II3, top 3 and 5 - Page 2

Thats ok Priya if you don't want to take a chill pill. I respect your opinion. First of all I don't think that II3 is looking for a singing talent per say. Singing may be the foundation of the show but doesn't dominate the show and that is very clear from Judges'comments and viewer's vote.
Comeon we are watching the show, not listening to and that makes all the difference in the world. If studying 18 hours can make you an IIT then practicing singing since the age of 4 should as well be. Finding talent is very hard and it should never be based on your performance, it should be based on potential. You don't have to write subject GRE to study a particular subject, its the overall aptitude that matters. Despite of how Ankita is performing on the show, she is the most talented in the lot and I stick to it.

I still feel that Emon is the best amonst guys and if the II3 is a male then it should be him, if its a female than that is Ankita. As far as Amit is concerned, I didn't even realize that he was in the show until now so may be he sang good, got good comments from the judges, I don't know.

Top 5: Puja,Amit,Deepali,Emon,Charu/Chang
Top 3: Puja,Deepali, Amit/Emon
Winner: Puja!

Originally posted by: pungi123

Thats ok Priya if you don't want to take a chill pill. I respect your opinion. First of all I don't think that II3 is looking for a singing talent per say. Singing may be the foundation of the show but doesn't dominate the show and that is very clear from Judges'comments and viewer's vote.
Comeon we are watching the show, not listening to and that makes all the difference in the world. If studying 18 hours can make you an IIT then practicing singing since the age of 4 should as well be. Finding talent is very hard and it should never be based on your performance, it should be based on potential. You don't have to write subject GRE to study a particular subject, its the overall aptitude that matters. Despite of how Ankita is performing on the show, she is the most talented in the lot and I stick to it.

I still feel that Emon is the best amonst guys and if the II3 is a male then it should be him, if its a female than that is Ankita. As far as Amit is concerned, I didn't even realize that he was in the show until now so may be he sang good, got good comments from the judges, I don't know.

Well your choice is yours and i respect it, well if you didn't notice Amit then what to do. Most of us at india forum noticed him and knew of his talent. Even i feel that Emon is at the top spot when it comes to boys but Amit has worked hard and now no longer can we say that Emon holds the top spot. As for Anki, i'm sure the show is still basicaly about finding a singing talent. If anki improves on her singing she'll move into the top spot very easily but from where she is now she might not be a good choice. But there are a lot more gala's to come. Emon can improve, Amit can improve, Anki can improve and all will and should have the right to be called a star.😉