Trained VS Untrained singers..whoz betta?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Mansi

@angelicsmile

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: yu.r.fat.

r u sure about dat? cus i swear his dad was like a big music director or singer or something..so how can he not be trained? n plus hes bengali n most of dem r trained in either singing or dancing?

i knw KK isnt classically trained n god i love him!

hey now that u told me bout KK i m not sure if shaan was trained or not..
i knew one of them wasnt but i m confused now..lol😆

Quote

Pri

@pc84

Dazzler

Posted: 18 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: yu.r.fat.
yes u need a good voice but voice can also be moduled into d way u wnat it to be..just cus ONE trained singer i.e richa was rude to her partner just cus shes immature doesnt mean ur gunna balme everyone.

woh. dude.. no body is saying that trained singers are rude or anything.. we are not catagorizing anyone here..

To me Richa is rude.. if she wanted she would have helped prashant instead of giving him soo much trouble!! ok. i give her that she has an amazing voice.. maybe cuz she is trained and maybe she has born talent.. but her manners.. uFF!!... and no matter what age you are you need to learn something called common courtesy!! something that we all learn from a very YOUNG AGE!! I knew from a very young age that no matter what.. Never Look Down On Anyone!! and Prashant is older than her.. instead of respecting him.. she is disregarding him..

i think she needs to be work on her manners before she comes into II again!! i mean if she is soo uptight now.. wat will happen after she becomes Indian Idol.. IF she becomes Indian Idol!!

OOo.. i agree.. both her and prashant wil be in the top28... right beside my Meiyang!!😳

luv pri

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Mansi Sharma

@music_rules

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#13

the untrained at least don't consider themselves superior then others 😉

Quote

gopalbhai

@gopalbhai

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: miss17

hey now that u told me bout KK i m not sure if shaan was trained or not..
i knew one of them wasnt but i m confused now..lol😆

In Saregamapa Little Champs, Bappi Lahari was describing how well Shaan's father(Whom Bappiji knew quite well) prononunced Urdu when singing ghaazal even though he happened to be a Bengali. At least ghazal won't be tried by totally untrained singers . So. it is cleat Shaan's father was trained in music.

It is quite ulikely that Shaan was not introduced to music by his father.

Quote

fazila

@**Fazila_Sui**

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: mansi101590
the untrained at least don't consider themselves superior then others 😉

yep richa defo got an ego problem..n yh prashant will make it far

Quote

Hunyum

@xaphan

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: faiza111

yep richa defo got an ego problem..n yh prashant will make it far

swear...richa has too much attitude problem...but if we see i guess untrianed are better..coz they dont have the "ghuroor" in dere voice dat they are trained and are better...the attitude u sing wid really matters!