disrespects the elder and the elder must be right coz well just because he/she is an elder and 'should' be more experienced. That however is not true in the present world!!!

The same is true with the relationship also, the age or age gap doesn't matter, what matters is the way somebody thinks about it !

As far as carrying Anjali to her room was concerned, that was totally a medical emergency, it was either Arnav or Akaash who could have carried her to her room, coz I can't make out how nani, maami, payal, khushi or laxmi could have done that!! Why nobody complained when a healthy Khushi ji with both legs intact and without any physical weakness was carried to her bed just a day b4 ? Just because it gave a visual treat to the audience of watching the proximity between the leads, right ?

As far as the sonography report was concerned, when normal ppl have to share the big joys or sorrows of their life then the first person they remember is the one whom they love the most and here by love I mean 'being close to heart', no hidden meaning please !!!

riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: dmgloverforever

I agree with what you said. A brother and sister share the most refined relations of all and its only immoral to point fingers at it. BUT , There's always a but! lol I wont necessarily blame the audience for not understanding Arnav and Anjali's relationship in particular because to be honest I don't really get it either.


For a regular audience, Who are use to seeing brothers and sisters as nok-jhok buddies, always pulling pranks but still caring. Anjali and Arnav's relationship is rather new. Here are two siblings who just have each other to depend on , to rely on. These two will definitely have a different bond then "normal" parented brothers & sisters. Its a whole new concept and if not introduced properly could lead to conflict. And CVs by all means failed to portray the pulchritude of this sacred bond.

My grandparents passed away when my mom was just in 10th grade and ever since their death My uncle, who was a college graduate at the time has been responsible for my mother. So, I know what an orphan sibling bond is like And its definitely not like the one we see in IPK. not as melodramatic at least. Yes there is interdependence and insecurity but NOT to this EXTENT, especially after you're married. And showing otherwise is just giving the wrong message.

Another thing that badgers me about their relationship is the mere portrayal of Anjali.She is the older sister , So considering the matter of course she should've been the more responsible one rather then the over depending one. The older sibling is usually the one that makes sacrifices and not the other way around but Just to give Arnav's character all the glory CVs besmirched Anjali's role, A role of an older sister.

So , I'll say it again, Yes its wrong to point fingers at a pure relationship but you cant really blame the viewers for doing so in this case as the sibling bond portrayed in the show is quite muddled up within itself to be honest. So don't take offence when people sometimes cross the line as its merely due to the confusion and frustration caused by CVs not because they are cavemen and don't understand the significance of a relationship as pure as that of a brother and sister.














I just could nt understand what you were trying to say actually - u are justifying those people who call bro-sis bond with disgusting name if brother carries a weak sister in his arms to her room or if she hugs her brother when needed support.In real life also when you have age difference of many years between them one take position of parent in other's life and it is very common..
Anjali is weak person and is an emotionally handicapped person too ..If such a person needs a support in her life what wrong in that...and there have been times when she has been support and mother figure too for arnav but at this moment when she needs his brother support,why cant she ask for it...
Edited by riti4u - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".