Something is different in Idol 2... - Page 2

Hi
I agree with you amey is a very good signer……. I been to most of the sites online and I can see how popular he is I was so surprised when I heard judges comments they said Amy didn't sing well………….. common I think that was one of his best perfumes I think they want a girl to be a Indian idol b they asked meenal who is the hottest guy she said amey they mad a story that meenal amey love each other amey never said he likes her but it did ruin his reputation …… ……….janta doesn't want to hear the love story it's a music challenge…………. show they want hear good songs …that's way the didn't vote for booth of them sonu keep praising meanls alaaps and lambi lambi taans he himself never sang a. …………….classical song In the movies with lambi lambi taans they said ravi was a good instead of ravi the sandeep should have been In bottom three? Isn't strange they wanted sandeep to go out…………for ravis one good performs very unfair… ………I also agree with you judges always change their comments ….so what should we believe the first comments or the next so many ppl vote on judges comments as they think judges have good knowledge of music……………... Then next day they feel fool of their self to hear totally different comments… Meenal had been in bottom three for four times ………….but still in the show??? Monali and panna were the victims of bad comments I think panna was good a performer monali….. Was good singer better then meenal………… (he sings form her nasal) each time I watch the show my heart sinks that we gona lose one of our favorite singer …never saw something like that In any other shows even sa re ga ma show hosted by sonu was a much better show all the judges were so fair the did justice to show even idol 1 was much better I think if they want to do Indian idol 111………….and want ppl to watch the show the they should chose amey as a Indian idol……….sandeep is not a bade singer his voice………. Similarity to udit ji may bee his bad factor sonu mention so much that In last gala he tried to change his voice and missed the track its very unfair….. For a jugde t0 repeat his comments . in American idol there was a girl whose voice matched the signer pula Abdul ….. one of the judges when she finish the song Simon one of the jugdes paid her the complement that first time I herd something better then the organelle…….. I think the judges should be honest to deserving ones...one of judges started playing games he knows form the last experience that who ever juged saying is good ppl voting them out or putting them In bottom three… so he has changed his strategy to his favorites he is not paying good comments ……. And who dos not disserve to be in the show he is so good…….but he failed …..ppl have their on choice they are not listening to there comments.. I just have a simple question is this show is for signers dancers or good looks …I think they should see the original show in that all colures sizes don't matter just a good singer the first American idol was a 800 lb a black guy Amey .Antra …Karunya are the best if anyone of them is gone there will be nothing interesting left in the show
It's just my opinions didn't mean to hurt any bodies feeling

I agree

The judges comments are very misleading. they should be honest I feel.

Originally posted by: Ahmed143

I dunno whether to agree with u or not...

but let me very honestly tell you. I am one of the biggest fans of Amey...and even I felt that Amey would be in bottom me (plz dont start saying that he shouldnt have been)...the moment i listened to him, my intuition said that he would definitely be in bottom 3 and I think same was the case with Anu Malik...

and I dont think that II is fake as u said.....if they want to make the show popular by doing so, then they wouldn't have let Panna to go out. and Anu Malik never said that Amey sang badly...it was his sixth sense that made him say that Amey might be in danger

I dont disagree with you very strongly.....coz I also think somewhat like you....but on the whole, u r not 100% rite (my personal opinion)

i agree widu...but wut is kinda weird dat panna always got such high amount of votes but den wen he actually sang gud they throw him out😕

After this weeks result I think it is appropriate to revive this topic. This week again the same thing happened: Karunia ended up in bottom 3. He was the best singer this week and I do not see any reason for him to be in bottom 3. This again proves my point that there is manipulation going on to increase the shock effect of every result round. I am positive that Sandeep and Ajay would have got less votes than Karunia but Karunia was put in bottom 3 to retain the shock element. If you watch the pattern from last few galas then you will notice that Amey and Karunia are placed in bottom 3 alternetely. One week it is Amey then the next week it is Karunia. So this week do not be surprised to see Karunia safe and Amey in bottom 3.