Fiction vs. Reality - The improbable and the plausible

incandescent thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

Time and again we've told or have been told, don't take it seriously because it is fiction after all or it is just a show, it's not real. But the inevitable is that we end up taking it far too seriously, firstly because they allow us a form of escapism and secondly because many of them have the capacity of pulling us into an illusory world and make it appear real. We invest our time, energy and emotions and become attached to people who aren't even real. The emotions tug at our hearts, the pain of the characters mirror in our hearts. We know it's unhealthy and yet we struggle to detach ourselves.


What makes it hard to understand the faking of selective amnesia is not the improbability of it, but the presentation. Because as rare as it is, it can happen. I know of a real young couple where the husband suffered amnesia and didn't recognize his wife. A woman having complete faith in her husband is admirable and if the said husband is worthy of that trust deserve equal admiration. But the question lies whether it is acceptable to hurt a person for their own sake or if there is a limit of tolerance to pain. At what point does a person snap? How far should a person take another's love for granted? It makes you wonder what would have happened if this was real life. Would Annika really be able to bear her husband announcing another woman as his wife? Isn't Shivaay putting too much at stake? What if he loses Annika in the process? Is it really worth it? But it is fiction after all so we must buy into it.


Whether someone wants to address their own feelings or not, is it their prerogative. Can an individual who was not willing to commit in the first place demand commitment from someone else? Is it fair to want the rights and privileges of a spouse when the same was not handed out? How much does a person have to prove themselves in order to be considered trustworthy? Is the whole ordeal really worth it? If this was real life, would Om not be considered duplicitous? Would Gauri have really stayed with Om after being accused of lying and cheating over and over again? But it is fiction after all so all will be fine in the end and Gauri must walk the path of fire.


There are two kinds of men, one that respect women and one that don't. A person can be shallow and immature. But a man who was taught to respect women and has respected women in the past would not forget his learning and slander a woman in public. In the real world, the lowest of low lives would go and make such a demonstration at someone's wedding. Rudy has been lowered to that level but very soon, he would be elevated back to the old Rudra for which I am thankful.I want to forget that incident as a bad dream and I am glad Rudy is away for sometime from Bhavya because the memory is still fresh. No girl would still have images of such a guy in their phones, certainly not the independent and self-respecting Bhavya who wears a uniform. But this is fiction after all so it's all part of growing up.


The one thing that is completely logical and believable is grey people being grey. Partners in crime suspecting each other of deceit. Did I mention how much I enjoyed watching this one thing in last night's episode? Because it is the one thing that is plausible. It was a treat to watch TejVi and ShinKy arrive in their individual cars and gather at the derelict Kalyani mills. Secrets can't remain hidden forever. Whatever the sins of the past, karma does come back to bite you.

Edited by incandescent - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

799

Users

3

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

Reeltoreal thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
I have not been watching since Monday but going by what you say I agree Karma is ...funny ... replace it with B word n I hope that it comes to bite back everyone royally . The makers n writers included along with all the fictitious characters that we get attached to so much that we for real go thru more pain n angst than them onscreen ... albeit it's self imposed for most of us .

I have been ranting raving n going thru all the motions of loosing something or some one very precious N close but I think am done now . Nostalgia hits watch old episodes , depression knocks get a book , feeling murderous watch someone else getting murdered meaning a crime show ... my new detox from IB program.

But I will say this too once Shivika back again I will be back too ... there is hardly a cure for addiction when you do not want to rid urself of it 😆 ( at myself)
Naju2388 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Great points you made, I really wish the writer showed how much this lie could affect anika emotionally and mentally instead of showing a comedy root, I wish they talked about how anika was during the past two weeks not knowing the whereabouts of shivaay! I can't connect with anika at the moment, your husband just announced a another girl as his wife in front everyone and insulted wyou without reason and you don't react at all! Foolish!
incandescent thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: yash2010

I have not been watching since Monday but going by what you say I agree Karma is ...funny ... replace it with B word n I hope that it comes to bite back everyone royally . The makers n writers included along with all the fictitious characters that we get attached to so much that we for real go thru more pain n angst than them onscreen ... albeit it's self imposed for most of us .

I have been ranting raving n going thru all the motions of loosing something or some one very precious N close but I think am done now . Nostalgia hits watch old episodes , depression knocks get a book , feeling murderous watch someone else getting murdered meaning a crime show ... my new detox from IB program.

But I will say this too once Shivika back again I will be back too ... there is hardly a cure for addiction when you do not want to rid urself of it 😆 ( at myself)


Karma indeed is B and it does come back to bite royally...whether in fiction or in real life. It's ridiculous how much pain we suffer for these fictitious characters. I am going through the various stages of grief and I think I've reached the acceptance part where I have realized there is little chance of IB being salvaged from this. Or it's probably because I have something else ( another fiction ) to distract me at the moment.😆

But as you say, it is addiction after all.

Reeltoreal thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5


Karma indeed is B and it does come
back to bite royally...whether in fiction or in real life. It's ridiculous how
much pain we suffer for these fictitious characters. I am going through the
various stages of grief and I think I've reached the acceptance part where I
have realized there is little chance of IB being salvaged from this. Or it's
probably because I have something else ( another fiction ) to distract me at
the moment.😆


But as you say, it is addiction
after all.



Good luck with your new baby(fiction) for me this is my first Indian tv show in10+ years n this will be my last unless Shivika bags another show together ... 😆 no more cycles of grief or any gul show my heart n mind will not survive .
Edited by yash2010 - 7 years ago
incandescent thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Naju2388

Great points you made, I really wish the writer showed how much this lie could affect anika emotionally and mentally instead of showing a comedy root, I wish they talked about how anika was during the past two weeks not knowing the whereabouts of shivaay! I can't connect with anika at the moment, your husband just announced a another girl as his wife in front everyone and insulted wyou without reason and you don't react at all! Foolish!


Thank you.

@ Bold - I wish that too. But that would require putting some thought and effort and judging from the overall state of things, the writer is in no mood to provide that. I can't connect with Annika either. There was a lot of scope to show Annika's emotional condition but they glossed over the whole thing with a comedy track. Frankly, I can't connect much with Shivaay either because we aren't seeing his anguish yet. I was bored watching the Shivika scenes today and that is such a shame.

incandescent thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: yash2010



Good luck with your new baby(fiction) for me this is my first Indian tv show in10+ years n this will be my last unless Shivika bags another show together ... 😆 no more cycles of grief or any gul show my heart n mind will not survive .



Thank you and fortunately my new baby is not another Indian soap. Even if it gets bad it won't be this bad. 😆

I am a survivor of another Gul show. Why did I decide to put myself through this again? No idea. 😆
Edited by incandescent - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".