Richa’s voice is annoying to me - Page 5

Originally posted by: sweetsorrow18

gah...its great to see that im not the only crazy one...that theres people who agree with me...

everytime i see her appear on screen i want to scream "why r u still here!"
i have nothing against her..shes a cute girl, very innocent, very naive and very sweet...LEKIN...and im sorry to say this...but she really CANNOT SING...its not that she will never be able to....but honestly speaking...as an avid musician and having personally having music knowledge and background...her voice is not mature enough to sing...thats it...simple fact...she doesnt not have the physical ability to sing at her age....her vocal chords are not even full developed for her to pull off certain notes...and no amount of practicing is going to do anything until she reaches around age 17..where her will accquire the a voice that will not change.....that is the main reason......i dont see why she is still put forward in the next round...i personally think its all because of her so called "x-factor" cause im sorry but there were better girls in the audition round then whut she sang today

I agree her voice is not good ,infact its irritating to see her still there .Shes there only because of her 'acting' innocent ! And that brainless anu malik !!

I also feel the judges where extremely partial n biased in her case .I mean common she forgot the lyrics and they still were nice to her ,remember the guy who forgot his lyrics anu malik even rejected the lady singing with him for no fault of hers !!!

Some ppl are using my post as a way to unleash their own tirade of hatred against richa.....I have mentioned earlier that I Don't Hate Richa....i quite find her adorable....and I also think she sings well...its just tht her voice is kinda immature and childish..and she has entered II a couple of yrs too soon...tht's all as for ppl makin a big deal abt all the harkat's she took....well...I guess she is a well-trained singer so if u got flaunt it..ehhh...wot say??? 😉

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

Since its not a personality contest, I wouldnt judge Richa on her behaviour. As for singing, I like her voice and think she has loads of potential but I do feel she overdoes the harkats. Overdoing harkats can sometimes take away frm the feel of the song----songs lik 'Ek nazar mein bhi...' r meant to be perky n lively but she made it sound too classical.

I wish she would sing in a more simple fashion and focus on singing the straight notes rathr thn tryin to add a harkat everywhere possible.

She needs to keep things simple rthr thn trying too hard to impress. Besides, it takes more thn singing a few harkats to make a good singer! Infact, anyone who's learnt carnatic music for 6mnths/1 yr can add the most complciated of harkats into a song.

But she is one of the best voices on the show, NO DOUBT!

agreed sneha!! couldn't have said it better myself! 👏

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

Since its not a personality contest, I wouldnt judge Richa on her behaviour. As for singing, I like her voice and think she has loads of potential but I do feel she overdoes the harkats. Overdoing harkats can sometimes take away frm the feel of the song----songs lik 'Ek nazar mein bhi...' r meant to be perky n lively but she made it sound too classical.

I wish she would sing in a more simple fashion and focus on singing the straight notes rathr thn tryin to add a harkat everywhere possible.

She needs to keep things simple rthr thn trying too hard to impress. Besides, it takes more thn singing a few harkats to make a good singer! Infact, anyone who's learnt carnatic music for 6mnths/1 yr can add the most complciated of harkats into a song.

But she is one of the best voices on the show, NO DOUBT!

See...tht's whr i disagree...right there...wht i put in bold....it's not tht i don't get impressed wit her singing skills...she is terrific..she can show voice modulations even many well-known singers won't be able to pull-off......BUT...her actual voice...the voice quality is not tht gr8..she sounds like a kid...very immature voice..I think she shld have let her voice grow up a couple of yra and then came on the show...coz the way her voice sounds right now is very kiddish...baaki she's one of the best SINGER on the show...but her voice is not the best...tht's hw i feel....😕

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

See...tht's whr i disagree...right there...wht i put in bold....it's not tht i don't get impressed wit her singing skills...she is terrific..she can show voice modulations even many well-known singers won't be able to pull-off......BUT...her actual voice...the voice quality is not tht gr8..she sounds like a kid...very immature voice..I think she shld have let her voice grow up a couple of yra and then came on the show...coz the way her voice sounds right now is very kiddish...baaki she's one of the best SINGER on the show...but her voice is not the best...tht's hw i feel....😕

she is a kid isnt she? and as time passes she will mature into a better singer...

Originally posted by: nibbler

she is a kid isnt she? and as time passes she will mature into a better singer...

I agree...she is a kid...soooo she shld have waited a couple of yrs b4 coming in II.....let's say she wanted to in a movie as a lead actress...and she was terrific at acting....would someone have cast her as a romantic lead looking the way she did..no matter hw well she acted..or in this case sings...there is a time for everything...and in my opinion she has been a bit hasty in entering II...but she's good nevertheless..so I wish all the best to her...😛

angierockzzz, i agree with you... well not in all aspects but at least in saying that her voice is childish... and her voice won't be suited for lead playback actress' voice either.. it would sound too childish...but she's a good singer.. and singing is totally different from acting in movies.. she can release her own albums until her voice matures.. and in her albums, she's not required to have a mature voice... but i know people may not vote for her because of these very reasons!!

yea.. i mean she singz well but ima not attracted to her voice for sum reazon..i guess she singz to high pitched..btw i agree itz kinda getting annoying 😕

her voice is good...but the extra harkat she takes..is......