Note from Gautam Hegde - writer of IPKKND - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

203

Views

28k

Users

129

Likes

1.9k

Frequent Posters

anurao.66 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
I really want to tell you that you have such a fantastic show on your hands and you peeople dragged the show and introduced some irrelevant tracks. The script and story has to be so crisp and fast moving that the viewers will be on their edge of their seats to find out what is going to happen. If you drag a show then the viewer will loose interest and it is the creative team fault. Not the actor or the crew because they don't write the story or the screenplay. We will criticize the actors only when they act badly. When they are acting stupendously why will anyone not give them credit. we do give credit when it is due.

YOU HAVE A WONDERFUL BABY IN YOUR HANDS PLEASE DO NOT MURDER IT.




---------------------------------------------------
Life is too short, Enjoy it too the fullest,

Anu

Arhimaniac thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
Interesting Note...(was not expecting it though honestly)...I was sure that being public figures and catering to wide range of audiences you would be open and well used to both negative and constructive criticism...however proven wrong today all I would like to say is that what you perceive as constant criticism from your viewers is nothing but merely love for your Serial that prompts them to talk and try to give you a piece of their minds.

Why are you forgetting that these very people whom you are trying to point fingers at are those who praised your work and gushed over each and every episode of IPK in the first 9 months. There were comments like wow, mind-blowing how beautifully and aesthetically that scene was shot, how the CVs (notice CV not BS and SI) used all the 5 elements in the scene...be it the diwali sequence or the holi sequence...the praise, the pointers have always been there but you chose to be happy and be quiet about it...so why respond now??...I know you face a lot of issues at your front which we are not aware of but then again if leads dates are an issue I am sure you were aware of it for quite some time so the CVs should have planned accordingly...

Its your planning and your creativity that the leads bring life into...but if you plan to drag tracks Or butcher their characters (by forgetting that ASR is supposed to be ruthless and the post marriage track was supposed to be pain and angst for Khushi, not OTT comedy of 101 ways to irritate Arnav which he welcomed with open arms OR by forgetting that Shyam is supposed to be an evil creep, a lusting and obsessed villain who suddenly forgets that Khushi is in the same house as his and lies low and out of screen for God knows how many days) and not give the audience what they want they will complain and some will lose interest as well and move on...

As passionate as we all are about this serial we fear when it falls in the TRP charts...we hate to see such a beautiful creation spiral down and we hate to see the tracks that had been laid so beautifully being rushed now in order to save TRPs and close loops (most of which are going to be definitely discarded in the rush)...I am seriously hoping that you are not going to redeem Shyam and make him into an angel and we will get a repenting Arnav who needs to realize what havoc he has created in Khushi's life from the day he released the video footage...

All your fans or so called criticizers have been waiting patiently for the confession, repentance and Shyam's punishment for the past 11 months...please do not disappoint us...otherwise we will crib again and you will not like it...😊

My apologies if it hits a nerve but it is the truth...

Winston Churchill rightly said:

"Criticism may not be agreeable, but it is necessary. It fulfils the same function as pain in the human body. It calls attention to an unhealthy state of things."


So please take it positively and rectify the mistakes you have made (as you mentioned...this means you have realized them).

To Err is human but to keep erring is plain stupid 😊

Edited by Arhimaniac - 13 years ago
zainza thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
just knowing that you care so much as to take in our cribbing and respond is huge enough.we love your work and you're right about the fact that we as viewers easily blame the cvs for everything and dont give due appreciation.point taken about all the hard work and unforeseen problems and other restrictions.we wish you and the show all the best.hats off to the entire team of ipkknd, the only show i watch on star plus.
DMGFan-2b-not2b thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
Dear Gautam

Completely appreciate the rant, the tantrum and the need to tell the fans to back off! It must be terrible to put in all that work and find a bunch of ungrateful fans at your throat no matter what you do. And we are a particularly critical lot aren't we?

And I agree it's unfair to just appreciate the actors and criticise the Creatives cos frankly it's the characterisations that make a character come alive. ASR is ASR because of the way you guys have written him & of course the way Sobti has played him but I'd give you 60-70%of the credit. And of course each of those 80 people who toil to give us 30 mins of "entertainment" every day. They are, undoubtedly the unsung heroes! And need to be appreciated. And I say this with all sincerity & no underlying sarcasm.

But Gautum IPKKND is not just a labour of love / creativity but as you pointed out it's your Anna-datta and a product. No matter how hard you toil, if the product is not good enough it does not sell! Welcome to the real world !

Or ask Coke. A multiple million dollar business, in their wisdom, in 1985, chose to change the basic formulation of Coke. Tagged as better, tastier, healthier - they spent millions and a lot of intellectual time & effort in launching it. Alas the public didn't take to it, no matter how hard the team had worked, no matter the effort, no matter the hype. People just didn't like what the co had done to their favourite Coke! There was a huge hue & cry! So the mighty Coco-cola Mgt did what any sensible professional would do - issued a public apology and changed back to the old formula and Coke rules nmero uno even today!

Moral of the story is stick to the knitting, do what you do best keeping in mind what the consumer wants. Cos you may believe that you are doing a fantastic job but if the audience doesn't like it, it will not sell.

Sure every episode cannot b fabulous but must every other episode be completely mindless? Can not even one person out of the 80 ensure continuity? Can not even one person out of the 80 point out that you are frittering away the connect you had with the audience? Destroying the intensity that was IPPKKND?

So by all means rave & rant and take out your frustration with us - I see no reason why only we the fans should have that luxury.

But at the end of it, having vented everything out, go back to the drawing board, brainstorm, figure what had made things tick for the show, what made it work, where have you made mistakes & try and rectify them. Stop reacting to a handful of Internet viewers, instead focus your energies on the show.

You are lucky, you have fans who are passionate enough about the show to bother telling you their peeves. They will still be around whether it's for the story or for Barun & Sanaya but TRPs will not. And unfortunately IPKKND's longevity is determined by that not by either your or our rants!



Nmyra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Drwho

😃


How aptly and succinctly put, Nmyra, your entire post is so topical!

It makes me cringe every time they show ASR collapse because of not taking one dose of his anti diabetic medication, now I have never ever seen a person collapse because of not taking one dose in my entire life(& I have been alive a while😃). People with diabetes collapse if they take medication and don't eat, that is LIFE THREATENING!!! Some home work is much required.





Thank you Dr.W! I know what you mean i was all set to praise them on the almost accurate wording of the will and was like YAY they did their homework for once, and then they have him confidently sign over everything and i assure you one course of Property Law is enough to make me want to bash someone over the head for even suggesting that's possible, and i'm just a student!

The thing is fraudulent cases do happen despite legal measures but they are much more complex and believable -in TV contexts - think of how One Tree Hill dealt with Lucas Scott signing over book rights or Brook Davis on her adoption rights etc.

I wish they would make us want to scream and rant at the system instead of the script!
blue.kindle thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: spirit

GH Thank you for reaching out to the audience, your words convey the frustration that no doubt persists in your camp regarding the fate of the show, the current stalemate and let's face it, this unrelenting scrutiny by fans... Ouch! It must not be a good time to be a writer of a show under all sorts of scrutiny!

You speak of the cuss words but what of the love that has been showered upon the team - if the recent awards are any indication, it's pretty clear the viewers are not so mean as you make them sound. And you ask why? Viewers will respond why not! I agree you guys are virtually making a movie every week, if you go by that twisted logic, then I'm sure, so many people who watch your shows are making so many other meaningful things every week in their lives as well, but that's a lame excuse imo, what stopped you from using BS's limited time in a meaningful way rather than that silly romantic sequence the other day? Lack of ideas...? Or maybe the panic button... Why would you waste his precious availability in lame song and dance routine instead of something more logical, what stopped that?

The viewers respect your point of view, and appreciate all the hard work that goes into making of each episode but that is no reason to justify obvious mediocrity! -

Why was there no need to reach out to the audience when the show was climbing the charts?

Why was there no need to ask for audience ideas or make fun of them in that way, when you guys were presenting your story, in the way you wanted to at the start?

Because you guys stuck by your ideas and built it up nicely- stuck by your convictions ... and things always make more sense when you are convinced of your ideas, no matter how silly or filmi or cliched it may be, audience does lap it up. My suggestion is to stick by what you have conceived and be true to that, and not go on changing tracks, play with characterizations of your major characters, scripts as per demands. That will just end up messing your show, it's not our story to tell, it's yours, and only you can do justice to it, the best way.

Why the pressing need all of a sudden to defend things?

The other thing, which I think is seriously messing with your show, is all the publicity and by it, I mean all the bad publicity in recent times - what is the need for all those spoilers, pictures, insider info every day on this forum - are you not trying to gauge audience reaction? And whose reaction, those people who are least likely to contribute to your TRPs, those that do - will most likely not get those spoilers! See somewhere you are also benefitting from this interaction with the fans, and one which you have been using well, so it's a mutual thing, you've encouraged people to interact and provided them a platform to do that. It will obviously work both ways, pray tell me you knew it wasn't just the applause you were expecting your way! And this simple thing of BS taking a few days off should have remained just that ... what was the need for all those articles or interviews? Just too much publicity where it's not needed will only spoil things and put many people off. Just as you have invested into the show, so has the audience who watches your 'movie' every week. If its bad, well,...too bad, the ratings won't lie...either way!

And if you are a creative person or intend to be one, be prepared for the onslaught because everything you do will be scrutinized. And the nature of the medium...of your art ... is one where it[scrutiny] is inevitable. An artist who has no takers for his masterpiece, cannot whine on the podium saying, I spent x hours of my life working on this... so all you buggers have no right to criticize it. Hard work does not need to be stressed; it is evident from the final product because it will speak for itself. There is no alternate to that route...so stop ranting about that. Go back to your drawing board and if possible watch your show from the start to its last episode, do it objectively, if you are half as smart as you claim yourself to be, your product will speak for itself, and you'll know exactly what the audience has been complaining about. I can list out a few here, missing script..I'm sorry, it sounds mean I know but it really is one of the reasons, messed up characterizations, lack of adequate parallel tracks, not using all the supporting cast smartly ... at the moment they are like mere props... like those plastic pots by ASR's poolside...the thing that caught my eye first was the way you guys dealt with tracks, the resolution / treatment of issues was refreshing to say the least... you have no idea how many times i curse myself for watching this show, when you go on stretching this idiotic MU as if your show will collapse like a pack of cards the moment you resolve it. Wake up and smell the coffee, this stale MU [Terrace Misunderstanding] is what has infested your show...I could elaborate but then you get paid to do this not me. To be 'Senti' is good but learn to channelize it productively, and not get emotionally swayed. Let's not complain like a whiny kid!

As for the silly, fanatics, well that cannot be avoided given the internet and these internet forums - it's an inconvenience you'll have to learn to deal with the best way you can. But if it bugs you so much, just shut that fan page off for a month, and go back and work on your show without any outside influence, just the way you want to, have to and need to. Good luck in reviving a show, which can definitely fare better than its doing at the moment.

cheers,

-spirit-




I agree with what u have said, "Spirit"!

To GH ,

I mean it's really not fair to put the blame on the audience if your show is not doing well.You need to stop fooling the audience! We are too smart for the silly hide and seek game that you play. I am sure support characters can be used very intelligently provided you try to do so in the first place. Please stop making excuses! Don't give us nonsense like we would not want to ruin our show coz its our baby! well if it's ur baby u r responsible for it , or how u bring up ur child! Stop blaming and start taking responsibility for ur actions! we are no nincompoops! Wake up and smell the coffee!
CravingKhana thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Nmyra



Thank you Dr.W! I know what you mean i was all set to praise them on the almost accurate wording of the will and was like YAY they did their homework for once, and then they have him confidently sign over everything and i assure you one course of Property Law is enough to make me want to bash someone over the head for even suggesting that's possible, and i'm just a student!

The thing is fraudulent cases do happen despite legal measures but they are much more complex and believable -in TV contexts - think of how One Tree Hill dealt with Lucas Scott signing over book rights or Brook Davis on her adoption rights etc.

I wish they would make us want to scream and rant at the system instead of the script!

Nmyra...you dont need to go to school to just be a lil more aware of your facts ...thanx to the web you have google and its only a finger away (pardon the pun)...
besides indian land laws are the most complex ones around...
there are those like me who are atuned to indian entertainment who are even willing to overlook 'small' glitches like that ...if only they could consistantly stick to the story and scren play and charactor board...
for me the all time low was depicting Bali in a Hawaiian get up...now how hard is that...
Edited by tangam - 13 years ago
serialjunkie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
give me the flight details from Delhi to Scotland.

i need a vacation from this verbal diarrhea!!
Drwho thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Nmyra



Thank you Dr.W! I know what you mean i was all set to praise them on the almost accurate wording of the will and was like YAY they did their homework for once, and then they have him confidently sign over everything and i assure you one course of Property Law is enough to make me want to bash someone over the head for even suggesting that's possible, and i'm just a student!

The thing is fraudulent cases do happen despite legal measures but they are much more complex and believable -in TV contexts - think of how One Tree Hill dealt with Lucas Scott signing over book rights or Brook Davis on her adoption rights etc.

I wish they would make us want to scream and rant at the system instead of the script!


@ bold, big and red above, Exactly!!!

Why do I get the feeling that the Production house was somewhat unprepared for the phenomenon this show has become, they probably just wanted some, time pass moong phalli munching kind of show, watch it tonight from 8 till 8.30 and forget it instantly and move on to the next show on offer!!

And instead we are wanting to focus on serious issues and that is not something that they expected.
We have been overlooking such bloopers/goof ups as dramatic licence as long as everything else was brilliant and there was some continuity and credibility in the storyline! Now that the story has gone down the drain these things are even more glaringly obvious!!

The production team are like a painter being astounded by the exquisite masterpiece he/she has created and cannot understand why people are so heartbroken when they see it being destroyed in front of their eyes😭
Drwho thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: serialjunkie

give me the flight details from Delhi to Scotland.


i need a vacation from this verbal diarrhea!!


We regret to inform you, there is no flight from Delhi to Scotland !! or even from Mumbai to Scotland neither from Chennai nor Calcutta. 😭 😃





Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

1 months ago

#IPKKND/ArShi Poolside Moments/A splishin&splashin’/ I hate you/page 1

A splishin’ and a splashin’! A little bit of pool time is among the unforgettable ones Entangled meetings straight from Kisses to heartbreaks By...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

7 years ago

\\ #IPKKND Rewind //*Kahani Teri Meri*Episodes 170-300/Holi Gifs-pg 75

~Kahani Sirf Teri Meri~ Having you in my arms, a warm heart just cried Never thought of missing when tears were dried Your Eyes left with me...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

9 years ago

IPKKND Ek-Jashn / New Post/ Page 47/Nov 2023

Nov, 30th ...Can we forget this day? When our favorite show "Iss Pyar Ko Kya Naam Doon ..." Ended abruptly. It was painful for all of us not to...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

6 years ago

\\#IPKKND Rewind// "You're mine" / Episode 300 plus

I welcome you with my open heart Because you are my light, my sunshine I don't give a damn of right or wrong With this promise, I"l make you...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

1 years ago

#IPKKND/ Arshi Teri Meri Special/13th Anniversary/ Page 32/2025

Disclaimer : All images and writing belong to Mysticaldivine. Do not use without permission... 12 Years of Teri Meri Kahani 💕 Does she know I...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".