_Chaverah_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#1



A huge shout out to: Pentu82

I've been time and again saying this ki, Advay is my guy. I mean, I know him, I understand him, I just..can read him. For all that he is.

It actually is Chandni whom I find hard to understand or connect to. I..I dont know, I cant feel her the way I feel Advay.

Or rather, I cant understand her character with as much clarity as I would like to. Its like..blurred and murky for me.

Until today.

There's this HotStar Discussion thread (if anyone is unaware of it, please do check it. Its a stickie thrad and appears on the top of the first page in the forum.) where the HotStar premium users post how the episode is, give us a few spoilers, short reviews and basically, tease the crap out of the regular viewers.

And while we were discussing about quite a few wonderful things that today's episode has, Pentu82 (one of our yaaron) commented regarding the show, and there is this one line she's made:

Dark aspects of Chandni's character came out - sometimes you think you are so good that you hurt others -that is what is happening to chandni.

And..its just struck me. This really makes a lot of sense.

Its like, I've finally found one crucial bit of Chandni's character.

See, I am not saying ki jo bhi Addvay kar raha hain, woh sab sahi hain. No. What I am saying is that, Advay is an anti-hero, driven by rage and revenge and hence whatever he does makes sense, coz that is exactly what his character is.

What I couldn't understand is Chandni. She..is the soft, good morale woman. The one who preached that 'jeethne ko doosron ko haraana zaroori nahi hain.'

Who time and again corrects her sisters upon how one should not let the anger consume you.

The one who speaks so high of morals, truth and honesty of life and living. The one who believes in self-respect and you know, everything that makes her all the more admirable and really wonderful.

But what I couldnt again understand is, why, a girl as educated, confident and broad thinking as Chandni would agree to get married for the sole purpose of aiding their family's affluent status?

I have no qualms with her agreeing for an arranged marriage. Hell no. Its quite normal for us, around here. Rishtha acha hain, ladka acha hain, you love your Mom, you go ahead and give a nod. To atleast see the ladka if not right away get married. And with the kind of relation that Indrani-Chandni share, I understand why she was downright ready to marry even if that means she's gonna put her happiness curbed down forever.

But agreeing to get married just so as to enjoy the wealth that comes with him and get back to their pedestal of the rich and flourished Mahanth family?

I was lost there.

Chalo, we'll think ki, Chandni has no idea that her Mom wants this rishtha to be fixed coz of the money. Let's give it a benifit of doubt. Done.

When you know that your family is in need of money, (oh she knows this. She's the one who sold the bangles to get the pooja samagri, remember?), what are the three young educated women doing sitting at home rather than working somewhere?

Chalo, lets think ki, Mahanth's daughter hain woh, they're not allowed to go out and work, warna the world will know that they are in need of money.

1: I dont agree. Not every working woman is working coz she is in dire need of money.

2: Atleast they could do some home-tutions or YouTube videos, coz hey! They can cook well and we also gotta know that they know the stuff that goes behind recording a video and telecasting it.

So again, lost there.

Plan to send a man out of his own house?

Totally lost.

I mean, I cant understand why a character like Chandni would attempt doing something like this. It kinda against the morals she believes, doesnt it?

Answer: Morals dont apply when it comes to keeping/making her Mother happy. -> [1]

She's hurt coz her Mom's not talking to her. Fair enough.

And so she comes and hurts him back, with words deep, dark and daunting. Fair? Well, yes. Honestly yes. But with what we got to know of Chandni's soft and calm and all that..ya know, sweet sa character, this was a bit out of line.

Extreme times call for extreme steps, yes.

But that's what has me frowning.

She's not what she claims and prides in. Atleast, not all that she believes and preaches that she is.

Coz for her Mom, she's do kuch bhi. Kuch. Bhi. -> [2]

Put the goddamn nails (or whatever that is) on the floor while the guy is carrying her, so that he wont do the rasm?!

More than totally lost.

I mean, here, her Mom clearly had no objection in letting Advay carry her, coz of the apshakun or something. So why even attempt?

Answer: When he doesn't follow any goddamn rules, why the eff should I be the only one to follow the rules? -> [3]

From equations 1, 2 and 3 (Engineering ka side-effects), we can here by conclude that, Chandni might not be as dark as Advay is (hell, she's far from it), but she's not all the Holy than Thou either. She's got gray shades in her as well.

And that makes her normal for me. Which means, I kinda now can see her as a normal regular real character and not the one that is strictly limited to the fictional world.

Also, like pentu82 mentioned in another post of her's,

I have sometimes noticed this in real life too. People who assume they are on a moral high ground tend to hurt others more because they think they can do no wrong. A person who realizes his own fallibility is usually a kind person.

While I was under the impression of Chandni belonging to the second category, she, clearly is the one who belongs to the first category.

She's all fine and white-y white till her family is in smiles.

If it comes to her that something is going wrong with her family, then she has no qualms in stepping out of her line and her much preached morals and goody good character.

Which means, Chandni too has a gray in her.

Of course, everyone of us do. Or atleast I do, coz I cant talk about everyone.

But I never claim to be the goody good all the time. I know I can be the bitchy ass when needs comes to be and I am pretty vocal about it.

When Chandni went all 'samay, shaanthi, sach and nyaay'; I was like..er..okay?

I do respect such people, dont get me wrong. It takes a hell load of control and waay too good a heart and head to believe and abide by those norms at every given point of time, no matter how deep into the shit you are.

I respect them.

But..I just cant understand or connect to them.

Its like...admiring a modern art.

You know it is beautiful and magnificent and of very high value and is pretty damn rare. But you can not bloody understand it.

But now, now, I am a bit more comfy at understanding her. Understanding atleast a bit of her.

So yep, that's my post for today.

I am NOT going to talk about Barun Sobti's tweet and his acting in today's episode.

Nope, I am not.

Coz if I will begin typing now, I will finish it by tomorrow at around this time. And that's harmful for me.

Khel jazbaathon ka - dard zehreela sa.

Nafrath ke godh mein chupi - mohabbath hain woh sachi.

Aawaaz tha nasheela - alfaaz thae madhoshi.

Aakhein hain lafz unke - chehra atrangi.

Aashiqana hain woh hasi -Aafath woh aasoon.

Naa hosh tha, humein - na khaaboo,

Khaatilana tha woh nazar, jo chaa diya woh jaadoo.



That's all for now.

Signing off,

Candy.

P.S:


Oh and there's something I wanna share.

Today, for the first time ever, I watched IPK3 with my parents.

They were silent all through the episode but once it was done, my Amma (Cadbury, remember?) was like 'He is real good.'

And she kinda likes this subtle look over the bearded one she's seen him previously in.

And she asked how much he earns. And I read somewhere ki he's given 80+K per day. And guess what my Amma thinks?

That he is way underpaid.

Coz according to her, her words and I quote "for a glamorous profession as his, 80+K is nothing. He needs to maintain his body, his face, his health and probably remain without work between one project to another."

And I was like...nodding with wide eyes.

And my Nana-garu.. He absolutely loved Barun. Pretty, too damn pretty impressed with him.

He was like 'I cant watch Indian Soaps, no matter how good the leads are. But I'd love to see him in a film or something. He's got the potential. Try kiya Bollywood mein?"

It was such a proud moment, yaar! Felt like personal achievement of sorts.

And yes, needless to say, I gave a proud speech on Tu Hain Mera Sunday and the crucial things about it, which includes the release date, the film festivals it was screened in (which surprised and impressed both of them) and the awards it has secured.


Tu Hain Mera Sunday - 6th October, 2017.


P.P.S:

If anyone is gonna begin going #teamChandni on me, please...even though I am out and out #teamAdvay, I do love Chandni a lot. Its just that, I don't tend to understand her at times, bas.




Edited by _Chaverah_ - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

3.8k

Users

26

Likes

131

Frequent Posters

Viji79 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Res

😆

Unres

Ab mei aur kya boloo when you have said everything. Chandni's characterisation is confusing. Right from the beginning she has been shown as a very righteous woman who will get away from the way of evil rather than confronting it. The one thing that has been consistent is that she will do anything for her family, she will overcome her dear and get out of the house, she will sell her bangles which are special to her to dave her famioy from disgrace. The list is endless. But it was only after advay openly told her that he wants to marry her that her characterisation has taken a U turn.

In her defence, she has been openly told by a man about whom she doesn't know anything that he wants to break her. Remember he told her that good she is not as simple as he thought she was. Ab tumhe thodne mein aur mazaa Aayega? And everything he has done after that have been perceived as chivalry by everyone in the family but her since she knows that he was scheming. It is quite possible that she is highly confused about his intentions and that's why she is behaving out of character.

But that said, it is not normal to hide such important thing as advay's true intentions from Indrani and seek the younger siblings' silly schemes to drive advay from his own house with not an ounce of self respect is out of character, totally. But I guess its hereditary. After all that entire family has been living someone else' fortune for years now. To marry PP just to save her family from bankruptcy is not Chandni. She might as well have confronted Indrani and could have been shown to have succumbed to her emotio all blackmailing. She was shown to help Indrani in her quest for temple wealth. Hence it is a gross negligence in building her character.

Chandni who said it is not necessary to hurt to win someone cannot hurt advay the way she did intentionally. I want to believe that as a normal human reaction to have been manipulated to become a reason for her family's badnaam. But it wasn't done convincingly. I still want to give her benefit of doubt since she does cry when advay bleeds as shown in the spoilers. I want to believe that she wasn't aware of what awaited advay in that rasam.

So to conclude, yes I agree that Chandni is not white, and has shades of grey, but despite being portrayed as flawless in the initial episodes, her change in character touching on hues of grey is possibly because of advay's aggressiveness.
Edited by Viji79 - 8 years ago
Rimi_BS thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Nicely pointed out the crucial points!👏
Invisible123456 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Candy the creativity is all yours!! But thanks for the credit 😊 My name is Sudha btw ( Su for short)
Viji79 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: pentu82

Candy the creativity is all yours!! But thanks for the credit 😊 My name is Sudha btw ( Su for short)



Candy is right now lattu on you. Jackpot jo dila diya aapne usko.

P.S: My very dear cousin's name is sudha. I am very fond of your namesake
Edited by Viji79 - 8 years ago
Tumpaasaao thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
I am so so so so so happy
Today is our day.
Khush raho sab aaj.
Invisible123456 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Viji79



Candy is right now lattu on you. Jackpot jo dila diya aapne usko.

P.S: My very dear cousin's name is sudha. I am very fond of your namesake



Haha!!! I didnt realize I was giving away a jackpot!!! 😛

I am telugu too..i think you and candy are too right? Or am i mistaken?
Audrey.h. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Hi candy thank u sooo Mich for making this post...I totally agree with you when you say you cant relate to chandni! I feel the same way too! Since the beginning of the show makers have tried to show that advay is going to hurt chandni while chandni was shown the kind of healer but what has actually happened is advay has consciously or unconsciously always protected her while she always hurts him!

To me she comes across as a person sitting on a high horse and judging advay...usually in Gul shows if not totally I can relate to the heroines on some level but I m not able to connect to chandni like you want to throw a man out of his own house? Sure you need money so u must marry? Ever heard of doing a job?

Maybe in the upcoming episodes I might start liking her hopefully but right now I can't connect to her or her pain on any level..

Channa_mereyaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Wow such great in depth analysis .
Aww family story is so cute.even my mom always say kitna handsome munda hai fr him 😆 if only i can make her sit n realize he is beyond that .gem of an actor but then she gets busy with her work .
But i will surely take her fr thms 😃
Edited by Channa_mereyaa - 8 years ago
Viji79 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: pentu82



Haha!!! I didnt realize I was giving away a jackpot!!! 😛

I am telugu too..i think you and candy are too right? Or am i mistaken?



Candy is but I am a Tamilian, though I live in HYD now

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".