IP REDUX; OO-THA-HELL-O - Page 11

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Brilliant post Tanthya! Loved how you kept it simple and subtle and short and yet explained everything so well! *claps*! And yes - today was the return of IPKKND for me - and for everyone of us who has been a part of Redux and that was solely because of Shyam - and no one else. Remember I said yesterday that I have always wanted to see the Arnav - Khushi and Shyam equation - and finally we saw a beginning of it - and tomorrow more so ever. Like you - I keep my fingers crossed too!

Now I really was not thinking to do an analysis today - but I have u bookmarked on my phone and as soon as the clock turns 12 I am waiting for u to post! :D - and that is the effect REDUX has on me! I have never thanked u enough for creating this platform - I do so today! Thank You!! :))

Now coming to my analysis :

-- Okay - the first 7-8 mins were a drag! I know I do not expect them to show only the Raizada members performance but it felt like a drag. Then came the mami and Payal scene - somewhere I was happy that Mami and Payal were bonding - and Mami had started trusting Payal if not explicitly - but I knew it since Monday that Payal was going to screw it up. The reason in my opinion was stupid - how could they be so sure that the rivals would have won if not any of the Raizada's!? Lame Excuse!

I agree with you here,I really did not like the execution but I liked message but they could have used some thing different to give the message.

-- Secondly - when I said I would not like if Khushi called Arnav a dhokebaaz - I meant it. I did not like it - and I say that because I felt that the dialogue for the situation was wrong. She wanted someone else to win - I get that - but why call Arnav dhokebaaz!? I do not know. And yes - she did not do it to make Arnav angry because she had no idea he was listening. So here I was disappointed.

-- When the whole family was trying to cheer up Mami - It was only Arnav who stood by Payal. I may be reading a lot into this ( as usual) but when the truth comes out in front of the family - it will obviously strain Mami and Payal's already strained relationship and maybe Aakash's also. And that is when Arnav will be the only one standing in support of Payal and cover her up and only then will Aakash come to Payal. Frankly I loved the small scene of Arnav and Payal and I really really wish - that the creatives could develop a bond of Arnav and Payal - slowly and steadily. One important thing was Khushi was missing from the scene - she was not a part of either of the two frames.

Well, I think Anna, Mami will support Payal but Aakash will not. Payal will support Arnav and Khushi in revealing the truth. But when the time comes, it will be Arnav who will explain to Aakash the reason behind Payal's silence and bring them together.

-- The Green room scene - Loved like absolutely loved Khushi here This is the Khushi I love and adore and admire - the one who fights back with passion and intensity - not the one who uses 7 year old antics to trouble someone! Sanaya and Barun were brilliant here! Arnav needs to realize that Khushi is not going to back down. Just like he does not give her any answers - he does not deserve any too. It was a tit-for-tat scene and very well played. Even in this one scene - the understanding that Khushi has of Arnav and what his actions are going to be was quite evident. We saw that yesterday also when Khushi asked him to leave like he always does and we saw it again today! Brillaint creatives!

@bold blue - Totally agree...

Another thought would be that,when the time comes,Khushi will ask him to leave her for Anjali and he will leave her as he always does.😊

-- Anjali and Khushi scene - one thing I noticed was Khushi's kalerin got tangles in the dress - she could not free it herself - Anjali came and did it for her. Now is it possible that it will be Anjali who will end and free Khushi of all her troubles and pain when Khushi comes to know the reason behind Arnav's!? Ofcourse yes! She will be the 'sutradhaar' for these two always!

Brilliant Anna - Loved your analysis here.👏

-- Anjali fainting - Khushi concerned - Anjali calling Shyam and ordering him to go with her - frankly an illogical scene. Shyam is not a baby that he could not go alone - and Khushi is not a kid who could not request Anjali that she would go with Akash or someone else. But I get it - it was needed to build up the next setup. The medical store scene - as soon as Khushi left her handkerchief on the table - I knew what was gonna happen - but loved Khushi the way she rattled him up by calling him 'jeejaji' :D - Even the storeman was looking at Shyam - with the 'WHAT THE' look :D - Abhaas was good today and I was so glad to see him I cannot say. He kept it simple but was perfect.

- Precap - do not want to judge but Abhaas's expressions were fab! Hoping for a really good episode tomorrow! :)

-- edited--

@Doodhs : Love the conversation u have had with 4 lions and star plus! Yes they do lack strategic thinking - atleast I felt they did earlier on but I guess they are trying to come back on track - IPL asar obviously! But loved the points u have put up. However I do not see how Mami and Payal bond will grow stronger - because if they do not come to know of why Payal did what she did - Mami is not going to be able to trust Payal again. But I do hope u are right! :) Also love the brother and husband relation that you drew. The conflict is indeed between the brother Arnav and the lover Arnav.

@Pam : Loved ur post as usual Pam 😊 But I would dissgree on only one point : and that is the dhokebaaz point! Both Arnav and Khushi are cheats - they are cheating themselves and each other - but yesterday the situation did not demand it. I have no qualms about Khushi saying that she did not want the award with him - but calling him a cheat and that in public was out of the situation. It was not required. Is she would have said it on his face - it would have been better played. And u know what made it worse was Arnav's lack of reaction on Dhokebaaz - knowing Arnav he picks up on a word and creates a fuss and I did expect him to go directly on it! I would say nothing but poor writing.

Also - for me both Arnav and Khushi are at equal fault - Arnav a bit tad more because he still does not give Khushi the reason and has shattered all her hopes - but ultimately they both are! They both tried to play god and however right the reasons were - they were in the wrong. And that is why I seek repentance from both and not Arnav alone - and that is why I think - Khushi may not stay with Arnav but she will understand the reason behind his act and realize how big at fault even she was!

Love :))

P.S : Tanthya I also think BS is very very tired - he looked like hell today - not even fresh! He was good but there was something that I felt was definitely wrong! He needs rest I think - maybe relax a bit and shave or he would not be able to justify Arnav properly! Hope to see that change soone enough! :))

P.P.S : And guys you were discussing Humsafar one day - and I decided to watch it - and now I am addicted to it - hate you guys for it! ;P -- Nevertheless I love the title track - I love Khirad's character and she is the first woman character that made me cry - love Asher - hate the mom - love the direction and the simplicity everything! Thank you so much for discussing it here - nahi toh I would never have known! :))

Please do let me know if there are any other good pakistani serials - would love to watch them! :))

Yes,Anna I loved Khirad and Asher...She is one strong lady and love the title track too...Isn't Asher similar to Arnav, not ASR..😉.

Originally posted by: Ankifan

Anna i agree with u on the dhokebaz part.
When Kushi refused to take the prize it was coz of Payal, and to help the other women get money,
frustration on Arnav no where played here, she dint even knew he was listening, so why call him a dhokebaaz to and demean him in frnt of other's just to get ur work done???

Originally posted by: supermom1

Brilliant post Tantya, Doods and Pam0k. All of you are excellent writers, and am glad that I am part of this REDUX and get read all of your views and takes on what was shown and how the future tracks will be. I really do look forward to your PM everyday. @Doods...I am big fan of your writing...I must applaud you for the time and effort you take in writing the analysis everyday for people like me who would never even think the way you bring forth the actual message the story teller wants to give.

Hopefully, starting next week we will start seeing some movement in the story and someone I don't care who it is ARnav or Khushi one of them should start connecting the dots. I would prefer if Arnav starts first but again something needs to happen. Since yesterday Khushi has reached her boiling point and looks like she will not give up easily and will keep pushing Arnav to the edge till he blurts something out. I do want to see him repent, ask for forgivness, which we all know Khushi will do it easily. She is the one who will not keep grudges for too long especially with Arnav as she loves him dearly. Like Tantya mentioned they are picking up traits of their soulmates now, so Doods do you think that it is possible that because of all the hurt and pain Arnav is giving her, will there be a role reversal, where Khushi is the one who does not believe in love anymore as her heart has been broken numerous time. Will she start thinking more from brain and care about others feelings?

Since HOli the Guptas have not been shown, so when do you think they will come into picture? Will it be once Shyam's truth is out and Khushi leaves RM. So far in IPKKND Khushi and Arnav have not been separated (since they met) for more than a week. How long would this separation run as the whole story is based on them and their interactions. I am still trying to figure out how the PH will weave the past of ARnav, Anjali and Khushi. Who will play major role in bringing out the complete truth about Shyam? Would definitely like to know your thoughts on these.

Originally posted by: doodleberry

Heyyy Sweetie Pies ... Hugzzz 🤗

Tant will be a bit late that's what she told me to inform you all and she is mising here but kya karegi...phasi hui hain...😡

A BIG HUG From HER

🤗

Originally posted by: Zuzana

Hello all lovely gals here..hugz🤗

Originally posted by: Cool_wonder

@Doodls

I just wanted to say that I LOVED THE POINTS THAT YOU MENTIONED 👍🏼...

They were so apt...

Yes We love this show and along with positive comments we shuld also be honest critic and point out where the things are going wrong...Loved all your points..

@Tants

Fantastic analysis as always👍🏼

Originally posted by: Japonica

Great reply to Tanthya's brilliant post. We are on the road to hell, just hope it isn't a long one.

I've heard Dhoop Kinare is a great Pakistani serial, it is supposed to be brilliant, a friend can't stop praising it. Kuch to log kahenge, is, I believe, a remake of the show.