People's thoughts on the II3 Judges?

Who do you like, who do you dislike, and why?


Let me say that I like and admire all the judges, they are all wonderful at what they do. But I've been watching the II3 eps (I'm up to Gala 5) a few things have started to bug me a little . . .

Anu Malik: Is it just me or is he constantly interrupting the other judges (especially Alisha)? Its fine if he has a different opinion (often I agree with him) but he gets his chance to speak and say whatever he wants, so why must he always be butting-in on the others? Its so rude!. . . is he just arguing for the sake of ratings?

Alisha Chinoy: (Javed-saab mentioned it also) She is lovely, but does she have to giggle after every single thing she says?

Javed Akhtar: I've always had a lot of respect for him, and mostly he made good comments . . . but I can't work out why he was so often against Emon? He praised Ankita for her confidence, yet put Emon down for the very same reasons . . .?

Udit Narayan: He might be a bit soft in his comments sometimes but I love the way he really gets into to it when someone is singing well. way people are singing, its so sweet.


Anyways these are my thoughts till now . . . just curious; what does everyone else think?

Annu Mallik : Very straightforward jugde, he gave fair comments, sometimes harsh but that was good for all the contestants, but yeah he was quite rude especially when he interrupted each and every judge, especially Alisha!!! What was his problem!!!??? If he had his opinion, he should have let others saying theirs!!!

Alisha Chinoi : Very cute judge, she was an angel!!! She sometimes giggled too much but she was the only one to reply the same way to Annu Mallik, but overall I appreciated her a lot!!!

Javed Akhtar : Javed Jiiiii..... Kya Kahein!!!??? He gave very good comments, I respected but I started disliking him when he was so harsh to Emon!!!??? I mean, he said that Emon will never be a singer in the Bollywod Industy because there's a better singer than him... Is that something to say to a contestant!!!??? What would have Emon felt that time!!!??? Anyways, overall, he was a respectful and fair judge!!!

Udit Narayan : Sweet Judge, but he wasn't fair at all in his comments... He didn't dare to reply back to Annu Mallik and he just shut his mouth in front of him which was quite weird!!! He still added spice to the show, he was quite funny and made such funny comments sometimes!!!

Totally agree with you rahman2005 😛

lol, I guess this topic is only interesting to you and I rahman 😳