HOW SHOULD THE PUBLIC JUDGE AND VOTE?

How should the public judge and vote? Which of the following criteria should they use?

1. SINGING 2. PEFORMANCE 3. Ex- F ACTORS LIKE: GRACE, INNOCENCE, SINCERITY 4. REGION 5. CASTE OR CREED 6. POLITICS AND FAVOURITISM

Personally, I would use only the first two or [at the most] three criteria and completely reject the last three as extraneous, unethical and wrong.

Am I right, friends? What do YOU think? Express yourself !!

Sim

Originally posted by: simar malhans

How should the public judge and vote? Which of the following criteria should they use?

1. SINGING 2. PEFORMANCE 3. E-F ACTORS LIKE: GRACE, INNOCENCE, SINCERITY 4. REGION 5. CASTE OR CREED 6. POLITICS AND FAVOURITISM

Personally, I would use only the first two or [at the most] three criteria and completely reject the last three as extraneous, unethical and wrong.

Am I right, friends? What do YOU think? Express yourself !!

Sim

I knw abt X-factor but what is E-factor

All 1,2,3 qualities should b der in II. He shud b multi-talented.. looks good, humble human, great performer and offcourse xcellent singer..

Originally posted by: Decent_Girl

I knw abt X-factor but what is E-factor

All 1,2,3 qualities should b der in II. He shud b multi-talented.. looks good, humble human, great performer and offcourse xcellent singer..

wat do u mean he? it cud also be she

Originally posted by: srk_lover

wat do u mean he? it cud also be she

Ya cud be but ma expectation is again from male.. n u knw whom I m talkin abt !!! 😳

DECENT GIRL:
FRANKLY, I DO NOT KNOW THE ORIGIN OF THE USE OF X AS IN X FACTOR. X CAN BE USED TO SHOW A KISS OR, AS IN MATHEMATICS, AN UNKNWON QUANTITY. IT IS QUITE POSSIBLE THAT X IN X FACTOR MAY REFER TO THE OPERATION OF UNKNOWN OR UNKNOWABLE FORCES. SACHIN TENDULKAR REMAINS POPULAR DESPITE HIS POOR PERFORMANCES IN RECENT YEARS. IT IS SAID THAT THIS IS DUE TO X(UNKNOWN) FACTOR.

E-FACTORS WAS A MISPRINT AND I HAVE ALREADY CORRECTED THE MISTAKE. WHAT I INTENDED WAS "EXTRA" OR EX-FACTORS. AND IT IS HIGHLY PROBABLE THAT X IS THE SAME AS EX, THAT IS EXTRA. COMPARE YOUR SUBSTITUION OF XCELLENT [X] FOR EXCELLENT [EX]!!

SO I REACH THE CONCLUSION THAT X IS REALLY EX=EXTRA.

THANKS DECENT GIRL FOR TH PROVOCATION !
SIM

For me it is no.1 and no.2 But no. 1 is more important maybe 70-30 split. For me no. 3 is a combination of 1 and 2 ........if someone sings and performs good they have X-factor according to me 😊 .

Judging by no.4 5 or 6 is 🤢 and 😡

First singing,then performance and X factor or watever.But I dont think anything else shud influence the voting

This is an interesting topic. I am sure no one disagrees that voting should be purely guided by one's understanding of the candidate's ability. One's ability is ,of course, shaped by one's innate talent, and modified by one's diligence, effort, and the X-factor. Considering this, factors 4 and 5 don't figure anywhere.

But, despite a general acceptance of this basic theory, we should be aware that the human mind is not so simple; the sub-conscious is always going to play into one's decision to vote. And, then, there are personal differnces in nature which also shape people's decisions.

A person like me would vote emotionally(fortunately/unfortunately I can't vote from the US);thus, even though I feel that Karunya , Amey,and Antara are superior singers, my tendency would be to vote for Panna or Meenal(she is ,to me, in the same league as the top 3 singers I mentioned + has an innocence/inherent goodness about her, just like Panna).
Then, I also feel sorry for Karunya, because, there are enough people out ther who vote based on regionalism; generally, contestants from South India suffer because of this trend. So, I would probably vote for him over the others. It is just complex.

An intellectually motivated person will have a different way of thinking and so on.

In short, how one should vote and how one does vote are two different things, most of the times.

on pts 1 2 n 3 plus entertainer how tht person acts wth the cam!!
in short like panna n amey!!
n also antara