Why so much bitterness for shivaay and for his fans too!!!! - Page 2

Originally posted by: itzMYattitude

i know this comment was not directly for me thats y instead of asking 10000s of questions that r in my mind i just wanna raise one😳will there ever come a time after shivika kids or marriage of their kids when people can forgive shivaay for what he was in the past? I heard people say hate the crime not the criminal. The crime of shivaay marrying anika forcefully can be redeemed? Anika portrayed like an angel we can relate to. But shivaay potrayed as a human learning from his sins people cannot relate to? hard to digest for me.

p.s- I love ur writing😃

Originally posted by: LoveToWrite

Firstly, why would even this comment be directed towards anyone? This was what I believe and not a ranting keeping in account others. So be assured, this was neither directed towards you nor towards anyone else. 10000 questions? My goodness, that's quite a lot. Since you are asking me, I am bound to answer. Why should people forgive him without any redemption? And you said 'for what he was in past' then let me just say that someone's life turned upside down because of 'what he was in past', didn't it?

N he made his sin the most beautiful truth of her life. N he never done a SIN afterwards, a mistake maybe but not SIN.

As much as I hate to say this but I would have to.

You heard people say, hate crime and not the criminal right? Just tell me, should people forgive rapists who have had killed girls after their crimes then? because as per this theory, people should hate rape and not rapists.
Yes in this case u cannot undo the whole stuff. But in shivika case, anika would never never love a person likfe shivaay without redemption. N Shivaay was the one who did everything and win the girl back.

I personally believe, it could be redeemed because he has done quite a lot of things for her, because he loved/loves her but then, there should be a proper redemption for people to forgive him entirely. ( Have you watched ONS track revelation episode? You should really! Have a hear on the words he used for her and the accusations he put on her)

he felt guilt about what he did (the forced marriage) and he confessed it through words more than once. He took a bullet for that girl (u know one thing about life? u only get it once. And he without a blink was willing to sacrifice that). he was compromising his believes not for his own sake but for her. He gave her the things she was always craving for in her life. Tell me what else can a man do for u? Like WHAT? this is the question actually. Actions speak louder than words and there's nothing left he could have done more? WHAT yar he dont have anymore options left.

Anika has been portrayed like an angel? I don't think she has ever. I honestly know and believe that such people exist who go to such extents to protect their loved ones.

A girl living with a man accusing her? married her forcefully? I understand what shivaay's mindset is. But how can u connect with anika in this whole mess? So obviously if she is not an angel (may b an alien) she is not behaving like a human would in these situations. I connect with shivaay because he has a journey and his every act make sense for me, even his SIN make sense because its his egoistic upbringing n nature. Anika on the other hand half her actions are above my understandings 😆 I never liked anika because she is a beautifully written character but because surbhi is just flawless in everything.

Even in this track u know what shivaay is doing

Anika on the other hand has no clue right now what she wants?

She left OM, both have separate ways living there lives. Noted

Then she came back knowing shivaay's not same anymore (i dont know what else she was expecting) "only to bring his tadi back". Shivaay's tadi is back by some foolish way she thought will work and she started living there? WHY?

Now when shivaay is marrying someone else she's like dont. Y? U dont want to come in his life and u dont want to let him live with someone else? what exactly she wants? To live under the same roof without any proper relationship for the rest of the life?

Then all of a sudden she told him the truth saying we will fight it together and m with u in this shit

Next morning she again changed her mind and wanted shivaay to be in relationship without ever knowing the truth?

So many U turns just in a span of 20 episodes? I want anika to first sit peacefully and make up her mind EXACTLY what she wants. I love shivika but this unjustified act?

Firstly humans do mistakes and that's normal and natural but sins? That's one big word, my dear. That's one big word.

That may be! Not only for you but for many like it is for rest of the people to digest his doings - as I have said over and over, perspective differs 😊

PS: You meant fics? Thank you 😊 I am glad to know the same.
yesh m not reading many lately but when i use to u r fab 👏

Originally posted by: LoveToWrite

Just to add a bit more, I personally wouldn't have remembered the FM thing if he hadn't done what he did in the separation track. I don't know about others but it was like heartbreaking for me to watch. I was literally hoping and waiting for him to corner her or to say - '' Tell me what it is! I don't believe this crap! '' And probably those expectations are the reason why I felt even more upset in the track.

He did actually many times before the separation. Everytime she was saying bad about his family he asked way too many times.

And u proved my point. HE CAN NEVER REDEEM. He is human n will make mistakes. If every mistake will bring the FM track then u want him not to make mistakes. He cant do that as long as he is human.

N lastly i really want once in IB for shivaay to do the same anika did with om's truth coming out. I really wanna see the calm anika doing nothing if shivaay will do the same with saahil. Trust me the whole stance of anika fan will change for sure.😳 She wont be able to take this sort of shit about saahil either

But anyways, I hope I did not hurt you with anything I said. I, understand and respect how you think of the situations but I somewhat have pretty different takes. Let me just quickly apologize if you get hurt anywhere while reading my reply. Thank you.

Originally posted by: -LetItGo-

oh thankyou so much😃wasn't expecting this kind of response from someone with whom I hardly interact thankyou again😃 that's heart warming.

I love surbhi ofcourse and anika I used too I don't hate her as some people think it's her lack of strenght in her character that's disappointing.

Mallu