Amey/Antara/Meenal -- Only talents in II2

TruthWins thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Hey guys,

Would agree with me, that talent wise only Amey, Meenal and Antara are good. Karunya can only sing Punjabi songs. He failed when he tried chak de and hum tum and ai mere zohar zabi.

WAIT WAIT don't through stones at me, honestly ask yourself. He was correct technically, he was in sur, thats not what I meant. There was no feel in his singing in those three songs and thats why he was in bottom 3.

Well this is how I would honestly choose my idol

Karunya - only punjabi songs. Honestly ask yourself other than that would you feel moved or involve in the song when he is singing. No right so how can he become an idol, he cannot inspire people with his singing. Also he is always after girls. So A BIG NO NO to Karunya

Amey -- Awesome singer, you get involved when he sings, good looking also.

But a Big NO from myside because of his conceitedness and the diciet and also his dishonesty. God bless the girls who are willing to marry him. Then they'll see the true side.

Antara -- Awesome singer, but not as good as Amey in moving you so I put Amey above her. Also she is very deceited. so A BIG NO from me.

Meenal -- Talent wise in the same calibre as Amey, you are involved and she inspires and moves you.

She is the best personality on the show. Great attitude and humble person.

So she is the next INDIAN IDOL automatically.

So the top two can be Meenal and Amey and I want Meenal to win because I don't want a deceited person to be and idol.

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

1.6k

Users

6

Frequent Posters

innocent_devil thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
yeah i agree with you but i think karunya too is a good singer
smartalec21 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: TruthWins

Hey guys,

Would agree with me, that talent wise only Amey, Meenal and Antara are good. Karunya can only sing Punjabi songs. He failed when he tried chak de and hum tum and ai mere zohar zabi.

WAIT WAIT don't through stones at me, honestly ask yourself. He was correct technically, he was in sur, thats not what I meant. There was no feel in his singing in those three songs and thats why he was in bottom 3.

Well this is how I would honestly choose my idol

Karunya - only punjabi songs. Honestly ask yourself other than that would you feel moved or involve in the song when he is singing. No right so how can he become an idol, he cannot inspire people with his singing. Also he is always after girls. So A BIG NO NO to Karunya

Amey -- Awesome singer, you get involved when he sings, good looking also.

But a Big NO from myside because of his conceitedness and the diciet and also his dishonesty. God bless the girls who are willing to marry him. Then they'll see the true side.

Antara -- Awesome singer, but not as good as Amey in moving you so I put Amey above her. Also she is very deceited. so A BIG NO from me.

Meenal -- Talent wise in the same calibre as Amey, you are involved and she inspires and moves you.

She is the best personality on the show. Great attitude and humble person.

So she is the next INDIAN IDOL automatically.

So the top two can be Meenal and Amey and I want Meenal to win because I don't want a deceited person to be and idol.

Total B***S**T...the order in terms of talent has to be:

1. AMEY

2. Karu

3. Meenal/Antara...

all else reasoning is c**p

swt.smile thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
I agree...Now that my PANNA left 😭 ..The best are Amey, Antara & Meenal ...BUT MY IDOL IS ALWAYS GONNA STAY PANNA GILL!!! 😛 [ He needs to come back ] 😭 ..So yeh you're right..Amey , Antara & Meenal are the best. I don't get ..how come Panna got voted out before Ravi & Anuj ..Lols I mean he's much much much better than them...
TruthWins thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
I just mean to put my views across.
Well smartalec, if you have different views you can put them across. You honestly ask yourself, did ever get moved so much by Karunya to put him infront of Meenal who is such a great talent. She is way above him.
Well anyway I respect your openion too, whether you respect mine or not.
You are saying my explanation is crap. I would say you are unwilling to dig a little deeper and accept the truth.
chitti123 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
Why is Amey dishonest? Ofcourse Meenal,Amey are best but it is not fare if you say Karunaya is not a good singer. What is his fault if he is getting less votes like Meenal. If Antara is getting more votes than Meenal and Karunaya it doesn't mean she is better than both. Meenal and Karunaya are not lucky in getting votes.

I wish Amey, Meenal, Karunaya should be in top3.

1)Amey/Karunaya
2)Meenal

But i think Meenal or Karunaya may be out in next gala. So get ready for a shock. This time u may get shattered not shocked.
Edited by chitti123 - 19 years ago
TruthWins thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
Well I didn't say Karunya is not a good singer. I said he is technically right, but not passionate about singing like Amey and Meenal are.
You listen to Amey and You listen Karunya, though he is in sur you won't enjoy his singing, because there is no soul in it.
He is getting less votes because junta don't get inspired by his songs. The only time he got votes was those two punjabi numbers.
If you remember well he was once not selected in the top 50 straight away and was given a second chance.
Try to listen to those Amey/Meenal/Antara and then listen to Karunya and then you will understand what I am saying.
I am not against anyone.
I am just stating the qualities that make a person Indian Idol.
Think for yourself, would you accept Karunya as your Indian Idol, then you'll understand what I said.
Anyway I respect your openion Chitti
deslovetiny thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

~~~Antara is BEst~~~

She deserves To WIN!!

She will WIN it...Wait n WAtch! 😃

Edited by karish89 - 19 years ago
TruthWins thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: karish89

~~~Antara is BEst~~~

She deserves To WIN!!

She will WIN it...Wait n WAtch! 😃

All the best , God bless!

smartalec21 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: TruthWins

I just mean to put my views across.
Well smartalec, if you have different views you can put them across. You honestly ask yourself, did ever get moved so much by Karunya to put him infront of Meenal who is such a great talent. She is way above him.
Well anyway I respect your openion too, whether you respect mine or not.
You are saying my explanation is crap. I would say you are unwilling to dig a little deeper and accept the truth.

well..dude.. i was just callin yr explanation c**p...infact i actually happen to like meenal a lot...next to amey..but i still have to say tht talent wise... karu is far ahead of meenal...even meenal has given some weak performances...and u r askin me abt involvement then i have to honestly say tht i never feel involved in meenal's singin....it's good but not mesmerising...u seem to smitten by her and hence think tht whtever she does is flawless..but i beg to differ...

and P.S...i'm sorry if i've offended u i didn't mean to..i was just expressin wht i felt readin ur post..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".