Promising story & performers becoming a victim of shite execution.

ghissapitta thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Just need to rant a little bit, idek if anyone is awake rn lol.


So I wanna start off by clarifying I have zero attachment to IPK 1, any of the actors or actresses involved, the bg scores, the scenes or anything. This post is just me venting out my frustrations regarding the technicalities of the show.

Now when I first heard of the story, heard about it being the revenge-saga of an anti-hero, I was intrigued. Then we started getting details about the characters and how they'd be fleshed out eg. Advay a maths professor and musician, Chandni a Sanskrit scholar, dealing with anxiety issues. The characters, to me, also sounded intriguing.

So far so good.

Cue two weeks into the show and the only thing I am is mighty confused. Sorry not sorry, but the editing and directing teams in particular, are majorly letting down the story and the cast. There is little to no flow between scenes, and oh! One of my biggest peeves is when I have no CLUE about what one of the protagonists is thinking. This is the case with my Chandu rn - I'm not demanding long inner dialogues or monologues or soliloquys but at least some clarity on how she feels towards this stranger who has been cornering her and being cryptic towards her for no rhyme nor reason. The only time we have really gotten a look into her thoughts and feelings is when she is reminiscing about Dev, or thinking about her kidnapping and how she won't let that incident leave her with crippling fear.

I'm of the opinion that the leads do act well, they DO have lovely chemistry but the execution of their scenes, the fleshing out of their characters has so far been wishy-washy. I am NOT expecting any character development already since we're only two weeks into the show, but I am at least expecting some character establishment. More than with Advay, I am becoming confused with Chandni's character. Especially after the new shaadi promo and screen journal BTS.

She was no abla nari, yes she suffered from anxiety but she has always shown a quiet strength. She even showed a hint of feisty-ness in her scene with her sisters when she teased them. But where is this 'tossing-her-hair-on-his-face', talking-back-to-him Chandu coming from?

Now this post could be extremely premature, maybe they'll show us a good enough reason on why Chandu suddenly becomes uber comfortable to do nok-jhok with the man who was threatening and terrorizing her. But at this stage, and I am someone looking forward to some MAJOR AdNi romance, the shaadi promo makes no sense right now.

Advay seems like he has a change in strategy; he's planning to charm and woo her then break her. But what makes Chandni suddenly get so sassy around him? I would love it of course, I just hope it is justified plausibly.

I still have faith in this show. I love the leads, I love the villain, I can take some illogical nonsense in story, I can even take the costumes now as they don't bother me. Just a simple request - make the writing and execution a little more crisper and tighter.

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

1.9k

Users

12

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I agree with you. The direction and editing has not been at par. One reason might have been there was lot of stuff that had to be out - like parts of past, Dev - Chandni interactions, Chandni's nightmares so they could not completely reflect on Chandni.
I think Monday's precap part is the start of reflections of Chandni. We see that she has come to investigate Advay and see what he is. Right now Chandni is kind of intimidated by the guy - staying away is her primary response but she has learned to give him back equally. Her dialogue of - Main Chandni hoon proves that. And I guess after the khazana door is not getting opened she will try to figure this guy and his cryptic messages.

Let's see why she came into Advay's room and see how she tackles him.
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
And I personally hope the shaadi promo is only a far away indication and is not happening so soon. At least I want Chandni to figure out Advay is her Dev before she accepts the proposal.
ghissapitta thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: PSharada

I agree with you. The direction and editing has not been at par. One reason might have been there was lot of stuff that had to be out - like parts of past, Dev - Chandni interactions, Chandni's nightmares so they could not completely reflect on Chandni.

I think Monday's precap part is the start of reflections of Chandni. We see that she has come to investigate Advay and see what he is. Right now Chandni is kind of intimidated by the guy - staying away is her primary response but she has learned to give him back equally. Her dialogue of - Main Chandni hoon proves that. And I guess after the khazana door is not getting opened she will try to figure this guy and his cryptic messages.

Let's see why she came into Advay's room and see how she tackles him.


Yes. In hurrying to establish their pasts they forgot to first properly establish the characters themselves.

Oh yes! I haven't watched Friday's episode yet so forgot about it but her entrance to his house may very well start to delve into her thought process when it comes to Advay. As far as I remember reading the precap, she's still afraid and wary of him. Interesting to see how and why she'll suddenly become a sherni in front of him 😆

Regarding the shaadi thing, I have a sinking feeling she mightn't find out until after she marries him Would love to be proven wrong tho!

I guess she also falls in love with 'Advay' hence that love letter we got :/
Edited by ghissapitta - 8 years ago
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ghissapitta


Yes. In hurrying to establish their pasts they forgot to first properly establish the characters themselves.

Oh yes! I haven't watched Friday's episode yet so forgot about it but her entrance to his house may very well start to delve into her thought process when it comes to Advay. As far as I remember reading the precap, she's still afraid and wary of him. Interesting to see how and why she'll suddenly become a sherni in front of him 😆

Regarding the shaadi thing, I have a sinking feeling she mightn't find out until after she marries him Would love to be proven wrong tho!

I guess she also falls in love with 'Advay' hence that love letter we got :/


It has time and again shown that Chandni thinks herself and Dev being together so it would be stupid for the creatives to show her suddenly falling for Advay. Especially given that this guy totally invades her personal space and is rude and unapologetic.

In all of this I am actually confused as to why the writers have not shown Chandni recollecting how or why Dev went away. Hoping next week would build up on this - and I think the Shaadi promo would not happen for some more time. I would have loved Advay buying the haveli off but looks like that is not what the writers are aiming for.
Rimi_BS thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Honestly I have no knowledge on editing and direction, so can't give gyaan about that department...but execution could be much better, lets see what happens in the coming days...
Hopefully it will improve with the coming episodes..
.SobtiLicious. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
I have said this from the very beginning of the show

This show lacks only one thing and that is proper direction and editing

Due to the lack proper edit and direction , the hardwork, the mind blowinn acting by almost all the actors r being overshadowed.. i really dont know how to send my voice to 4lions, but they really need to fix this out

Gul reads each and every comment on jer insta post ..can we make her know about it ?
Edited by .SobtiLicious. - 8 years ago
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: .SobtiLicious.

I habe said this from the very beginning of the show

This show lacks only one thing and that is proper direction and editing

Due to the lack proper edit and direction , the hardwork, the mind blowinn acting by almost all the actors r being overshadowed.. i really dont know how to send my voice to 4lions, but they really need to fix this out

Gul reads each and every comment on jer insta post ..can we make her know about it ?


Yes we can comment on Gul's Insta post so hopefully she will read it. But please try not to be negative on condescending. The team already has baggage of attacks from haters, bashers, loonies so let's not add to it. Instead give honest feedback that direction and pace of editing should slow down to allow people to understand the characters and their traits.
Pixiepixel11 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Arshika_arshi

Honestly I have no knowledge on editing and direction, so can't give gyaan about that department...but execution could be much better, lets see what happens in the coming days...
Hopefully it will improve with the coming episodes..

yep same here keeping my fingers crossed.
ghissapitta thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: .SobtiLicious.

I habe said this from the very beginning of the show

This show lacks only one thing and that is proper direction and editing

Due to the lack proper edit and direction , the hardwork, the mind blowinn acting by almost all the actors r being overshadowed.. i really dont know how to send my voice to 4lions, but they really need to fix this out

Gul reads each and every comment on jer insta post ..can we make her know about it ?


I have an insta from years ago. Maybe I should finally put it to some use lol.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".