II2 top 6 Vs II3 top 6

my opinion only, you can add your's

II2

1.Sandeep - average singer, good looking, regional votes and huge fan(females)

2.Karunya - accepted by every one, Excellent singer,good voice quality

3.Anuj sharma - Good Looking, average singer, regional votes helped him a lot to reach top 3

4.Amey Date - Excellent singer, but ground support was not there(most of the time was in bottom 4)

5. Antara Mali - Excellent Singer, superb voice quality,still not helped to reach top 3.

6. Ravi Tripathi - Average singer, hyped only because of Suresh Wadker's Shishya.

II3 - history repeats

1. Prashant - Average singer - regional votes

2. Amit - Accepted by every one (has to wait till final to see if he wins or not)

3. Chang - look matters and community/regional votes

4. Emon - Same as Amey's Situation

5. Puja - Same as Antara's

6.Ankita- Only hype- no singing

we can add deepali also and can be compared to monali

Meenal was in sixth place, not Ravi Tripathi.

I prefer II2's top six to II3's.

top 6 in ii2 had meenal, not ravi 😊 and antara's last name is mitra, not mali 😆

but yeah...i pretty much agree with ur list...for meenal i wud say same thing about antara/puja... 😊

tho i dont want emon to end up in amey's position...i have a feeling thas wats gonna happen... 😭 same for puja 😭

indian idol2 had 4 GREAT singers and two okay ones...
indian idol 3 has 3 GOOD singers and 3 baddd ones

o sorry but i thought it was ravi who was in top 6

ooh antara mali is that sexy actress sorry its antara mitra, 😆

Unlike Karunya, Amit hasn't been in the bottom three since the start of the galas. SO I think Amit has a good chance of winning. He has a lot of supporters (or at least ones that vote a lot) which I don't think Karu had since he was in the bottom three quite a few times.

Also, can't help but to compare Anuj to Ankita as both were wildcard entries, decided by the judges. Last year, the judges weren't happy with Anuj after his return. The situation is somewhat the same with Ankita.

I think Emon will be another Karunya. and Amit will be another Amey. and Prashant will be another Sandeep Acharya.(sandeep is much much much better than Prashant)

i think amit will be highly flattered if he knew he was in the same sopt as karunya, i love amit a lot but i still feel karunya was a world apart from everyone. one day amit will reach that position i hope.

o my god
its not singing i compared
from II3 no one will reach near to Karunya or Amey in singing
but i think the situation is some what same and most probably this will be going to happen in next eliminations.

Originally posted by: priyankumupal

i think amit will be highly flattered if he knew he was in the same sopt as karunya, i love amit a lot but i still feel karunya was a world apart from everyone. one day amit will reach that position i hope.

Oh yes, Karunya is a world apart...
Emon is nowhere close to Amey...

But we're just comparing the two shows and possible results.