Heer dances Arnav cries, Khushi Qs? ASR replies

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

JWMRK

@JWMRK

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: riti4u
Hey I am back in your thread-😃 .. yes I found other acts apart from Heer ranjha a bit clumsy..the one they could have done without..👎🏼..wont waste my time on them..so back to scene I loved the most too.. Ranjha came in form when Heer died...that was arnav speaking his heart out.. and I so felt his emotion..specially when he says last lines...😭..I could sense his pain..and also felt his pain when in green room he lifted earring...he loves her so much..isnt this love a reason why we all are glued to the show.. Imagine under such Misunderstanding..if he could still love her like that..how strong is his love..he can not see her dying..even in act it seems..and yes khushi does understand his feeling to some extent..that lone tear from her eyes depicted that..and in green room also..she demanded his confession..when will this -first you then I continue..😆

Hiya riti😃

many thanks and good to interact again

to your bold...yes this is the reason at least I am still watching this😊

I got a feeling some of the screen shots were interchanged...that tear would have been more appropriate after either 'farak padta' or the last lines.

Seriously riti...I just want them to talk it and finish it once and for all...if we get comedy at the end of this week...all this fancy dress stuff will agan seem disjointed.

cheers!

Quote

JWMRK

@JWMRK

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: shanu.ami
First i thought that i will be mad at u for bashing the whole serial, but later i feel sorry for it, 😭, beautiful narration👏

😆😆 thanks😊

No not interested in bashing...real or reel

At best I critique the story or the treatment by creative team...beyond that not intested in counter arguing or defending😊..

.if at all I only explain my view...its the IF readers wish if they want to agree or not.😊...if they want to bash me ...what can I say😆😆

Edited by JWMRK - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

LuxCal

@LuxCal

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#23

Great analysis - the only piece I don't agree with is that Khushi also has a huge ego - I think its more insecurity than ego...she's always trying to make others happy and yearns to be loved...its her own emotional insecurity that checks her confession...but Arnav's actions are pushing her to the point of frustration which might force a confession from her soon

Quote

JWMRK

@JWMRK

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: mid-night-sun
well written

Thanks😊

Quote

JWMRK

@JWMRK

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: Ankifan

Awesome post again JW🤗 will edit back, me in a boring meeting nw🥱

🤗🤗...take your time...and sorry again dost...am a bit lost today at work

Quote

SillyPepper

@SillyPepper

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#26

Hey J!!!!!!!!!! The first few minutes of strday's epi were highly unforgettable...the Sholay spoof n Mughal-e-Azam act was so nursery types

U know my feeling towards this Heer-Ranjha act already...Whenever they give a hypothetical situation, a forced Slip-Fall scene,a wardrobe malfunction to prove us dat they love...our intelligence is being questioned...

And IPK being my first hindi daily(used 2 watch SGP...but it was nt able 2 hold my interest for more than a month!) , a totaly pragmatic , non M& B type person like me...the leads are the sole owner of the credits for whom I bear this shoddy script n cliche's!

So again, the eldest member of the family following sum school girlish plans n a baby carrying baby squeaking over it...Let me cover my brains in clouds!

Believe me I typed the SGP and one month thing b4 I read ur ASR thing...so yeah! the show picked up the pace one he made entry on the stage...And kudos 2 SI, she was brilliant strday be it on the spot dialogues or the Snarky "aap ki zindagi ke sabse acche ghadi aur Ranjha ke bure" ...but her costume n jewellery were tacky

And boy once she enacts death, it was Ranjha there...it was Arnav...wat a performance! I won't repeat the lines as u already quoted dat...it was beauuutifull...n drops of tears , it was so poignant...

And as much as I think Kh has ego (no, I m not against it)...I think she needs some sort of verbal confirmation cos of his hot n cold behaviour...

Yahaan na sahi, shayad kahi aur ek duniya hogi, jahaan tum aur main milenge

Kisi jhoot ka kisi sach ka'.koi matlab nahi

Jab jo Bura kiya, uska koi matlab nahi

Jab jo Bura kaha, uska koi matlab nahi

U said it...the first two lines depicting his wish and the following wat he is...beauuutifulll is an understatement

J again Touchwood...my Kh's jewellery tacky comment was typed b4 reading ur notes n feedback...I read a para n type reply simultaneously😆

I agree ur post whole heartedly...brilliantly put...

Dunno wat type of people Raizadas hang around with...all gossip mongers n sociopaths...And last para for Barun...hats off! I never thought I wud go crazy over an actor this much...be it luks, dialogue delivery...hell! even a muscle movement...I love it...if my admiration equals 2 teenage school girl crush for a few here...I give a hoot! And finally...Punjab da Sher in Sherwani...oye hoye...there s something apl abt gabru jawans in traditional suit...he s already spl...so specially special😆

Edited by cindrella255 - 13 years ago

Quote

AnnieARS

@AnnieARS

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#27

Your post echoed my feelings...I feel like giving up on IPKKND but its Just Sanaya and Barun who keep me hooked on...

I guess its the same episode director who directs SaRun, how come they are just perfectly imperfect when they are not dealing with SaRun and then when its SarRun scenes they are amazing...The inconsistency will surely take its toll...if not now, in the time to come..

Quote

SunoNa123

@SunoNa123

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#28

Originally posted by: JWMRK

🤗🤗...take your time...and sorry again dost...am a bit lost today at work

I was just pulling ur legs han😳 dosti main no sorry no thankoos😆

lost at work, Aww🤗

Edit: i edited my post in page3😃

Edited by Ankifan - 13 years ago

Quote

mommy2000

@mommy2000

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#29

JW!!! a spot on post once again!!! (I have now resorted to going to your tag to find your posts😃)

I must admit, i was cringing at the prospect of seeing ASR made to perform on stage in a fancy dress organized by the neighborhood kitty party. Khushi's basic character sketch allows such script but totally out of character for Arnav. But despite the cheesy-ness of the track, both did a fabulous job. They made the whole sequence belong to ArHi. I say, once again, I hope the makers know that caliber of the talent that they have.

Heartwrenching emoting by Arnav and fabulous confrontation by Khushi after --- she was asking the right questions. i really really hope that the CVees follow through on what they have started here. Forget the characters, they need to redeem themselves on every front - script, screenplay, direction and editing. They have a brilliant cast...the rest have a lot of catching up to do.

AWESOME post, my friend! And yes, I watch the show for the same reason u do!!😛

Quote

sman

@sman

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#30

loved ur analysis and loved heer ranjha .. only thing I want from Kushi is , instead of calling him ASR, try calling him "Mere Arnavji" once and see the difference..only thing that will work on him is emotional atyachar and not egoistic fights