3rd Week Judges Vs Judges - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

111

Views

5.9k

Users

17

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

coolprince143 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#31
Javed ji, I respect ur opinion and as I have said I think singing is the most important think of an indian idol, but other things do play a role.

In today's times an idol is chosen by the audience based on the X factor. So definately according to the audience people are looking for entertainment and just not for people to stand there and sing.

Also, if you are listining to a song on the radio than naturally the singer's singing is what you will concentrate on. But, if you are watching a performance u don't want to see someone holding the mike and just singing. You want to see their personality, them interacting with the audience, dancing and having fun.

An indian idol should be a blend of being a great singer, having confidence and having a outgoing and friendly nature.

Thanks
coolprince143 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: kothra

Omg...
where is alishaaaaaaaaaaa?...
plz yeh third time alisha haar bardash nahi karsakti 😆 😆 😆

I am already here, had written a comment even before you posted ur post. lol. I am trying my best, but siddh is so good.

Manshaa3 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#33
Udit Jiiii, Where r u? "Angleforu"
i think someone else from Udit Ji's team will show up?
Who ever is it. Please show up. 👍🏼
siddh_v thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#34
Alishaji aap hume batiye X-factor kya hai????? Kuch nahi hai X-factor. X-factor II ke phichli judge ka weham tha. X-factor logo ki baniye who man ghadan baat hai. Playback singer ke paas x-factor ka kya phaida. Filam maine jab gana gaye ga to log uski shakal se , yah persnality se pasand karen ge yaah uske gane se. khan gaye x-factor wale Qazi or Sandeep Acharya, kyoon unke ek ek album nikale aur uske baad kuch nahi??? Kyoon Qazi aur Sandeep ke bare maine koi news nahi????

Dusri baat hindi music industry maine Sangeet ka badsha kaun hai?? Pancham da unke paas kaunsa x-factor tha??? Lata ji unki awaz hi unka x-factor hai.

Koi x-factor nahi hota aur agar hota bhi hai to ek baar Indian Idol bane ke baad contestant sab kuch kar sakta hai. Woh II ka rutba usko confident kar deta hai, II ke pehchan uski personality ko nikhar dete hai, uske fan's usko sawar dete hai. Magar awaz maine dum nahi, agar sur pake nahi to kuch nahi hoon sakta.
siddh_v thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: coolprince143

I am already here, had written a comment even before you posted ur post. lol. I am trying my best, but siddh is so good.



😆
anonmember thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: siddh_v

Alishaji aap hume batiye X-factor kya hai????? Kuch nahi hai X-factor. X-factor II ke phichli judge ka weham tha. X-factor logo ki baniye who man ghadan baat hai. Playback singer ke paas x-factor ka kya phaida. Filam maine jab gana gaye ga to log uski shakal se , yah persnality se pasand karen ge yaah uske gane se. khan gaye x-factor wale Qazi or Sandeep Acharya, kyoon unke ek ek album nikale aur uske baad kuch nahi??? Kyoon Qazi aur Sandeep ke bare maine koi news nahi????

Dusri baat hindi music industry maine Sangeet ka badsha kaun hai?? Pancham da unke paas kaunsa x-factor tha??? Lata ji unki awaz hi unka x-factor hai.

Koi x-factor nahi hota aur agar hota bhi hai to ek baar Indian Idol bane ke baad contestant sab kuch kar sakta hai. Woh II ka rutba usko confident kar deta hai, II ke pehchan uski personality ko nikhar dete hai, uske fan's usko sawar dete hai. Magar awaz maine dum nahi, agar sur pake nahi to kuch nahi hoon sakta.




Excellent points!! 👏
Way to represent JA team! 😃
Edited by sonyaee - 18 years ago
coolprince143 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#37

Javed Ji very good points. What I think X factor is a person having a good personality. Qazi won fame gurukul because he had the looks and the personality, not the singing. Same can be said about Sandeep. While Arjit and Karunya had the singing but not the looks and the outgoing personality. Arjit on the other hand was a bit rude. However we can see who won the "khitab," the people that had the looks and personality. Again in contest like the Indian Idol it is proven that singing plays a role but looks and character are also taken into account by audiences when they choose their idols.

saan1997 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#38
X-FACTOR!Main yani Anu malik I I 1 se yehi baat bol raha hoo aur ye sab log samajhate hi nahi hai.Do u think that Abhijeet won because of X-FACTOR.Abhi ye log(Javed A.)sur ki baat kar rahe hain.Kya unko maaloom hai sur kya hai?Agar maaloom hai to gaa ke batao😉.Alisha,Tum bhi,sur ki baat karti ho?Pop singer ka sur se kya lena dena?Mujhe to lag rha hai ki main BEEN bajaa raha hoo.Kiske aage, aap log samajh jao😃.Hamara SONU X/factor bardasht nahi kar paya aur chala gaya😕.Rahi baat Udit ki,kaafi samajhdaar hai.Main jo bhi kahata hoo manta hai!So participants,be careful,this time we are not going tolerate besuras and i promise u all that this time I I 3 winner is going to be the best singer among all the music shows.Main aur udit sab thik kar denge,I mean sab ko thik kar denge😉.Keep supporting indian idol 3.So the decision has been taken and this time we are going to judge on the base of singing.Just remembered a beautyful song from the film BASANT BAHAR"sur na sadhe,kya gaoon mai,sur ke bina jeevan soona😊.Jai hind.
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: saan1997

X-FACTOR!Main yani Anu malik I I 1 se yehi baat bol raha hoo aur ye sab log samajhate hi nahi hai.Do u think that Abhijeet won because of X-FACTOR.Abhi ye log(Javed A.)sur ki baat kar rahe hain.Kya unko maaloom hai sur kya hai?Agar maaloom hai to gaa ke batao😉.Alisha,Tum bhi,sur ki baat karti ho?Pop singer ka sur se kya lena dena?Mujhe to lag rha hai ki main BEEN bajaa raha hoo.Kiske aage, aap log samajh jao😃.Hamara SONU X/factor bardasht nahi kar paya aur chala gaya😕.Rahi baat Udit ki,kaafi samajhdaar hai.Main jo bhi kahata hoo manta hai!So participants,be careful,this time we are not going tolerate besuras and i promise u all that this time I I 3 winner is going to be the best singer among all the music shows.Main aur udit sab thik kar denge,I mean sab ko thik kar denge😉.Keep supporting indian idol 3.So the decision has been taken and this time we are going to judge on the base of singing.Just remembered a beautyful song from the film BASANT BAHAR"sur na sadhe,kya gaoon mai,sur ke bina jeevan soona😊.Jai hind.

Arre Vaa ...yeh huin na baat ...👏 👏👏👏...kya boli aapne....fantastic ..awesome ..Lajawab ....bahut khub😛😛

Maya and Raunaq mujhe bhi woh pom poms chahiye😊...

But now Anu ji is on a roll without dhol..👏👏...keep rocking ..😃

siddh_v thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: coolprince143

Javed Ji very good points. What I think X factor is a person having a good personality. Qazi won fame gurukul because he had the looks and the personality, not the singing. Same can be said about Sandeep. While Arjit and Karunya had the singing but not the looks and the outgoing personality. Arjit on the other hand was a bit rude. However we can see who won the "khitab," the people that had the looks and personality. Again in contest like the Indian Idol it is proven that singing plays a role but looks and character are also taken into account by audiences when they choose their idols.



Alishaji wohi to maine bhi ke raha hoon????? Khitab jitne ke baad , ek album nikale ne ke baad age kya hua???? Wohi to is debate ka tatparye hai??? Loog apne Idol ko galat factor pe pasand kar rahe hain.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".