Originally posted by: roshniae
first of all i completely dont agree wid u.....
1. he has indeed given many gud performances but never received a standing ovation from all the judges (AMIT HAS GOT THAT)
2. i dont find him a lovable or humourus person at all . its all made up by the sho host. if u want to make emon an ii by his 'gud personality' then why not chuck off ankita for her vamp like nature who goes on national tv and names deepali for just giving a constructive peice of criticism. and lemmet tell u ....emons mimic of anu malik is no where next to wat anu is....i think sonu did it better. And he cant even do javed ji properly. his mimcry is not good 🤢 . accept it
3. he has starred in a comedy show but he was definetly not funny there too. see the performance closely. see the whole episode. even the lowest score gainers were funnier than him and abhishek. and we want a gud singer in ii3 ...u want us to vote for him just bcoz he has come in a comedy show??? wat sense does tht make
4. he weeps for everybody who leaves the show ....ya right.....temme one thing...wat does weeping have to do wid winning the show????? 😕 😕 😕 mini cries even widout anybody getting out...shuldnt she then be crowned the indian idol of all three seasons??? i am amazed when u write that his crying shows u how caring he is...well u r looking for a potential ii3 not your groom.
5. i agree that he is very talented when it cums to playing instrument. on that i will not argue coz i too agree wid u on tht point. But he is not tht gr8 a singer coz
1. he has a lisping problem (not a PRONOUNCIATION PROBLEM) coz even in bengali 'ch' and 's' is pronounced as 'ch' and 's'... not 'th'
2. he got overconfident in the earlier galas...and say wat u may but u cant hide the truth. thnk of wat will happen to him if he bcoms ii. He will be completely swollen headed.
3. He is such a big fan of sonu tht he now sounds completely like sonu coz he tries to learn singing thru sonu. Remember in the audition rounds a guy had cum all dressed up as a lady (meera bai) and was a huge fan of udit narayan. he also got his painting and offered flowers to udit. he sang just like udit and was rejected. also sandeep acharya. so accept it that emon sings like sonu. if u dont agree....theres got to be sumthing wrong wid ur TVs audio system
Thats it...... people i am here not asking u to not vote for emon. if u think he SINGS WELL...go ahead and vote. coz in my post i havent said tht he sings bad!! its just tht his lisps and vocal quality makes it sound bad otherwise his harkats and murkhis r accurate. but i wouldnt like to put my money on him! 😊
i m sry but i dunt agree wid u roshanie..and here is y 1) Emon has never recieved a standing ovation doesnt make dat performance less brilliant...incase u cant tell the judges r being biased towards him..dey always criticize him for one thing or another..but anu malik had also sed dat he is his playback singer many times n he even says it in the upcoming gala.....none of the other contestants (except amit) hav recievved standing ovations so y r dey here?
2) altho dis is a singing competition many ppl hav sed dat dis is not only a singing competition...and personality is a very important factor in public voting. Emon does hav a fun likable and humorous personality...even the conetstants demselves hav sed dis many times.....wat do u mean its all made by the show host?? 😕 his mimicry has nothing to do wid his singing.....dats jus a bonus point....if u dunt liek it dats fyne but many ppl find it enjoyable n funny...he may not b better den sonu but we r not here to evaluate how well he mimics the judges
3) you may not find him funny at comedy circus but dat doesnt mean he wasnt...i luvd his himesh mimicry!😃he didnt cum here for comedy circus? dis is II wich is a singing competition... Emon and Abhishek wer only der to start the show and der act was only bout 5 min long..not even...so wat else do u want him to do?
4) The fact dat he cries for eveyone who leaves the show further shows that he is a caring person...he is frendly and he got very emotionally attached wid the other contestants...do u c any other contestant crying dat much? noo..i dunt think so. I am not saying jus cuz he cries he shud b II....dats just one of the points u mentioned
5) u didnt argue wid dat..so i wunt either...he is immesnsely talented!! playing instruments is not a peice of cake ......none of the other contestants can as far as i noe..
6) he does not hav a lisping problem...sumone who has a lisp u wud noe de minute the start speaking....if the judges didnt notice dis problem till las gala...he does not hav a lisping problem! yes..he does hav a slight pronounciation problem cuz hindi is not his mother toungue...but so does prshant..dis is sumthing dey both can wrk on n it can easily b improved......
7) he was not over confident in my opinion...dat was a controversory dat javed ji started n anu malik jus tuk over...but w/e dats ur opinion so i cant argue
8) also he does not try to copy sonu!.....his voice is slightly differrent.. a lil more high pitched...n he has his own style of singing..again its another controversary dat the judges r trying to create. plus he is styll young as he grows his voice will mature and eventually develop further. Sonu is his idol n dats it....y dunt ppl understand dat?ders lots more i can say but im tired of writing..
wow dis turned out to b a huge post.....neewais i ve sed wat i wanted to n if u styll think dat he doesnt deserve to b indian idol...den i suggest u think it over...😊
Edited by kyph_1fan - 18 years ago