IP REDUX; Smoke Signals !! Second thread

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Supna9

@Supna9

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#591

Originally posted by: Lizzy2012

See.. The thread has seen only bashing for the last three days,I understand the exceution issues..but did any of u point the positives.. There were positives too.. Am I right.?

plz geet whatever problem say to me i v 10 min to go to sleep n mujhe 4 am pe again wake up na phir bhi i m here to listen u plz :-) if it show character then plz inn ki karan koi baat na bigaro plz dekho ye show n character tou ate jate rahain ge but friend ll never get n meet again

Quote

tanthya

@tanthya

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#592

Originally posted by: geetmaanluv

i agree with geet.. i would not characterize its as all out bashing but i think khushi character was under a very very critical eye. the way arnav and his actions are not analyzed but i thought... an this is what i thought.. people were not happy with sanaya performance of khushi but instead of saying that people kept talking abt khushi. so it got a little over board .. imo. for me khushi is a as interesting as arnav but her character development is not given the same treatment as arnav.

Ruks,

I have not said that Khushi was treated like a satin flower , what I have said is that many were disppointed with Khushi's PORTRAYAL n expressed what they wanted to see ...

Na, SI was not the issue here, the way Khushi was conceived was the issue here ..SI is always impeccable in comedy ... I do not think we commented on SI * Don't put a bomb n say that we commented on SI too 😊**

Ur last line is what we were discussing , Ruks and wondering WHY is Khushi not paid the same attention as Arnav?? it came out in tones of anger, frustration, disappointment, sadness, logic... but the underlying theme was same..WHY IS KHUSHI BEING NEGLECTED??

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

SunoNa123

@SunoNa123

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#593

Originally posted by: geetmaanluv

i agree with geet.. i would not characterize its as all out bashing but i think khushi character was under a very very critical eye. the way arnav and his actions are not analyzed but i thought... an this is what i thought.. people were not happy with sanaya performance of khushi but instead of saying that people kept talking abt khushi. so it got a little over board .. imo. for me khushi is a as interesting as arnav but her character development is not given the same treatment as arnav.

I beg to differ here. I was present when the discussions happened today and i dint come across a comment on sanaya. None spoke about her performance it was all about how kushi is being portrayed and how she should have been portrayed . the only comment i saw today about actors was they are nt groomed well and are nt given good clothes to wear which was told to PH and nt to actors again.

people did maintain the line between real and reel and spoke about the reel character Kushi.

Quote

Lizzy2012

@Lizzy2012

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#594

Originally posted by: Supna9

plz geet whatever problem say to me i v 10 min to go to sleep n mujhe 4 am pe again wake up na phir bhi i m here to listen u plz :-) if it show character then plz inn ki karan koi baat na bigaro plz dekho ye show n character tou ate jate rahain ge but friend ll never get n meet again

Supna.. You will always remain my friend.., u are such a sweet person .. Love u for that.. See positive aspects are not being discussed but negative aspects are highlighted.. When it is a show.. Then it should be discussion of both.. See the positive aspects remain in the analysis but negative fills the remaining 100 odd pages.

Quote

Lizzy2012

@Lizzy2012

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#595

Originally posted by: geetmaanluv

i agree with geet.. i would not characterize its as all out bashing but i think khushi character was under a very very critical eye. the way arnav and his actions are not analyzed but i thought... an this is what i thought.. people were not happy with sanaya performance of khushi but instead of saying that people kept talking abt khushi. so it got a little over board .. imo. for me khushi is a as interesting as arnav but her character development is not given the same treatment as arnav.

Thanks ruk.this is another issue I wanted to point out.. There was post about how SI cannot act in some scenes.. I found those posts too distasteful.. Everyactor has some area he has to work on..but time and time in the last month or so these comments have come out ..

Quote

Crazygd4

@Crazygd4

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

#596

Originally posted by: Lizzy2012

See.. The thread has seen only bashing for the last three days,I understand the exceution issues..but did any of u point the positives.. There were positives too.. Am I right.?

@lizzy2012 I'm totally new to this forum.. But a silent reader for a long time.. I'm glad that someone is bringing some sense to this whole anti-Khushi rantings...for god's sake people who are watching this show should know that this girl is an orphan/adopted/outsider ..and this is the way she's been protrayed all along..until she can rely on someone like her adoptive father(who never questioned her real intention.. I.e total understanding )which is yet for her to see in Arnav ... She is going to be like this till he opens up to her...

Sorry I couldnt control myself...

Quote

Supna9

@Supna9

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#597

Originally posted by: Lizzy2012

Supna.. You will always remain my friend.., u are such a sweet person .. Love u for that.. See positive aspects are not being discussed but negative aspects are highlighted.. When it is a show.. Then it should be discussion of both.. See the positive aspects remain in the analysis but negative fills the remaining 100 odd pages.

dekho geet abhi me too was against khushi but my little sis cnvinced me na we do discussion we r in some points agree n in some points nt but nt quit na . Tum humain convince karo agr hum nahi hotay tou bhi dil mat haro. Kyun k tum ne apne dil ki baat share ki yahi sab se achi suchi aur baat hoti hai. Jo tum sahi samjho usse kehne se kabhi na ruko agey tumhain pathar mile ya phool uss ki care na karo geet :-)

Quote

sonia_1

@sonia_1

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#598

Originally posted by: Nareshkota

DM is also confused after hearing such a selfless girl's heart..

it was real BS..

DM must have been so relieved when the selfless girl was katti with her🤣

Quote

lalsunvid

@lalsunvid

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#599

Originally posted by: tanthya

Thank You, Vidya...for a while I was wondering whether my eyes were playing tricks on me and that I was unable to sense the 'Negativity' in the threads...Thank You for restoring my faith that Redux although vented out , was not being a negative thread from past 3 days...

It was just not with Khushi alone...We neither liked the cry baby Anjali on the other hand or the way Akash was shown...

See Khushi's character is a lead and so came into a major scanner. Thats all...But as always Doodhs says they fail in execution...

Akash is the best example. Right from the beginning of IPK we have seen him speaking his heart.He is not like ASR who hides his feelings and gets away from a situation creating a rage. Akash has spoken his heart out...He let out his feelings to Anjali when she caught him attracted for Payal...he didn't want to hide his love for Payal ..went and proposed her ..He always stood up for Payal when she was insulted by his mother...but when his mother felt her insecurity due to Payal's arrival..he comforted her in a much genuine way... he hasn't even hesitated to speak up to ASR in few situations... He is a open person...so such a person cannot take these big things hidden lightly... Its absolutely true and understandable...

But how was it shown on - screen. We didn't even get a glimpse that he is hurt by Khushi and Payal's action instead felt him grey...Execution... ???

But Cv's can't commit this mistake with Khushi also...as she is a lead and some sensible actions should be shown w.r.t lead.