Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge or Indian Idol

Please reply. i have always wondered what other people think on this matter.

i personally think its Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2005. I think the quality of singing is far better. The final episode rocked, however it was quite sad. only one winner got everything. and i personally liked vinit.

please vote and leave a comment if you have time.

VINIT ROCKS.

😃 Indian Idol! Becuase they make this show interesting and they have good quilty singers

SRGMP anyday its more singing and there were so many singers giving power packed performences "nahi samne" by hemu, "i love u" by nihira, "jiya dhadhak dhadhak" by himmani, "tera jadoo chal gaya" vinit etc. and many many more the quality of singing is so much better there ......in indian idol u see amey giving good performences (he is an x SRGM contestant) and karunya who is generally good, antara is hot and cold other than those 3 no ones even good enough to get into the final stages of the SRGMP (the one where they select 10 contestants) so basically they are just not good enough even ppl like abhijeet sawant are nothing when compared to hemachanda or sharib etc. he is hyped and made huge the only good thing indian idol has apart from its 2 or 3 contestants is sonu nigam who has an amazing knowladge abt music and the best male singer in the country doing playback.

I like SRGMP cause of mentors. especially Ismail Ji n Himesh! 😃

and also cause of Vinit, Himani, Hemu N Sharib 😃

Hi

These two shows are different from each other...both are good...SRGMP concentrates only on singing while II looks for a complete package...

I personally think II is better...it has every dose of entertainment...and i think there is no denying that II and its contestants are the most talked abt and most followed amongst all the shows...

SRGMP is very good in its place...but I would put II above it...it has everything...

II rocks.

i would say indian idol. 😛

Indian Idol Rocks...
It Rocks bcoz of Sonu, Anu, Farah, Aman and Mini Mathur..
And Bcoz of the Wonderful Contestants...

SRGMP C 2005..

sofar we saw very good singers emmerging fro m this compitations and final 12 countdown was very exciting , also conterversis and lots of drams on set...

IL2 is also good with singers like Amey n Karunya (both are best) but comparing to last year IL .. this year is bit dull

My vote goes for SRGMP, though I follow II2 more regularly than SRGMP. SRGMAP has a tradition to provide all rounders and more trained singers. Thus, i think only very very talented singers apply for this competition. which is not the case with II2 (Check out funny videos of II2).

Moreover, yesterday I was listening all MP3 songs of SRGMP and II2 and II1 and I can conclude that SRGMP singers are better than II2, undoubtly. Even standard of II1 was better than II2. If you leave Amey, Karu and Meenal, the whole competition is flop.