which is better?

judges judging the show or public voting?

if it's judges then people argue that how can 3 people make correct decision?

if it's janta then people blame that they are voting blindly?

if it's 50-50 then still it doesn't make sense.

i don't know to what extend janta can vote sensibly. as even we see here that every contestant has so many fans. same is with janta. also people votes varies from looks, cuteness, regionism, pleasing personality, family background etc.

i don't know what the format should be as i think we will always find unfairness in judgement.

liek fame gurukuls idea of onli sending those ppl in danger who the judges put in danger

but i didnt liek the idea that 1 person comes in by janta votes...and 1 comes in my contestant votes

both shud come in by janta votes and teh last leaves

atleast that way the judges can keep the good ones till the end!!! but styl it didnt happen with fame gurukul becuz judges put rong ppl in danger at times...and the faculty saved rong ppl

but i liked the idea of it

but did they succeed in doing that in FG? janta voted for just one guy.

Originally posted by: srk_lover

liek fame gurukuls idea of onli sending those ppl in danger who the judges put in danger

but i didnt liek the idea that 1 person comes in by janta votes...and 1 comes in my contestant votes

both shud come in by janta votes and teh last leaves

atleast that way the judges can keep the good ones till the end!!! but styl it didnt happen with fame gurukul becuz judges put rong ppl in danger at times...and the faculty saved rong ppl

but i liked the idea of it

megha!! that's what i wrote. some section of people will always feel unfairness even with judges or janta judging.

India bole to 50-50 😉 👏

I have even better solution!!! MAKE ME JUDGE!!!!! 😆😆😆

Originally posted by: thhikana

India bole to 50-50 😉 👏

I have even better solution!!! MAKE ME JUDGE!!!!! 😆😆😆

good one thhikana!! :)) so amit sana 1st indian diol?

Well, not a single format is fool proof !!
Let it be decided by program directors which faulty format they adopt to fool us !! 'coz at the end of the day, we - fans get emotional but it doesnt make any difference to those ppl's lives....

peace

Originally posted by: Anjali.Nair

good one thhikana!! :)) so amit sana 1st indian diol?

😆😆😆 I would have make Aditi 1st Indian Idol!!! coz b4 Amit I used like Aditi 😆😆😆

i think every way has its own pluses and minuses, we have to the best of everything and use the best available choice in the most effective way.
public voting has worked in the rest of the idol programmes in other countries.

there shud be a jury of abt 10-12b people deciding who shud leave