antara is not that good!!!!!!!! - Page 2

Well - just an honest and unbiased opinion from Australia. I apologise if I offend Antara fans. Antara's demeanour are so artificial that it becomes sometimes annoying. She may become the Indian Idol because she knows how emotionally blackmail public with melodrama. Too smart and too cunning - not a hallmark of a great singer - yes but truely all the qualities of a successful performer in today's world.

I particularly like Amey and Karunya.

"Too smart and too cunning"

what? how can you tell? oh wait let me guess, she cried on stage...jeez people, let that go! i'm gonna take a WILD guess here and assume that hmm, maybe she's emotional? (i know, gosh, how is that possible? emotions are so overrated 😆 😉 )

and the emotionally blackmail part, how can you discredit the public so much to think that they would be affected by that? i think everyone and their mom has noticed that she cries every episode and wouldn't they think "oh, she is just doing it for public vote." i mean, if everyone notices it, why would she STILL get votes?? (this doesn't mean i understand how the public votes, i'm just as clueless as the next person)

she is an awesome singer and has so much talent. i think it's strange that instead of encouraging her for not being in the bottom 3, people find random faults to discredit her.

i'm an antara fan, obviously, but i didn't take offense to what you said...i think you just need to be more careful on what you say bc there's no way you can tell by looking at someone how they are in real life...remember what they say "don't judge a book by it's cover"

Both Antara and Meenal are good. Come on Antara's not a bad singer, though I'm still a MEENAL fan. 😛

antara is a average singer at best
meenal beats her any day

I think Antara needs to work on her pronunciation BADLY! During today's performance, while singing Bairi Piya..she was like Beri Piya.. I can't take it anymore. Even when she sang Zara Zara, her pronunciation and diction was off in so many places. She over does it. She's good in crying and thats what she does best. I think her whole crying melodrama is going to work in her favor again this episode and she's not going to come in bottom 3. It's really sad!! Meenal is a far better singer!!

i always loved meenal's singing except her singing today which was plain awful with no feeling or sur (didnt suit her voice at all). ANTARA WAS SOOO AVERAGE AND PLAIN AS USUAL. even her sur was lost in the singing and was no where near as good as shreya ghoshal.

Originally posted by: indiangirl19

I think Antara needs to work on her pronunciation BADLY! During today's performance, while singing Bairi Piya..she was like Beri Piya.. I can't take it anymore. Even when she sang Zara Zara, her pronunciation and diction was off in so many places. She over does it. She's good in crying and thats what she does best. I think her whole crying melodrama is going to work in her favor again this episode and she's not going to come in bottom 3. It's really sad!! Meenal is a far better singer!!

I seriously hope not all Meenal fans are like this...I mean, both girls deserve to be in the top 4. instead of criticizing those who really need it, people are going for antara (which makes no sense...crying = votes? 😡😡)

she sees her parents after how long...why would you blame her for crying? come on guys, thts so wrong and mean, not to mention...

let's leave the actual judging to the judges, it's what they do BEST.

I THINK MEENAL IS UNDER RATED BUT SHE IS VERY GOOD

grt going.. just keep criticising her as much as u can..very good job.
i just wonder here so many threads against antara though she didnt do anyting..
let me say one thing.. u r jeal of her talent nd for getting her a lot of votes from every whr of india.. dat im sure wont be stop wat ever u pple say..
antara rox..

I agree that Antara is an Avg singer,BUt she desrves to be in top3 among remaining contestants