IP REDUX ; Khamosh Dil Ki Dhadkan *Updtd* - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

665

Views

39k

Users

84

Likes

2.6k

Frequent Posters

Lizzy2012 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: slmu


</div>
<div>

Good question monsi. 😆Posion anyone???😆


Monsi,started masti early today 😉 Lage raho.
SunoNa123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
updated in page3

Sathya loved ur post🤗.. I love that song..

doods awesome post.. 🤗
I actually love the way u bth even find out when the actors are on and off.. It totally sums up ur analysis, u bth are so observant..

And i absolutely agree about nani and shyam.. What ever Nani did even before Anjali could count ll the manipulation's we knew how Nani trapped them, it was no surprise only Arnav and Kushi were dumbed down to nt knw it otherwise it was blah..

And shyam, his constipated expressions frm when kushi entered to the show ending was same, atleast he used to flare his nostrils while seeing Kushi-Arnav together today even that missed😆
He dint even smile when kushi came on stage, shyam was just sitting their as a expressionless constipated doll and nothing else..

The heer-ranjha initial lines could hv been better, it lacked the punch..

tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Shai

Hello ladies and gents... don;t anyone to feel ignored 😛

Tanthya ... when do you generally post your redux?

Very intense episode.

Initially, when I saw the dialog exchange... didnt like it one bit. It felt clinical... disconnected ...lacking passion. But then realised later... it was a skit and they were thinking on their feet. It was an impromptu act ... turning into their personal dialog.

I liked the way they both reminded each other that they were Heer and Ranjha on stage - trying to hide behind the mask.

"Jisko jee jaan se chahte hai .... " This part was Khushi. But the monologue that followed was Heer...probably voicing out Khushi's desires about love and marrying her love. But all of the her words hit Arnav at the right spot. The intensity was visible on his face.. his gaze. He realized somewhere he has killed all that Khushi desired.

Of course Khushi had to gibe at Arnav.. can;t miss that chance na😆... "Hum mar jayenge". That shot straight to his heart. Made Arnav realize - if Khushi was not in his life... he was nothing. It was Arnav on stage.. not Ranjha. He was speaking his heart out to Khushi.. not Heer. Khushi felt his love..even with her eyes closed.

But sadly he decided to shut down once again when the Khushi questioned him, Arnav not Ranjha, what he didnt finish on stage. I guess she wanted him to complete his sentence for validation - that it was Arnav not Ranjha who was saying those heartfelt words. It reminds me of the time diwali time. When Arnav almost kissed Khushi. At that moment she had questioned him "woh kya tha...aur humari payal aapke pass kaise"? and Arnav had rebuffed her. After all the La-Marriage hoopla...Arnav tried telling her while going back home and she had pretended ignorance and excitement about his engagement. Them circling the issue had resulted in so much of heartache. This time... khushi was more proactive..more daring... held his hand ... asked him directly..even then Arnav tried dodging the reply. It is quiet evident that khushi has reached her saturation point. Now she doesnt care what it means to anyone...the truth about loving him is waiting to burst out... and a right nudge is thats required. Arnav dude... your lady just wants to hear the word...stop fighting the lost battle.

Nani-Anjali donot really understand the depth of their action. They are assuming they helped two newy weds get over their tiff. In reality, they have become the biggest catalyst for Arnav Khushi to reach this point. Their love is evident to everyone...to themselves too. They are just unable to let their guards down - can't blame them after being hurt and shattered so many times.

There is a big argument looming just around corner...call is the "right nudge". I am really looking fwd to it.

I like the complexities they are showing. How easy it is to fall in love... and how difficult it to confess!

Phew... that was long rambling... interspersed with cooking.. feeding.. trying on new clothes .. scatterbrain can be my middle name 😃

Time to read other interesting analysis.



Shai,


Will say one thing..continue with ur cooking, feeding, trying on new clothes if we get such concise and to the point analysis😃
pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Lizzy2012

Very well written posts satya,bollywoodcrazed,Anna,shai,momma.
Just waiting for satya to complete and doods to write her analysis.

By the way good song selection satya for nothing can describe these two better thanthose lines.
Coming to Nani and Asr equation,the two are made of the same mould.Nani puts her fingers on ASR's weakness.like satya told us yesterday That asr has learned a bag of tricks frm her.but has Nani really sensed the magnitude of problem between Khushi and Arnav? What do you feel my mates?

Secondly I agree withsatya on the score that the acting and the direction were patchy at places.but for me the impact of the words in the sequence mitigated this lapse.I had tears in my eyes by the time the episode ended.

Khushi after listening to ASR's words starts to see a ray of hope about the sad state of her marriage but that hope dies an early death after Arnav's harsh word that he did it only for his family.so Khushi's frustration is at an all time high.shehas been driven to the edge .all this is indicative of some thing big going to happen. Do u all remember the guest house incident where Khushi is caught inside and what happened after that ? SHE BLASTED him for that in his house.so now khushi's emotions are on the boil again ...

I always wanted to ask this question to the cv's.why haven't they shown Khushi reading the letter that Arnav's mother has written for her DIL?are they waiting for the appropriate moment or isit that they have forgotten about it??????

@Anna-"don't judge the book by the appearance of the cover".I guess the cvs have some appropriate explanation to give us on the usage of the word " dhokebaaz" by Khushi.personally I feel
People driven to the edge utter all kinds of tosh.I know that your images about khushi has taken a beating but looking at it from a different perspective,I feel that certain inconsistencies can be forgiven if it helps in the interesting progression of the story



Nice written, Lizzy 😊

I agree with you, Khushi is at the end of tether and her emotions are at the boil. She is going to lash out now. As I said to someone , ASR days are numbered, he has to face the lioness sooner than he thinks or knows.

@bold: Completely Agree with you.


Peace67 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: monsi08



And then Arnav wud have said..

"It's ok... today I didnt take medicine .. my sugar level is low... that's why I came to enact Ranjha... Mithai to khane ko mili " 😛😆

Oh, I get it. It was not nani who made him do Ranjha, it was his sugar level 😆😆
cool_tweety thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago


same here..i was saying to myself "khushi ab utkar yeh math kehana ki Arnavji aapo meeta mana hein" i was telling this through out the scene😆
--Anna-- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tanthya


Just Buckets N Rivers ..No Arnav !!😛

I was just crying - so badly - my mom came up to check on me If I was okay! And when she got to know - she was like you are crazy! Go get married you fool! 😆😆



I do not know why but I am not able to see the proper Arnav Shyam and Khushi equation and that is what I expected this track to focus on!
@ bold..U r unable to see bec they are not showing it 😡😡..looks like they have forgotten this is a triangle

Yep, He was smiling at one part ..bad editing!!

I know right!? I am so pissed with it! When this track started I was sooo happy that Shyam - Khushi and arnav under one roof - lot of important scenes - but they haev just messed it up! And Abhaas has lost his charm - he needs to buck up Angry

Thank You for liking the song..a fav of mine

I loved the stricken expression of Arnav..I think he never considered her leaving until that moment..

I know - BS was good here - after than the intensity was a let down - nevertheless I was going mad Tongue😆


You and Pam are soul Sisters !!..

Aa Pam jhappi paa 🤗😆



Loved the analysis, Anna...but that is nothing new..U always know that I love ur posts ...

Ranjha has moved u immensely or was it a certain Mr.Sobti...😉😆😆

Thank you Tanthya! Always a pleasure to read ur replies! 😊
I will confess I am a die-hard fan of BS - no denying that - but yesterday every crying was for Arnav and him alone - so much love is hidden in his heart - so much pain and agony that it just made me cry
I am in red :)
Edited by --Anna-- - 13 years ago
tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago


Goood Morning, Buddies


to Mon, Anna, Asumi, Lizzy, Shanthi, Pam, Doods, V, Shwettuu,and all wonderful girls who have arrived here..😃
Doodle thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sugar_babe



Fair enough! He is being taken for granted. I also feel, his makeup man doesn't do a very good job. I mean Sanaya and Daljeet never look tired, I'm sure they are, but they know how to apply their makeup. They should start doing Barun's. His eye bags are as big as mine, but I get to sleep at the weekends, something he doesn't get to do, he needs a better make up man!

I know this thread is read by the creatives and I really do hope they get the message to stop over-using him, there's only this much he can endure. Sanaya is multidimensional, she can cover up when she slips, Barun can't... his eyes are a big part of how he emotes!


Sugar, One question??? Who told you that Redux is read??? some say yes and some say no... and I am confused and sandwiched in between with all the PMs here and at FB. 😆 😆 😆

I only know we love to analyze and started Redux just to share the knowledge with each other. That's it. 😃
--Anna-- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Hi Doodhs! Still reading your analysis! :)))

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: dellzcreationz

7 months ago

ArShi Aarav : Dil Se Bandhi Ek Dor - Last Chap,Pg5

INTRODUCTION As a writing prompt given by my dearest friend Jasmine, by being inspired by the movie Pappayude Swantham Appoos which means Papa's...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".