Amey sounded off key!!! - Page 14

It was a tough song but he sounded off key in the "Dingi danga dinga" part. He was very confident singing it. If anyone else sung same way as he did, Sonu and Anu use faad dete.

THe only parts he didnt do good was when he would LOUDLY SCREAM RANG DE BASANTIIIII i didnt like the ending IIIII

Other than that it was pretty good 😊

Sorry about my previous post here.

Please vote for Amey, Karunya, Meenal and Antara

Originally posted by: harshmm

Whats going on here?
Please mods can we close this thread.
Hey guys, some of the detractors are saying we are not critisizing and are only pointing faults. If it was constructive crtisizm we all can understand.
But "distractors" it doesn't sound like it to me. You guys seem jealous of Amey.
Please stop this guys.

Moderator's Note: I have quoted harsh, however, this is in general reference to everyone's feelings here.... closing the thread will not solve the problems. i still find 90% of the replies on this thread well discussed. The rest of them have been edited. Any singer should be able to face criticism just as they would appreciate praise when they do a good job. Personally, I feel all the singers have had their good days and their bad days. whether it was amey's good day or bad day yesterday is left upto the people to decide. However, we cannot expect people not to voice their opinions. I am an amey fan too. However, that does not mean, no one should utter one single word against him. Please remember that it is criticism that will help a person sharpen his skills. The members who opened this thread have repeatedly mentioned that they like amey as a singer and they felt his performance yesterday was not up to the mark. what is the point of taking it out on the members personally? They have been kind and rational in their discussions. Please be more open minded in listening to other's comments. 😊 It will really help you understand your contestant better and in a way help him sharpen his skills to become the nation's favourite singer.

Harsh, I think some of these newbies are paid by someone to come here and criticize Amey. Amey & Karu were best yesterday, even Meenal.

Moderator's Note: do you know that for sure?😊 please dont make accusations without proof. it is very hurting for newbies who genuinely want to express their views

The results show wot exactly this thread is all about, but Amey didn't sing that bad 2 b in bottom 2.
No offense, I am a big fan of Amey n Karunya, i think they are the top 2 in II2.

Hello gamezone,

Itz not just abt newbies, moderators will u plz wakeup n take action on statements like this abt new members.

Moderator's Note: again, are you sure that all the mods are sleeping all the while? II has threads opened at the rate of 1 for every two minutes and even more replies. On top of many mods are busy with more than two sections too. Besides, all of us have exams/family/health/children/etc to take care of... there is generally some or the other GM online. you can always pm them if utmost urgency arises. We try putting in our maximum effort to make this section fun with games and contests and edit when posts go insinuating. Please try to respect the fact that IF does not run on a strictly shift basis. We are doing this voluntarily and so we may not be able to read all replies and posts 24/7. you can always help us by pming us personally if you feel something is wrong. Thank you 😊

Originally posted by: marymathew

Great!
I was thinking If i spoke about this today, I'd have bricks thrown on me by all the hardcore Amey fans.. I too generally like Amey, but yesterday i think he paid TOO much attention to the song, that he lost track of the singing. Agreed, that Daler put his might to that song, I really didnt think it suited Amey well.

I kept thinking to myself, was I the only one who thought he sounded loud and off key? Sonu seemed to like it, and i always thought he was one to give rite comments.

Can anyone agree with me that Ravi ACTUALLY did a rather fine job yesterday?? He sounded WAAAAYYY better than he normally does!

For once, i thought this competition is getting really tough!!

Ravi sounded well because the song required a nasal touch to it😆😆 but he DID sound good.

Originally posted by: harshmm

Whats going on here?
Please mods can we close this thread.
Hey guys, some of the detractors are saying we are not critisizing and are only pointing faults. If it was constructive crtisizm we all can understand.
But "distractors" it doesn't sound like it to me. You guys seem jealous of Amey.
Please stop this guys.

Do we consider ourselves better judges of music than sonu and Anu?
Please guys , why throw mud at such a great talent in the show.
Please don't do this! We don't want to loose them. For me Amey, Karunya, Meenal and Antara are the top 4 by a huge margin from the others and we don't want to loose any of them befor that.
If you have anything consturctive to say , you can say it.
Otherwise,lets help these 4 get to top 4.

Please vote for Amey, Karu, Meenal and Antara.

How can you say that as Amey is being criticised by his fans! Now, this is bad....
Gauri Khan is the biggest critic of SRK, it is because she loves him and wants him to do better!

watch todays' episodes, Sonu and Anu criticised Amey too...

Originally posted by: sonyaee

Who said he was imitating Daler? Of course, he can't sing this song that way he sang Tu Hi Re or Suno Na. Every song comes with its own style and flavor and you can deviate and improvise but how much? Why are you comparing Amey's song to Karyuna's anyway? Yeah, he sang a Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan song but so did Meenal and she to improvise as well. Compare Amey's to the original if anything. His song was of much high pitch than the others.

He himself admitted that...

I am an Amey fan but feling like an outcaste here... come on people, our favourites do mistakes too!