Saumya is not negative - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.8k

Users

12

Likes

37

Frequent Posters

xsumi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#11
hope its true that she is not negative x
napstermonster thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#12
For Soumya to be negative would be to go against everything they have shown us about her as a person for the past 6 months. Just to gain more screen time (which is by no means a guarantee in this show for anyone) they should not (and will not) butcher her essential character traits.

I understand the TRP grab that establishing the Nafratbaaazi does-- some weird throwback to 80s vamp "K-ekta" shows. Its clearly for TRP aunties who seriously need to stop watching TV, and let the rest of us get quality shows and not this regressive crap. But we are already expecting a moderately grey FL for Omkara-- (non truthful, or in any way non-sanskari is grey in Ishqbaaz, remember). Gul does not have the bandwidth to do another grey girl-- TRPs would never stand it.

Also, frankly-- why are people commenting on the lack of screen presence? Soumya has had screen presence--her story started along with Shivika's and of course, its taken a back burner--but its been brought to a point where she is already a married woman. Of late of course, she has not had a story line which will clearly be changing now that Prinku's upcoming MMS is tied into her marriage.

But of all the women, Soumya, next to Anika, has had a very established character arc. We know MUCH more about her nature, actually than we do about Priyanka, fro example. This knowledge took some story telling. You cannot think turning her grey makes her more interesting. I love who she has been so far. She IS interesting as a strong, confident regular girl with way more layers, more tragic losses than she shows to others. All that are still available as story themes for her and Rudra. More will be shown post her marriage reveal, obviously.

But look at what we have already, because to ignore what we know of her would be character suicide. This would not give her some great vamp to FL kind of growth- to turn her into a grey shaded FL is a reversal that makes no sense. As the Love Angel she has been kind and supportive to millions of viewers. She is a famous RJ and an intelligent feminist. She has been a good daughter like character in the house, standing by Prinku and even helping the family out during crisis after crisis. She has sat at pujas, helped Anika, taken part in Shivaay's wedding prep, danced at his mandap.

Motivation wise, she has none. She cannot be the surprise 4th daughter of Mrs Check-blouse Mrs Kapoor. Come on. She has come here because Dadi knows her Nani, she has a brother who died and an Ai on the phone slated to show up any day now, to do the roka with that Rehan. There is no familial connection to the Kapoors. And as for her father/brother deaths--is Gul a moron? How many more husbands/fathers/brothers have these Oberois killed, bhai? Mr Gayatri, Mr Kapoor, and now Soumya's dad/bro? Are we being told that Shakti and Tej are going around India murdering random people's male relatives, like two very specific serial killers??? Its absurd.

Soumya does not need to be a vamp for access. She is MARRIED to a ML. And more than the secret marriage that she is clearly valuing as well as Rudra, she is Rudra's support system. She has cried over his injuries, threatened his enemies, supported him when he needed her help and her love. How will Rudra survive a betrayal of this magnitude? Do you see him trusting her after this, or us audience trusting her after being a gaddar?

She has tied a rakhi on Omkara and sees him almost like a brother she lost. She has been a good "daughter," who's only crime has been to be a little too submissive to her already established mother, her "Ai." She has been eating the Oberoi's roti so to speak, for the past 6 months, as a very much loved guest of Dadi's. Can anyone tell me how her suddenly being part of the Tia Brigade is Grey and not Black as a character?

Anika has more reason to become a vamp with more cruelty shown to her, than Soumya ever has had to go through. She is NOT negative.
Edited by napstermonster - 8 years ago
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#13
@napstermonster:

While I agree with you on principle that Soumya being "Negative" makes no sense. (I dont want her to be). But the reason you think Annika has more reasons to be a Vamp is coz we have seen ALL of her for the past 7 months. Her home, her brother, her abusive nasty aunt, her issues etc etc. We know a whole lot about her. Yes Shivaay abused her. But the Oberoi's did not. She does not have ANY reason to feel angry with them. Her culprit is Shivaay and she has already forgiven him and seems to have no issues with the plight she was put into.

But Soumya? WHAT do we know about her? Other than that she is a nice girl, she has a RJ avatar, and she is confident and strong. She was never shown as being in love with Rudra or even being impressed by him, accept for one or two instances. She cares about the members of the household. But we have NO idea what her life was before coming to OM? What if she does have some sort of issue with the senior Oberoi's? Not a murder, but maybe a decision that caused her brother some harm? We simply dont know. She is a mystery in that sense.

She is not a part of RoTiLana. THAT is for sure. But maybe she helped Tia in some way? I dont know. But that is the interesting part. Lets face it, all she has been in the past few weeks is a white noise and background character being a cheerleader for ShiVika? Is THAT the sum total of her character? I think not. I for one am actually looking forward to see if she DOES have an issue with the senior Oberois for some reason and what that may be? I think it may be a good twist IF handeled well. No lame hand gestures of NafratBaaz for her please! LOL

Also, being "Married' to a ML does not automatically gurantee sainthood or white as a sheet status for a female lead, nor should it!
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 8 years ago
manny136 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
Whether she is neg or grey it gives rumya more of a storyline. If sumo just ended up helping rudra deal with romi n then later their secret marriage got exposed what would they show next them falling in love etc they barely get any ss so a meaningful time would not have been shown for them to show this progress. Now if she is out to get revenge we might get more of a background on her n how she was hurt by the oberois n her plan. She might change her ways if she starts feeling guilty etc n when rudra finds out we might get to see a new avatar of him. Also their marriage thing might later force things for them, maybe having to stay together despite the hurt n anger. It could give both some characger growth if only handled properly.
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#15
@Napstermonster:

Yes even I am angered by the fact that Annika has been shown to have "moved on" and not caring of how she landed in OM as their Bahu. I also dont beleive she wants "nothing" from Shivaay. Looks like they are choosing the cliched path of Shivaay rejects Annika because of Mrs Kapoors blackmail and not his firm belief in NKK. Dissapointing and not consistent with Shivaay. But then, we cant expect a lot more as cliches seem to be the PH's favorite!

Soumya - Yes she is wary of losing her heart to "Rudy". I wrote her exactly like that in my story. She never trusted he would be the sort of partner she wanted, or that she should trust her heart with him. Especially coz she had lost a lot in life. I dont want her to be negative or Grey, but it seems the makers do not have enough skill to make her a part of the story properly, without giving her an "Angle". So I for one am willing to accept that, if it gives her a bit more of an edge. I think the way she is is PLENTY, but the writers are lame in this department. (Something Lee himself said in 2 interviews, that the writers dont know what to write). So he made a clear dig at them for lack of RUMYA story development and SS. As a RUMYA fan I want to see their story progress, so I am willing to sign up to see what they do.

Now coming to Sumo not meddling in "OM" affairs? Yes she does not, and I LIKE that about her. Very much. I think she is classy and she is staying in her limits. The way any good house guest would. I would not have liked to see her sticking herself into their issues and showing up with Rudra for each and every thing. She has always made it clear she is not a family member. Even when that Fridge arrived, she got Rudra to sign for it saying "Only family members can sign". During Diwali she said one only celebrates Diwali with family IF they live in the same city and Rudra offered that HE lives here not overseas. It's clear Rudra is the one who gives importance to their changed equation more than she does. He respects relationships a lot. (One thing I love about my Rudy!). :)


Soumya "Likes" Rudra, but she is not in love with him yet, and even if she is, she is a LONG way to accepting her feelings. IF she indeed has an agenda of some sort, she will not let her fancy for Rudra get in her way. This chubby oversmart nerd is no one's fool and I love her for it. I hope she NEVER changes. She is one female character on this show I genuinly like and regard so far. I hope they dont force me to change my mind!
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 8 years ago
xaviara thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#16
Rudra already has a negative lead after his life, Romi ! Why would they turn Saumya in a negatice character too?

Plus Sahil has been known to have a good judge of character, even though he is a kid, and he has adored Saumya since the first time he has met her.

Another thing, Saumya's character is a perfect fits for Rudra's, so am sure Gul won't ruin their equation by turning Saumya's character as grey.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".